How did you score dawson adamak

[realheavyhands]

Considering adamak was tripped and it shouldnt have been a knockdown,

[Left2body]

Considering adamak was tripped and it shouldnt have been a knockdown,

Regardless a judge can't negate a knockdown which the Ref has regarded as legal. Either way KD or not I had it 10rds to 2rds for Chad, there knockdowns negated each other but he would've won without the trip anyway.

[PRboxingfan]

Left2Body is right, the KD is legit because the Ref called it. I had every round except the 10th and 11th for Dawson.

[realheavyhands]

Left2Body is right, the KD is legit because the Ref called it. I had every round except the 10th and 11th for Dawson.

ok.. if you were the referee how did you score it

[tito yuca]

I had it 118-110

[realheavyhands]

the proper scoring would have been 116-111

[mECHsLAVE]

Actually, you guys are wrong. A judge can still score a round 10-9 regardless if the ref rules a KD or not. It was a clear trip and not a KD, and if the judges saw that, then yes they can score it 10-9. A round does not have to be scored 10-8 simply because the ref rules a KD.

But it's a moot point. Adamek only won 2-3 rounds.

[Mike Tyson77]

"Bad" Chad looked like the cahmp from the beginning.


But Tarver would whoop both of em.

[PRboxingfan]

Actually, you guys are wrong. A judge can still score a round 10-9 regardless if the ref rules a KD or not. It was a clear trip and not a KD, and if the judges saw that, then yes they can score it 10-9. A round does not have to be scored 10-8 simply because the ref rules a KD.

But it's a moot point. Adamek only won 2-3 rounds.

Yes, you can have a 10-9 round but only if you give it as an even round, with the 10 going to the fighter that knocked the other one down and the 9 going to the fighter who got knocked down. You don't often see this unless a fighter CLEARLY wins the whole round and gets knocked down in the final seconds of the round.

Judges score on a 10-point must system, meaning that he must give 10 points to the winner of the round. They have to respect the refs calls, tho, so if a ref calls a KD as official then the judge must subtract one point from the final scoring of the round.

ok.. if you were the referee how did you score it

Judges score the fight, refs don't. If I were a judge, my card would've been 117-109.

[mECHsLAVE]

Yes, you can have a 10-9 round but only if you give it as an even round, with the 10 going to the fighter that knocked the other one down and the 9 going to the fighter who got knocked down. You don't often see this unless a fighter CLEARLY wins the whole round and gets knocked down in the final seconds of the round.

Judges score on a 10-point must system, meaning that he must give 10 points to the winner of the round. They have to respect the refs calls, tho, so if a ref calls a KD as official then the judge must subtract one point from the final scoring of the round.


Judges score the fight, refs don't. If I were a judge, my card would've been 117-109.

The 10-point must system means all the judge MUST do is give the winner of the round 10 points. That does not translate into the fact that they MUST subtract an extra point for a KD. The same way they don't have to score it merely 10-9 if the fighter that loses the round keeps his feet. Judges have plenty of slack in how they score, what they SHOULD do is not always what they MUST do, so just be careful with that wording. That's all.