The Official How'd Ya Score The Fight Thread

[ben41193]

I don't mean to put Taylor dwon, but he's never been a good fighter, and not even close. Everybody puts guys like Miranda down for lack of finesse, well at least Miranda has some real power.

I usualy dont disagree with yu but im gonna have have to repectfully disagree with you here man. Taylor is good. He deservess a spot on a p4p liist.

[Coach BxR]

draw. no way in hell taylor deserved to steal the belt from a long-reigning champion on hopkins. his end will come soon once he fights a real middleweight with power.

[Rudyo]

I had it 115-113 for Hopkins.

[K-Nan]

I usualy dont disagree with yu but im gonna have have to repectfully disagree with you here man. Taylor is good. He deservess a spot on a p4p liist.

I can see that Taylor has POTENTIAL... but a carreer based on 2 gift decisions does not equate into top 5 p4p status.

[ben41193]

He isnt top 5. But with wins over hopkins who is in the top 10 and a draw with number 2 he deffanatly deserves a spot.

[K-Nan]

He isnt top 5. But with wins over hopkins who is in the top 10 and a draw with number 2 he deffanatly deserves a spot.

Oh, definitely. But I just don't have him in the top 5, like most.

[ben41193]

I have him around 7

[K-Nan]

I have him around 7

Good call. I have the exact same spot.

My list:

1.PBF
2.Pacman
3.Winky
4.Barerra
5.Hopkins
6.Calzaghe
7.Taylor
8.Hatton
9.R. Marquez
10.Casamayor.

[ben41193]

[QUOTE=Kaynan;2094347]Good call. I have the exact same spot.

My list:

1.PBF
2.Pacman
3.Winky
4.Barerra
5.Hopkins
6.Calzaghe
7.Taylor
8.Hatton
9.R. Marquez
10.Casamayor.[/QUOTE

Mine is similar the main differense is that i have winky number 2 and pac man at number 3

[Guest]

Hopefully this thread gets big, but let's start off with Hopkins vs taylor 1.

How'd ya score that fight?

I scored it

115-113 for Hopkins.

Exactly my score.

Actually, to be fair, Taylor did appear to score a KD in ISTR round two which wasn't called, so...