Should James Toney Retire?

[psychopath]

if he came in at 220,,,,he would have got knocked out

K.o.ed? By What? By Peter's jabs?

Nah most probably not. Let's be honest about this. We have seen Toney in better shape and we know what he can do without those extra weight.

[GasPed]

He should definitely retire. Yeah, he's probably still a top 10 heavyweight, but he's not going to be champ, and it's only downhill from here. He's proven he could fight with the best, all he would show now is that he's still a pretty good fighter, but we all know that already.

Plus, the more shots he takes from the big boys, the worse it's going to be for him after he hangs em. Every blow kills a few more cells in the brain bank, and believe me, his account is going to bounce very soon.

[Lights0ut]

James should fight 1 more without a doubt to grab his 70th. If by the slim chance he can get into the type of shape he was for Holyfield, then he should and could continue, otherwise he should call it a career.

[maxorido]

He proved enought in his career and he has nothing else to prove
retire and you will be remembered as a ATG

Damn I wish that girl in your avatar would do **** ASAP.

[Dorian]

He proved enought in his career and he has nothing else to prove
retire and you will be remembered as a ATG

[maxorido]

the only guy I think he'd beat there is briggs. valuev is just too big and would knock him around,,,plus maskeav would beat him the same way peter did,,,although toney could make that one very very close

Yeah I didn't even mention Valuev because it's just ridiculous imagining him and Toney fighting. I think the fact that maskaev is slower and doesn't hit as hard as peter would be enough for Toney to get the UD. Now guys like Rahman and Lyahovich, i'm not sure what these guys have left. Lyahovich looked awfull against an awfull Briggs.

[realheavyhands]

wlad is overrated he is good but not great

[beez721]

If Toney can take Peter's shots and exchange with him, he can beat most of the other heavies out there. The shape he was in on saturday, he would have been able to do enough to beat Rahman. I can see Toney taking Rahman in a rematch, beating Maskaev, Lyahovich (shot), and probably Briggs too because his stamina is awfull and he doesn't **** as hard as Peter. However, Peter has his number and Wlad would destroy him.

the only guy I think he'd beat there is briggs. valuev is just too big and would knock him around,,,plus maskeav would beat him the same way peter did,,,although toney could make that one very very close

[Animal Squabbs]

no, he should fight Byrd finally and if he wins he should take on one of the other champs.

[maxorido]

If Toney can take Peter's shots and exchange with him, he can beat most of the other heavies out there. The shape he was in on saturday, he would have been able to do enough to beat Rahman. I can see Toney taking Rahman in a rematch, beating Maskaev, Lyahovich (shot), and probably Briggs too because his stamina is awfull and he doesn't **** as hard as Peter. However, Peter has his number and Wlad would destroy him.