Instant Replay now in Boxing...

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mikefromstu
    Contender
    Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
    • Jun 2005
    • 350
    • 38
    • 206
    • 6,625

    #1

    Instant Replay now in Boxing...

    The innovative New Jersey State Athletic Control Board has announced that effective immediately, instant replay can be utilized during combative sporting contests to review a referee's call or lack of a call. Instant replay will be utilized at the discretion of the lead promoter. Theagency will not force a promoter to utilize instant replay, but will not deny the promoter the opportunity to do so. The agency does not have the technology readily available, so it will be up to the promoter to provide the necessary equipment. The use of such technology would allow the Commissioner to review issues such as:
    1. Knockdowns versus slips
    2. Accidental versus intentional fouls
    3. If a cut was the result of legal strike
    4. If a fighter beat the count
    5. Low blows
    6. Whether or not a strike landed before the bell rang.
    The Commissioner, if approached during a round by the contestant's chief second, would review the issue at the end of the round. The bout would be temporarily stopped during the rest period and the Commissioner would have a maximum of three minutes to render a decision or choose to reserve his judgment because further review is needed. Upon the Commissioner's ruling, the bout would then be restarted and would continue.
  • mikefromstu
    Contender
    Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
    • Jun 2005
    • 350
    • 38
    • 206
    • 6,625

    #2
    As long as it doesn;t slow things down I am for it. Especially the knockdowns. I hate seeing a guy get called for a knockdown when the feet get entwined.

    Comment

    • Kball15
      HATTON WRIGHT PAVLIK
      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
      • Apr 2006
      • 15471
      • 491
      • 86
      • 22,680

      #3
      YES!!! this is good news. Although i think Intentional-vs-unintentional fouls should be left to gut feeling. The ref will start second guessing himself if he reviews it.

      Besides that its allll good

      Comment

      • psychopath
        Banned
        Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
        • Aug 2004
        • 5085
        • 196
        • 266
        • 5,396

        #4
        For the much needed improvement of the sports, hell yeah!

        The only draw back I can see is some corner making use of the halt time to give their fighter extra time to recover especially during "crunch time".

        Comment

        • Kball15
          HATTON WRIGHT PAVLIK
          Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
          • Apr 2006
          • 15471
          • 491
          • 86
          • 22,680

          #5
          Originally posted by psychopath
          For the much needed improvement of the sports, hell yeah!

          The only draw back I can see is some corner making use of the halt time to give their fighter extra time to recover especially during "crunch time".
          i would think that these things would take place ONLY in between rounds

          Comment

          • Njord777
            Archaic Pugilist
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • May 2006
            • 2509
            • 177
            • 9
            • 8,928

            #6
            Originally posted by kfootball15
            i would think that these things would take place ONLY in between rounds
            See, this is a necessary use of current technology in a sport that drags its heels to such things. Open scoring has been tossed around- but I for one dislike the idea. It's a debatable procedure. Replays, on the other hand, are used in every other sport and its only logical boxing follow suit. Long overdue.

            Comment

            • psychopath
              Banned
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Aug 2004
              • 5085
              • 196
              • 266
              • 5,396

              #7
              Originally posted by kfootball15
              i would think that these things would take place ONLY in between rounds
              Yes I got that clearly.

              The ussual in between round rest is one minute right? So if they'll give the official 3 minutes to review, that would mean extending the rest period from one minute to three minutes. That's what I'm talking about.

              The rythym of the winning fighter will be gone by the time the bout is allowed to continue.

              Comment

              • Kball15
                HATTON WRIGHT PAVLIK
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • Apr 2006
                • 15471
                • 491
                • 86
                • 22,680

                #8
                yea thats a problem. ****** actually.

                Comment

                • psychopath
                  Banned
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • Aug 2004
                  • 5085
                  • 196
                  • 266
                  • 5,396

                  #9
                  Originally posted by kfootball15
                  yea thats a problem. ****** actually.
                  The best they can do is to let the fight continue as is without disruption and put the previous round scores on hold. After the next round that's the time they can announce the result of the instant replay.

                  The rest time of one minute plus the succeeding round's three minutes will give the official four minutes to review the replay and declare the results without delaying and altering the tempo of the fight.

                  Just my thought.

                  Comment

                  • Rockin'
                    Banned
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Jun 2004
                    • 23907
                    • 4,461
                    • 12,395
                    • 1,239,562

                    #10
                    Sounds rediculous to me. First of all, if it is a replay at the descretion of the promoter, what do you think will happen when his boy goes down? I would think replay. What abvout when his boys opponent goes down, no replay I would imagine.

                    Football is about seconds and minutes as are all of the other sports. Boxing is about the split second and there is no time in between those split seconds for replays.

                    The officials put in the fights are worthy and capable of making the correct calls. At times it seems that some of them are watching another fight and we disagree with their calls. But for the most part I believe that opur officials make good and consistant calls, no need for replay reviewing..............Rockin'

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP