rate the southpaws

[Diablo]

DOn't get me wrong Pac and Winky would be atop this list if it was best fighters. But the list is for most complete fighters. WInky lacks power and Pacman lacks proper footwork and defense.

[realheavyhands]

Calzaghe is the most naturally talented, although Judah might have something to say about that. But the most 'complete', it's kind of close between Pacquiao and Wright because each have their different strengths and (albeit few) weaknesses.

I agree about calzghe but he tends to ge very sloppy when allowed ..its almost like he fights down to his competition

[!!! Beowulf !!!]

At his best I guess Calzaghe would be the most complete, decent power, fast, strong and has a good defence.

Winky isn't a complete fighter because he just doesn't have the power to hurt top class fighters, though he is a defensive master and a very tricky southpaw indeed.


Pac is just Pac, a wrecking ball of a fighter with increasingly good technique and ring smarts.

[Mr. Ryan]

tarver
pacquioao
winky
judah
calzaghe
bryd

whos the most complete

Perhaps Calzaghe or Judah, they are true traditional southpaws who understand the weaknesses and strengths of being a left handed fighter. Winky and Byrd just do what they do, and Pacquiao is just a slugger with phenomenal athleticism, but doesnt truly understand being a southpaw except that he knows he hits hard with his left than other people do.

[Parody]

and how many years ago was winky wrights last KO ?

not very complete is he..

Your a complete dumbass, you keep tossing audley's salad and you call some fighter a bum who is fighter of the year in 2006, every single posted related or not related you bring audley up, please shut the **** up and talk some sense. Just because Winky does'nt KO people does'nt mean hes a complete boxer? Your a ****** and its official.

[ROSEWOOD]

tarver - good boxer
pacquioao - good brawler
winky - great Boxer
judah - ok..when he aint bull****tin
calzaghe - Great Warrior
bryd - sucks HW...Great Cruiser

whos the most complete - Winky by far..This guy has all the tools to be a all-time great if he's not already..He doesnt get hit so he has a ton of years left in the sport..

[Mr. Ryan]

tarver - good boxer
pacquioao - good brawler
winky - great Boxer
judah - ok..when he aint bull****tin
calzaghe - Great Warrior
bryd - sucks HW...Great Cruiser

whos the most complete - Winky by far..This guy has all the tools to be a all-time great if he's not already..He doesnt get hit so he has a ton of years left in the sport..

2007 will bring the end of the Winky Wright show to be real with you. Judah is the best southpaw of all of these guys, to be honest. I just didn't want to say that.

[The Surgeon]

2007 will bring the end of the Winky Wright show to be real with you. Judah is the best southpaw of all of these guys, to be honest. I just didn't want to say that.

Im in agreement with both those points, Judah knows and uses the southpaw stance to better use than the rest. Duznt, at least not to me, mean he's a better fighter tho

[Mr. Ryan]

Im in agreement with both those points, Judah knows and uses the southpaw stance to better use than the rest. Duznt, at least not to me, mean he's a better fighter tho

Talent-wise, I think he may be a better boxer. By that, I mean that he understands the principles and has the basic functions of a boxer to maximize his effectiveness. Of course, that means nothing if you don't have it upstairs.

[The Surgeon]

Talent-wise, I think he may be a better boxer. By that, I mean that he understands the principles and has the basic functions of a boxer to maximize his effectiveness. Of course, that means nothing if you don't have it upstairs.

Yeah dude im with u on that. His chin sucks but more so than that its his focus that lets him down! He has had a good career but its been a let down, for me anyway, i thought this guy was gonna go ALL the way!