Jones-Toney-Eubank-Benn - who ya got?

[Guest]

Quiet week, so let's go with this.

I actually find Toney the hardest one to factor in to any match-up, but here's what I got:


Roy Jones:
W Eubank UD
W Benn TKO btwn 6-9
W Toney UD??? (I know this DID happen, obviously, but what do you guys reckon in a hypothetical match-up where Toney wasn't weight drained? No flames, just answer the question).


Eubank:
W Benn UD (I think if these guys fought primes Chris would win 7 out of 10 encounters. He's simply the be... better boxer, and the larger, stronger man).

Toney???


In fact, I find it hard to come up with any definite decision as to Toney vs. any of the three. The only one I'd like to really guess at would be L UD to Roy, though maybe not as wide if he was in proper condition.

[PATO 1]

jt beats eubank an benn but not rjj

[!!! Beowulf !!!]

RJJ:

W Eubank by decision (close)
W Benn by TKO after Benn Knocks Jones Jr down.
W Toney by decision (close)

Eubank:

W Benn by decision/stoppage. Could outbox Benn or hurt him like the first fight.

W Toney by decision

Toney:

Toney vs Benn would be close, but Toney's chin gets him a decision probably. Might even stop Benn late if Benn punches himself out. You wouldn't be able to discount Benn completely though.




I guess it's a shame Eubank/Benn and Toney/Jones only fought their fellow countrymen.


Throwing Calzaghe into the mix would be interesting, he'd have a good chance of being last man standing, prime for prime. Jones vs Calzaghe would have been awesome and too close to call.

[everlast99]

no, it wouldn't

jones would've made calzaghe his *****

[PATO 1]

no, it wouldn't

jones would've made calzaghe his *****

agreed .....jones ko 10

[number6]

Jones v Benn
I would think Benn would be made to miss alot in this match,i also think he would take too many punches.Jones tko in 10 (doctor stoppage)

Jones v Eubank
Jones should be too quick for Eubank,he would outscore him in most of the rounds imo.Dont think he would come close to stopping Eubank but still wins ud.

Benn v Toney
Benn was dynamite at times but also a little reckless,he would definately have his moments in this one but i would think Toney catches him for a ko win in around 7.

Toney v Eubank
This is the closest fight of the bunch,not too much between these 2 but i would give the edge to Toney,both had great chins and good power,i see this one going the distance.Toney to win a close fight on points.

[Shanus]

no, it wouldn't

jones would've made calzaghe his *****

What are you going by, styles? or do you think a prime Roy was unbeatable?

Anyway:

Roy UD Eubank
TKO Benn
UD Toney

Toney UD Benn
L UD Eubank

Benn L UD Eubank
L UD Toney
L UD Roy (But Benn has a bigger chance of KOing Roy than any of them)

[number6]

Jones v Toney
Jones still takes this one by ud,if Toney is weight drained or in his prime.

[Mr. Ryan]

I think Jones beats all of these guys, Toney stops Benn and decisions Eubank, Eubank had Benn's number, and Benn has a punchers chance with Jones but little else.