zab judah vs miguel cotto who wins ?

[BigSlick]

Actually I thought Zab looked really crisp and in top form versus PBF, but was just beaten in a close fight by a better fighter. Like someone else said Zab is an extremly dangerous fighter and IMHO is the most dangerous single punch KO guy at 147.

Floyd broke Zab down with body punches and Floyd isn't regarded as a powerful puncher. Cotto's bodywork would have Zab out the fight in 7

[Left2body]

Floyd broke Zab down with body punches and Floyd isn't regarded as a powerful puncher. Cotto's bodywork would have Zab out the fight in 7

If you read my earlier post you would see that I agree with the late stoppage for Cotto, however I think its a much more dangerous fight than others perceive it to be.

Also I think it was more of Zab's chronic fading in fights that lost him the fight. PBF doesn't fade and has excellent conditioning. When Zab slowed down a nano-second PBF took over but Zab had 4 of the first 5 rounds. The focused Zab that lost to PBF would've beaten Baldomir in my opinion.

I also still regard Zab as one of the top Welterweights out there.

[K-DOGG]

If you read my earlier post you would see that I agree with the late stoppage for Cotto, however I think its a much more dangerous fight than others perceive it to be.

Also I think it was more of Zab's chronic fading in fights that lost him the fight. PBF doesn't fade and has excellent conditioning. When Zab slowed down a nano-second PBF took over but Zab had 4 of the first 5 rounds. The focused Zab that lost to PBF would've beaten Baldomir in my opinion.

I also still regard Zab as one of the top Welterweights out there.

I differ with you on one point. I think the reason Zab lost was because of a fundamental flaw in his make-up. Floyd started winning and dominating when he began forcing the action; it was subtle, but it was the difference. As soon as Floyd started taking the lead, Zab was at a loss...because he's not a thinker. As long as he's setting the pace and the tempo of the fight he does okay; but if the battle of wills is won by his opponent, he's in trouble.

At least that was my observation.

[Welter_Skelter]

Call this fight Judah Tszyu II with very similar results

[Left2body]

I differ with you on one point. I think the reason Zab lost was because of a fundamental flaw in his make-up. Floyd started winning and dominating when he began forcing the action; it was subtle, but it was the difference. As soon as Floyd started taking the lead, Zab was at a loss...because he's not a thinker. As long as he's setting the pace and the tempo of the fight he does okay; but if the battle of wills is won by his opponent, he's in trouble.

At least that was my observation.

I agree with that. I just dont think it was any 1 thing though. I think it was a combination.

[frank THE tank]

Before I thought Judah would have a chance

But Cotto most likely stops Judah

this coming from the biggest judah fan here

[-EX-]

It would be competitive until Judah gets caught and tries to run and gets Koed or TKOed IMO. I think Cotto could put him away or if Cotto was confused Judah "could" outbox him most of the night, but I doubt that would happen.

Cotto by TKO or UD.

[titozhang]

zab will hit cotto's ball
then ko the refree

[Easy-E]

A focused Judah could give Cotto serious problems.
If Judah was going to win, he could not let up for one second of one round.
I would like the see this fight.
It would be a better win for Cotto than Tony would.

[El Jesus]

If cotto figures out how to stop judahs right hand from devastating him, cotto wins this with his consistency in the ring, unlike judah where you dont know if hes gonna look like hes a top 5 p4p or a complete ****ing idiot.