Did Joe Calzaghe lose in his prime to Robin Reid?

[Chollo Vista]

Many people seem to think so. What are your thoughts and how do you remember scoring the fight?

[Sugarj]

It was a close one. Activity level favoured Joe, but Reid clearly landed the key power shots. Calzaghe probably suffered more over the 12 rounds, but probably deserved to hold on to his title.

[DreamFighter]

why all these same threads? it was an either way decision anyway.

[RobLow155]

Calzaghe vs Reid

I had it 116 to 114 for Calzaghe. I had Reid losing the first four rounds. He gave Calzaghe a 10-8 round in the 8th round with a low blow, with 3 rounds even.