Top 5 greatest Mexican boxers of all-time?

[just the facts]

I agree, the first four are a given. Last spot is up for grabs between Saldivar or Canto.

Damn, forgot about Canto

[ROSS CALIFORNIA]

Your list is pretty lame if you don't have Sanchez in it.

[soul_survivor]

Who are they and why?

just off the top of my head:

Chavez
Barrera
Morales
Sanchez
Lopez

[BennyST]

Canelo hasn't done enough yet, so replace him with the much more deserving Vicente Saldivar.

Canelo hasn't done enough?! Dude, I only put him at 5 because he hasnt fought GGG yet. I think he's more likely top 3 and will undoubtedly be number 1 after the GGG fight.

Who is Vincente Saldivar? I've never even heard of him so he mustn't be very good. Definitely not better Mijares, Arce or Fernando Montiel.

[The Old LefHook]

Canelo hasn't done enough?! Dude, I only put him at 5 because he hasnt fought GGG yet. I think he's more likely top 3 and will undoubtedly be number 1 after the GGG fight.

Who is Vincente Saldivar? I've never even heard of him so he mustn't be very good. Definitely not better Mijares, Arce or Fernando Montiel.

So you think little red Canelo will do a job on GGG? Little red should fight at middleweight or get out of the middleweight division. He is shaming the division. Should be a hammer-out for GGG, if little red gets some nerve.

[just the facts]

Canelo hasn't done enough?! Dude, I only put him at 5 because he hasnt fought GGG yet. I think he's more likely top 3 and will undoubtedly be number 1 after the GGG fight.

Who is Vincente Saldivar? I've never even heard of him so he mustn't be very good. Definitely not better Mijares, Arce or Fernando Montiel.

If you don't think Saldivar is better than Mijares, Arce or Montiel - better do some homework.

[too_much]

Ricardo Lopez
Salvador Sanchez
Julio Cesar Chavez
Ruben Olivares
Vicente Saldivar

[The plunger man]

Chavez
Sanchez
Zarate
Morales
Lopez

[Zaroku]

Chavez
Sanchez
Zarate
Morales
Lopez

Nice list.

6. Marquez.
..
..
..
..
..

11. Jhonny Gonzalez
12. Jhonny Chihuahua p4p

[DAVID READ]

Canelo hasn't done enough?! Dude, I only put him at 5 because he hasnt fought GGG yet. I think he's more likely top 3 and will undoubtedly be number 1 after the GGG fight.

Who is Vincente Saldivar? I've never even heard of him so he mustn't be very good. Definitely not better Mijares, Arce or Fernando Montiel.

Haven't heard of Saldivar? You mustn't know much about boxing history. Saldivar was world featherweight champion from 1965 yo 1973