MODERN Top 50 - Last 25 Years 1986 - 2012

[SCtrojansbaby]

Oh and its just ridiculous to have Whitaker over guys like Eubank McCallum Roy Chavez. Whitaker's resume is clearly inferior to theirs

[McGoorty]

1.Roy Jones Jr
2.Julio Cesar Chavez
3.Bernard Hopkins
4.Marco Antonio Barrera
5.Mike McCallum
6.Chris Eubank
7.Manny Pacquiao
8.Evander Holyfield
9.Rafeal Marquez
10.James Toney
11.Lennox Lewis
12.Azumah Nelson
13.Erik Morales

Some other guys in no order

Kostya
Mosley
JMM
Wlad
Mark Johnson
Fenech
Vitali
Ricardo Lopez
Dariusz
Bowe
Maske
Hill
Whitaker
Hamed
Norris
PBF
Starling
Tyson
Carbajal
Winky
Isreal Vasquez

Some good fighters.,,, But, I was wondering WHY you have Barrera in front of PAQUIAO ???. It can't be right, did you see what Pac-Man did to MAB ?, it just does not seem credible. .......LET ME KNOW EH !!!!

[SBleeder]

I see you have Mayweather over Pacquaio. You're one of the only people I have seen with that.

Back on 2007, I felt Mayweather was the greater of the two, now I feel it's Pacquaio (but not by much, IMO) but I don't think he's done that much since 2007, really.

Could you break down why you feel this way, I want a second opinion on it.

I rank fighters mainly by skill/ability, with resume and accomplishments being secondary. Floyd's prime performances are far more excellent than anything I've seen out of Pacquiao in his entire career.

Pacquiao's run through over-the-hill fighters over the last five years does not, in my opinion, elevate him above Mayweather.

[SCtrojansbaby]

Some good fighters.,,, But, I was wondering WHY you have Barrera in front of PAQUIAO ???. It can't be right, did you see what Pac-Man did to MAB ?, it just does not seem credible. .......LET ME KNOW EH !!!!

Barrera has the better resume

[Scott9945]

Oh and its just ridiculous to have Whitaker over guys like Eubank McCallum Roy Chavez. Whitaker's resume is clearly inferior to theirs

Please explain how Whitaker's resume could possibly be inferior to Chris Eubanks.

[Sugar Sting Ray]

1. Pacquiao
2. Roy Jones
3. Whitaker
4. Mike Tyson
5. Julio Cesar Chavez Sr.
6. Oscar De La Hoya
7. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
8. Holyfield
9. Lopez
10. Hearns

[McGoorty]

Barrera has the better resume

PLEASE -- Try to prove your case !!!!!!, Because I don't get it, just put up your comparisons between Pac & MAC.----I agree that Barrera is a Top 10 - 15 or so, he'd be in there somewhere. I don't uderstand, AND he beat Barerra, if you think Marco was past it, say so. Take some time and put your case forward. Cheers !

[SCtrojansbaby]

1. Pacquiao
2. Roy Jones
3. Whitaker
4. Mike Tyson
5. Julio Cesar Chavez Sr.
6. Oscar De La Hoya
7. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
8. Holyfield
9. Lopez
10. Hearns

WTF

I won't even bother with Whitaker but Tyson a #4 is far too high but I guess an argument could be made for him in the top 15, DLH is not even top 25, and Hearns only good win past 1986 was against Hill not even sure he belongs in the top 50.

[BigStereotype]

PLEASE -- Try to prove your case !!!!!!, Because I don't get it, just put up your comparisons between Pac & MAC.----I agree that Barrera is a Top 10 - 15 or so, he'd be in there somewhere. I don't uderstand, AND he beat Barerra, if you think Marco was past it, say so. Take some time and put your case forward. Cheers !

I have to say that I agree with Trojan here. Barrera has the better resume. Hell, Pac's best win is a past-it Barrera. That says it all.

[SCtrojansbaby]

I have to say that I agree with Trojan here. Barrera has the better resume. Hell, Pac's best win is a past-it Barrera. That says it all.

Barrera wasn't past it when Pacquiao beat him