Who is more HOF-worthy??

[Pastrano]

Curry or Starling? Many will say Curry since he got 2 wins over Starling, but he lost to Honeyghan while Starling destroyed him. Starling was also the first to beat Breland and Simon Brown. I think both should get in, its a sham that they haven't already.

[Boxing Bob]

Past, they only let in 3 per year so these two and lots of other good fighters with good resumes just won't ever make it. Pretty close between these two, I'll take Curry, he was a more accomplished amateur and also won a 154 lb belt(although he beat a chump to get it).

[Pastrano]

Past, they only let in 3 per year so these two and lots of other good fighters with good resumes just won't ever make it. Pretty close between these two, I'll take Curry, he was a more accomplished amateur and also won a 154 lb belt(although he beat a chump to get it).

Hold up now! Gianfranco Rosi was far from a CHUMP, he defended the same title eleven times after he got beat by Curry. He's one of the best Italian fighters of that era. And all eras, when it comes to accomplishments.

[Boxing Bob]

Sorry Past but Rosi was a chump. He beat exactly one quality fighter (Lupe Aquino), and needed a hometown decision to get that. Sorry Past but Van Horn is not a quality fighter. If you think Rosi is anything but an ordinary fighter, or if you think Curry or Starling are HOF worthy then you're a very poor judge of boxing quality.

[fitefanSHO]

IMO Starling accomplished more, and didn't have the shocking KO losses that Curry has.

So that IMO makes him more Hall worthy than Curry.

[Pastrano]

Sorry Past but Rosi was a chump. He beat exactly one quality fighter (Lupe Aquino), and needed a hometown decision to get that. Sorry Past but Van Horn is not a quality fighter. If you think Rosi is anything but an ordinary fighter, or if you think Curry or Starling are HOF worthy then you're a very poor judge of boxing quality.

Lol, so he had only ONE quality win, eh?! Ever hear of DUANE THOMAS?!? Rosi TKOed him in 7 rounds, that was in his first title reign. Thomas was a Kronk fighter who had beat Mugabi by TKO3 to win the same title. He also decisioned Kalambay before that.

Anyway, Starling striked me as a nicer man than Curry. Yes he had some ego like Curry but didn't put his opponents down, slag em off like Curry did. At least not as far as I know.

[fitefanSHO]

Marlon did much better after boxing than Curry also, it bears mentioning.

[SCtrojansbaby]

Starling was better but neither one should even sniff the HOF