Greater fighter: Calzaghe or Hopkins?

[Daddy T]

Muhammad Ali repatedly held behind the head. People use illegal tactics they get away with. It's part of the game deal with it.

it ain't illegal if the ref says nothin about it lol - Well I like Joe but Hopkins ranks above him in my book ... i've never been keen on the idea of super middle anyway ... you're either a middle or light heavy - having another weight class in between is just one more way for guys like calzaghe and hopkins to avoid fighting until one of them is well past prime.

[DeepSleep]

Hopkins by a wide margin.

I get a kick out of people claiming Hopkins losses to Taylor somehow degrade his legacy. Hopkins was 40 years old when he fought Taylor.

You are not going to be remembered for being great by not fighting anyone with a pulse until they are in a walker.