James Tony vs Mike McCallum: Who should be ranked higher?

[Toney616]

In terms of skillset:
using the following criteria:
Offense
Defense
Counterpunching
Adaptability

[SCtrojansbaby]

I would give all the edges to Toney but they are close

[Obama]

I would give all the edges to Toney but they are close

Everything minus offense. McCallum's offense at 154 was better than Toney's at any weight.

[Scott9945]

Everything minus offense. McCallum's offense at 154 was better than Toney's at any weight.

Agree 100% with that. Although counterpunching may be about even.

[Toney616]

Everything minus offense. McCallum's offense at 154 was better than Toney's at any weight.

I agree with this. McCallum was brutal during his fights with Watson (round 2) and Jackson. He was also prepared to chase his opponents, unlike Toney who always wanted his opponents to come to him. Both of them also fought a prime Jones and McCallum did way better than Toney did

[Toney616]

Agree 100% with that. Although counterpunching may be about even.

Wahts your fav McCallum fight?

[sonnyboyx2]

James Toney