Why is Jack Dempsey over-rated (imo) by a lot of historians and other sources?

[Barn]

Yes, but, do you think #4 Heavyweight would warrant a ranking such as #9 on a P4P list?

[StarshipTrooper]

Yes, but, do you think #4 Heavyweight would warrant a ranking such as #9 on a P4P list?

No, but then again I think Heavyweights in general get overrated in a p4p sense

Poet

[Barn]

Let's say for example someone such as Hagler or Monzon who may regard to be a Top 5 Middleweight if I ranked Hagler at #9 I would get crucified for bias. So I don't understand why it goes passed by for Dempsey.

[StarshipTrooper]

Let's say for example someone such as Hagler or Monzon who may regard to be a Top 5 Middleweight if I ranked Hagler at #9 I would get crucified for bias. So I don't understand why it goes passed by for Dempsey.

Not from me. I don't see Hagler as a top-10 p4p all that particularly controversial. But that's just me :hah9:

Poet

[Barn]

Not from me. I don't see Hagler as a top-10 p4p all that particularly controversial. But that's just me :hah9:

Poet

I remember I had Hagler 25 on a P4P list and got around 5 replies saying he was too high.