Who was the Bigger Puncher Robinson, Hearns, Mccellan, Mugabi or Graziano?

[Joey Giardello]

Who was the Bigger Puncher Robinson, Hearns, Mccellan, Mugabi or Graziano?

[CarlosG815]

Hearns threw nuclear bombs.

[CiganoBoxer]

Diddnt the ring magazine do a pound4pound punchers list a while ago ??? wasnt Mclellan 28 and Julian Jackson 27....hearns was 18 !

[The Iron Man]

Diddnt the ring magazine do a pound4pound punchers list a while ago ??? wasnt Mclellan 28 and Julian Jackson 27....hearns was 18 !

Think this is it mate!

http://boxing.about.com/od/history/a/ring_punchers.htm

From those people i would pick Hearns.

[1SILVA]

Who was the Bigger Puncher Robinson, Hearns, Mccellan, Mugabi or Graziano?

Robinson threw the most beautiful punches you ever saw, yet I would give Hearns a slight edge in power. Hearns had the greatest right cross in 147 pound history, and his left hook to the body was fierce. SRR's left hook was better, so a slight edge goes to the Hit Man in terms of overall power.

[1SILVA]

Think this is it mate!

http://boxing.about.com/od/history/a/ring_punchers.htm

From those people i would pick Hearns.

I think Prince Naseem is rated too low at 46. I hated the guy, but his power at 122 and 126 was ridiculous.

[TheGreatA]

McClellan was huge compared to the rest, I believe nearly 180 lbs by fight time. Pound for pound I'd say that Hearns was the biggest puncher, a 147 lber who could knock out light heavyweights.

[CiganoBoxer]

I think Prince Naseem is rated too low at 46. I hated the guy, but his power at 122 and 126 was ridiculous.

Agreed....Manny Stewart said that Nassem Hamed was the biggest puncher he ever held mits for

[StarshipTrooper]

Think this is it mate!

http://boxing.about.com/od/history/a/ring_punchers.htm

From those people i would pick Hearns.

Guys, read the title of that list: It's "greatest" punchers not "hardest" punchers.....Power is only one critera that the ratings are based on.

Poet

[The_Demon]

I think Prince Naseem is rated too low at 46. I hated the guy, but his power at 122 and 126 was ridiculous.

Co-sign

Robinson threw the most beautiful punches you ever saw, yet I would give Hearns a slight edge in power. Hearns had the greatest right cross in 147 pound history, and his left hook to the body was fierce. SRR's left hook was better, so a slight edge goes to the Hit Man in terms of overall power.

I agree with this too,robinson was the better puncher in terms of technique but hearns had that raw power,his right hand was like a kick from a mule-and i think thats being generous to the mule!