James Toney vs Bernard Hopkins: Whose higher on the ATG list?

[General Zod]

James Toney:
Accomplishments:
ibf mw belt six defences
ibf smw belt 3 defences
ibf cw belt 0 defences
Best wins:
Nunn
McCallum
Littles
Johnson
Jirov

Bernard Hopkins
Accomplishments:
ibf mw belt 20 defences
wbc mw belt 7 defences
wba mw belt 6 defences
wbo mw belt 1 defence
Ring lhw belt 1 defence
Best wins:
Tarver
Tito
Winky
Pavlik
Johnson

Whose higher on the ATG list? Please explain your answers as well

Criteria:
accomplishments
Reaction to adversity
Best wins
Consistency

[Obama]

Hopkins takes it on consistency. Guy spent a decade among the top 10 p4p, and was #1 multiple times.

[Southpaw Great]

Hopkins all day!

[T.McGrady]

Hopkins for sure, but i don't think prime hopkins can beat prime toney.

[General Zod]

Hopkins takes it on consistency. Guy spent a decade among the top 10 p4p, and was #1 multiple times.

I can agree with this, I didn't realize how much he accomplished until I typed all of that stuff up

[General Zod]

Hopkins for sure, but i don't think prime hopkins can beat prime toney.

I think Toney beats him, shame they didn't fight though

[Obama]

They were negotiating to fight at CW at one point, but Hopkins was still a MW at the time. Toney still wants to fight him at CW to this day.

[wmute]

It's close, but at the end of the day Toney has better wins, and was the better fighter. It's close due to McDonalds.

[Toney616]

It's close, but at the end of the day Toney has better wins, and was the better fighter. It's close due to McDonalds.

lmao

[Toney616]

They were negotiating to fight at CW at one point, but Hopkins was still a MW at the time. Toney still wants to fight him at CW to this day.

Toney vs hopkins would be much better than Hopkins Jones II thats for sure