Roy Jones Jr. or James "Lights Out" Toney?

[wmute]

Jones, but it's close.

Thanks Benny for typing what I would type!

[T.McGrady]

I agree, which is what BennyST said as well

you class beating that version of McCallum as a great win?

Actully, McCallum gave roy a good fight.

[BigStereotype]

James Toney is fantastic, absolutely amazing. But Roy Jones is in another ballpark entirely and it showed in their fight.

[General Zod]

Actually, McCallum gave roy a good fight.

It was still a very over the hill version of McCallum though (who was 1 fight away from retirement), which is why I never listed that version of him in either Toney's or Roy's best wins.

off topic:
I scored the McCallum fight 9-3 to Jones

[General Zod]

James Toney is fantastic, absolutely amazing. But Roy Jones is in another ballpark entirely and it showed in their fight.

Toney always struggled with guys who had good footspeed, also he wasn't very good at cutting off the ring

off topic:
What are your favorite Toney fights?

[Bushidō]

Roy Jones Jr. or James "Lights Out" Toney? Who ranks higher ATG wise, and why?

Couldn't seem to find another thread about it, and I've been thinking about it lately...

Toney could have been one of the best FIGHTERS EVER but he underachieved his whole career.

[BigStereotype]

Toney always struggled with guys who had good footspeed, also he wasn't very good at cutting off the ring

off topic:
What are your favorite Toney fights?

Haven't watched too much, but I really liked Barkley and Jirov. I have a copy of McCallum, but the quality sucks.

[General Zod]

Haven't watched too much, but I really liked Barkley and Jirov. I have a copy of McCallum, but the quality sucks.

Toney vs McCallum I

the rest is on my account just double click on the vid, also you should check out his fight with Jason Robinson an amazing fight. which I uploaded to my account about a week ago

[General Zod]

Toney could have been one of the best FIGHTERS EVER but he underachieved his whole career.

That is true, but Im sure his still a hofer though

[BigStereotype]

Toney vs McCallum I

the rest is on my account just double click on the vid, also you should check out his fight with Jason Robinson an amazing fight. which I uploaded to my account about a week ago

Thanks man!