Lennox Lewis vs Roy Jones: who ranks higher on the ATG list?

[fight_professor]

Is this a joke?

AT P4P, RJJ is way up there, top 25 maybe. Lewis was successful, but never spectacular. RJJ used to make us all sit up and say "damn, you see that?". He was a magician.

[Jim Jeffries]

Is this a joke?

AT P4P, RJJ is way up there, top 10 maybe. Lewis was successful, but never spectacular. RJJ used to make us all sit up and say "damn, you see that?". He was a magician.

Roy Jones Jr.

Top 10 ATG?

Please tell me you're joking.

[General Zod]

Is this a joke?

AT P4P, RJJ is way up there, top 25 maybe. Lewis was successful, but never spectacular. RJJ used to make us all sit up and say "damn, you see that?". He was a magician.

You rank him up there with Archie Moore and those guys?

[Jim Jeffries]

You rank him up there with Archie Moore and those guys?

He edited it from top 10 immediately after my post.

[General Zod]

He edited it from top 10 immediately after my post.

I wouldn't even rank him top 50, his in the 85-95 range for me

[fight_professor]

Roy Jones Jr.

Top 10 ATG?

Please tell me you're joking.

Actually, I edited it to 25 before any responses. But, I maintain that at his best, he'd rate right up there.

[General Zod]

Actually, I edited it to 25 before any responses. But, I maintain that at his best, he'd rate right up there.

Who are his best wins, according to you?

[fight_professor]

RJJ best for me are: BHop (1), James Toney, Trinidad, Tarver. In context Ruiz.


But its equally important how dominant he has. He went from MW to win a HW title, that puts him in the superelite.

[D-MiZe]

Roy higher than Lewis, just because of his multi-divisional achievements.

[General Zod]

Roy higher than Lewis, just because of his multi-divisional achievements.

good point