Joe Calzaghe vs James Toney Prime 4 Prime?

[Stallone60]

Joe Calzaghe has proved he is the best boxer to come out of britain and probably the best ever Super Middleweight in history. James Toney was a great Super Middleweight with alot of skills back in the day. Who would come out on top if a early 90's Toney got in the ring with a Calzaghe that destroyed Lacy?

[nachorjj]

Toney by KO

[geribeetus]

james by close decision, i think he had the ability to get a wide decision but even on his good nights he tended to take rounds off, even if he wasn't tired. since this gets done to death, i think calzaghe beats hopkins even back in the day on stamina alone. this is coming from probably the biggest hopkins fan on this forum. and i think jones beats calzaghe comfortably, with joe picking up most of his rounds after the 8th.

[ghost deini]

lol this hypothetical matchups are funny

like Calzaghe would've really had the balls to fight a guy like Toney

Toney would've wiped the floor with that overrated bum

[baya]

james by wide UD. if joe stood and fought he'd get KO'd i feel.

calzaghe is an awesome fighter, toney was just all around better; just maybe not as fast.

[sonnyboyx2]

Toney is one of the greatest fighters of all times

[Suckmedry]

I think Toney is too accurate with the counter right and his counters in general, for Joe to beat him.

[boxasmash]

Calzaghe wins.

[The_Demon]

bad style match-up for joe but im sure he could rally late to sneak it

[Joey Giardello]

I think toney has to many skills for joe, the toney who took apart prince charles williams and iran barkley beats the calzaghe that beat lacy