Who ranks higher? Trinidad or De La Hoya?

[Dondi33O]

I voted for de la hoya, but reading some of the other posts i can see why others voted for Trinidad. He was a fantastic fighter.

Someone posted oscar had too many questionable wins, but he also had questionable loses and fantastic wins in mega fights. The Chavez fights especially the second, Mosley fights, Quartey, Vargas, Mayorga are some of my all time favorite fights and fantastic wins.

He also had a brilliant amateur career winning a gold medal in the Olympics.

He destroyed an old Chavez which made people dislike Oscar's poor choice of capitalizing on certain fighters. Ike was a good win but very close, Vargas he waited till Tito exposed him, same with Mayorga, Shane beat him, then Hoya kind of looked for advantages and smaller fighters after he robbed Sturm. Tito took the scarier fighters and always had you wondering if he bit off more than he could handle. Then as time went on he fought even more difficult fighters.
But both did their things.

[Del Coqui]

lol @ this.tito in his prime missed quartey and shane.both guys oscasr fought,and 2 guys who had the goods to beat tito

yeah Mosley coming up from 140 or was it 135 surely got Tito scared, .....Quartey???? pls man. Undefeated Campas 55-0 50 kos, Carr supposedly next best thing outta motown since Hitman, Vargas undefeated version, Reid gold medalist undefeated,....... just read his record dude. ROFL @ Quartey and Mosley beating Tito back then, funniest post in this thread....