Mayweather questions

[warp1432]

It's really hard where to place the Zab Judah fight...

Honestly, Zab Judah was kicking Floyd's ass after 4, and then he went away... completely. He gave up, but it is an interesting fight to watch. I have it uploaded in the video section... search for Mayweather Judah, and make it show topics... mine is from an HD source and looks really good, so give it a look!

Anyway,

My order:
1. Jose Luis Castillo I (This will be consensus... a lot of people think Castillo definately deserved the victory)
2. Oscar De La Hoya
3. Jose Luis Castillo II
4. Zab Judah
5. Jesus Chavez (El Matador, he fought some scrub early in his career with the same name)
6. DeMarcus Corley
7. Victoriano Sosa
8. Emanuel Burton
9. Reggie Sanders (Early in his career, didn't look very good against a guy who ended up with a losing record)
10. Ricky Hatton
...

...

...

39. Arturo Gatti

Are you kidding? That fight was pretty much domination by Floyd. I had it 118-110 (117-111 I could see too. 116-112 is a stretch).

I'd switch the Burton fight to 3. It was probably the most physical fight Floyd was in.

[Chrismart]

It's really hard where to place the Zab Judah fight...

Honestly, Zab Judah was kicking Floyd's ass after 4, and then he went away... completely. He gave up, but it is an interesting fight to watch. I have it uploaded in the video section... search for Mayweather Judah, and make it show topics... mine is from an HD source and looks really good, so give it a look!
Anyway,

My order:
1. Jose Luis Castillo I (This will be consensus... a lot of people think Castillo definately deserved the victory)
2. Oscar De La Hoya
3. Jose Luis Castillo II
4. Zab Judah
5. Jesus Chavez (El Matador, he fought some scrub early in his career with the same name)
6. DeMarcus Corley
7. Victoriano Sosa
8. Emanuel Burton
9. Reggie Sanders (Early in his career, didn't look very good against a guy who ended up with a losing record)
10. Ricky Hatton
...

...

...

39. Arturo Gatti

Thanks mate, il give the Judah fight a watch, cheers.

[Burning Desire]

Are you kidding? That fight was pretty much domination by Floyd. I had it 118-110 (117-111 I could see too. 116-112 is a stretch).

I'd switch the Burton fight to 3. It was probably the most physical fight Floyd was in.

I thought the 2nd fight was clear cut win for Mayweather but it was still not an easy fight for Mayweather, he wasn't ever troubled though and fought cautiously to win a boring UD.

[warp1432]

I didn't find it that boring as people made it out to be. Mayweather showed that he could actually deal with Castillo and still did some combinations which made it good.

Then again I really don't find fights boring as long as they are throwing punches.

[Fox McCloud]

Are you kidding? That fight was pretty much domination by Floyd. I had it 118-110 (117-111 I could see too. 116-112 is a stretch).

I'd switch the Burton fight to 3. It was probably the most physical fight Floyd was in.

Wow, I certainly didn't see the rematch being an easy dominant win for Mayweather at all. I think Castillo did a hell of a lot better than Chavez to be honest.

Burton was physical, but Floyd beat him up, plain and simple.

[warp1432]

Maybe I should watch it again, but the first two times I've both had it pretty dominant. I don't think he was roughed up at all and even when he did lose rounds I thought he was still in control the whole time.

What was your scorecard? 115-113? That's usually the general conception, but I cannot just not see it that way. What rounds did you score for Castillo so I know what to look for? Not critizing your juding, just wondering about mine.

[Burning Desire]

Maybe I should watch it again, but the first two times I've both had it pretty dominant. I don't think he was roughed up at all and even when he did lose rounds I thought he was still in control the whole time.

What was your scorecard? 115-113? That's usually the general conception, but I cannot just not see it that way. What rounds did you score for Castillo so I know what to look for? Not critizing your juding, just wondering about mine.

If i remember right i had Mayweather winning by 3 rounds i think he won very clear cut. But i don't think it was as easy as your suggesting, but maybe you scored the fight different to me, because of how Mayweather set the pace his ring generalship etc.

[KILLA RIGHT]

Castillo no doubt and Chavez aswell i think a big chunck of the Chavez fight is on youtube

[AK-47]

castillo is a definite
Watch zabs just for a laugh...It was damn funny there was a brawl aswell
You shoulda seen roger mayweather go lmao

[The Monk]

I always enjoy watching the Chavez fight. Chavez was a bull that night but the way Floyd dominated with a masterful display of back foot boxing was very impressive. The way he fights on the ropes is something I wish I was able to do, I bet alot of boxers wish they had ability like that too. Very entertaining fight.