Gerald McClellan, Great, or the Greatest Middleweight?

[The Noose]

I think overall Benn landed the better shots, and more of them.
The major difference is that Benns punches didnt seem to be able to hurt McClellan. Whereas McClellan hurt Benn many times.

McClellan was ahead on points beacuse of the 2 knockdowns. Benn actually won more rounds but less points.

[QueensburyRules]

Ok, I don't think he is the greatest by no means :P but I rank him in the top 20 greatest/best Middleweights of all time.

I respect BoxingScene's oppinion, so what do you guys think? Do you think McClellan is a all time great? He beat Mugabi, Jackson 2x, and was beating Benn before tragedy struck! As well as his physical talents, he was the hardest hitting middleweight in history!

- -Dunno about hardest hitting, but he could very well be exhibit A for boxing's exploitation of its fighters and exhibit A for boxing's exploitation of fighting dog breeds.