Though Catterall lost a controversial split decision in their first fight, he threw 219 more punches and landed 47 more punches than Taylor. The rematch was a much closer fight statistically. Catterall threw 40 more punches than Taylor and landed 14 more. Catterall landed 88 jabs to Taylor’s 60, while Taylor landed 102 power punches to Catterall’s 88. The combatants were separated by 3 or less landed punches in six of the twelve rounds. Two of the judges scored the fight 117-111 while the third judge scored it 116-113.