Advertisement: IBO Boxing
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com
Advertisement

Canelo Lawsuit: Contracts And Statement Of Arbitration Ordered By Court

Saul ‘Canelo’ Alvarez remains in search of answers regarding the language in the contract existing between his promoter and broadcast partner.

By Monday, the courtroom overseeing their multimillion-dollar lawsuit will have that information.

It was a good week for Alvarez’s attorneys, who saw a ruling in their favor regarding its Notice of Related Civil Cases filing, requesting for the two existing complaints in this ongoing legal battle to be heard in the same courtroom.

The U.S. District Court for the Central District of California agreed with Alvarez, as both their case along with the one filed by DAZN Media, Inc.—requesting the case be moved back to federal court—are now in the hands of Hon. Percy Anderson.

A hard deadline is now in place for the defendants—DAZN, Golden Boy Promotions and Oscar de la Hoya, et al—to submit the existing contracts to the court.

“The Court orders the parties to meet and confer and file, by no later than October 26, 2020, copies of both contracts at issue in the litigation,” Judge Anderson stated to all involved parties in an official order, a copy of which has been obtained by BoxingScene.com. “Although the Declaration of David Livshiz (one of several attorneys representing DAZN) filed in support of the Notice of Removal appears to quote the arbitration clause of one of the two contracts, neither the Complaint nor the Notice of Removal attaches the contracts.

“Because the contracts contain confidentiality provisions, the Court authorizes the parties to file those contracts under seal.”

canelo-alvarez (8)_12

DAZN Media, Inc.—one of nine specific defendants named in Alvarez’s lawsuit seeking damages of at least $280 million—file a Notice of Removal earlier in the month, seeking for the case to be moved from Los Angeles Superior Court back into federal court where the case first began this past September. Alvarez initially filed a lawsuit with the U.S. District Court on September 8, with the case dismissed without prejudice just three days later due to lack of jurisdiction.

The order from Hon. Anderson in the dismissal was for Alvarez’s team to amend its filing to accurately identify the defendants and their location. Such measures were taken by The Maloney Firm, representing Alvarez and S.A. Holiday Inc., only for the case to have been filed in state court rather than resubmitted in the federal courthouse.

Rather than respond to receipt of acknowledgement, the law firm of Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz PC—representing DAZN Media Inc.—filed a Notice of Removal to Federal Court on October 8, citing Diversity Jurisdiction as grounds for removal. Ground for the filing alleged that the case is a matter of citizens of different states and citizens of foreign states.

Alvarez is a citizen of Mexico; DAZN Media, Inc. is a principal business in and a citizen of the State of New York while parent company DAZN Limited (nee Perform Investment Limited, as named in the complaint) is a business entity organized under the laws of the United Kingdom, with its principal places of business in London, England and the State of New York.

Mexico’s Alvarez (53-1-2, 36KOs) filed a complaint alleging breach of contract, intentional interference with contract, negligent interference with contract; fraud and concealment; and breach of fiduciary duty. The pound-for-pound king and three-division titlist is seeking damages of at least $280 million, the remaining balance on his contract with Golden Boy Promotions (GBP) for services provided to DAZN-USA upon their record-breaking 11-fight, $365 million deal reached in October 2018.  

DAZN North America, Inc., DAZN Media Inc., DAZN US LLC., Perform Investment Limited (now DAZN Limited), Golden Boy Promotions LLC, Golden Boy Promotions Inc. and Oscar de la Hoya, Alvarez’s promoter are all named as defendants.

A major sticking point in the case is whom exactly owes Alvarez the money if in fact he is entitled to a full payout. It has been learned that the terms of the deal call for DAZN to pay Golden Boy Promotions at least $40 million per show involving Alvarez, who is not directly involved in that contract other than his promoter delivering his services.

Golden Boy has a separate contract with Alvarez, calling for the California-based promotional outfit to pay Alvarez a minimum of $35 million per fight which began with his May 2019 middleweight title unification win over Daniel Jacobs.

Alvarez is just three fights into his 11-fight deal, the first fight coming at a discount of sorts as he earned $15 million for a 3rd round knockout of Rocky Fielding in December 2018. Alvarez has not fought since an 11th round knockout of Sergey Kovalev to claim a light heavyweight belt last November in Las Vegas. The fight came days after the revelation of the fractured relationship between Alvarez and de la Hoya, beginning with the manner in which he was stripped of one of his middleweight titles last summer.

Ordered negotiations with IBF mandatory challenger Sergiy Derevyanchenko instead exposed a breakdown in communication between Alvarez and Golden Boy Promotions. Several deadlines were missed along with ordered purse bids delayed before a decision was reached for Alvarez to forcefully vacate his title.

Soon thereafter came an agreement to face Kovalev, although the damage was done by that point. A decision was made to move forward in a professional capacity, with that part of the relationship to have continued in the form of a shot at unbeaten super middleweight titlist Billy Joe Saunders this past May.

The event fell through due to the ongoing coronavirus pandemic, which has proved problematic in getting Alvarez and DAZN on the same page for financial terms regarding a fight absent fans given the current global health crisis. Alvarez conditionally agreed to a purse reduction, though the two sides never came close to agreeing on a specific figure.

As time was wasted, Alvarez instead took measures to get what he feels is contractually owed to him. The bombshell lawsuit has prompted all involved parties to further discuss a plan for the sport’s leading attraction to return to the ring sooner rather than later.

An hours-long meeting held in late September offered hope for resolution. Instead, Alvarez proceeded with his ongoing lawsuit, with the complaint making the rounds before winding up back in the original courthouse as where the case began nearly two months ago.

Previous comments from the defendant side suggest that both DAZN and Golden Boy prefer for this case to move forward to arbitration. Before that can happen, the court needs to proof of such terms given the Notice of Removal filed by DAZN Media suggesting such existing language.

“The Court additionally orders the parties to file a Statement Regarding Arbitration by no later than October 26, 2020,” requested judge Anderson. “Indicating whether any party plans to seek to enforce the arbitration provisions allegedly contained in the contracts, and any defenses to the enforcement of those alleged arbitration provisions that a party plans to assert.”

Jake Donovan is a senior writer for BoxingScene.com. Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by Kzbox on 10-25-2020

I think its weak af for Canelo to try get out of this contract because they want him to fight better opposition just ridiculous if they were holding him back making him fight weak opposition then i would understand this…

Comment by Boxing-1013 on 10-25-2020

[QUOTE=Al Broker;20837727]Says the GGG fanatic.[/QUOTE] GGG has flaws and stuff to criticize. Just the stuff he gets critiqued for on here is way over the top. Like how some people try and say Canelo got 6 rounds in either fight…

Comment by Dustin Tanner on 10-25-2020

I don't think he's ducking anyone he just has to make sure that the business is done correctly before he steps in the ring

Comment by Al Broker on 10-25-2020

[QUOTE=Boxing-1013;20837696]I don't really get into the weeds on details with Canelo fanatics. What's the point. Their mind is made up already[/QUOTE] Says the GGG fanatic.

Comment by Boxing-1013 on 10-25-2020

[QUOTE=Al Broker;20837657]When you can’t refute points your type of reply is expected. ;)[/QUOTE] I don't really get into the weeds on details with Canelo fanatics. What's the point. Their mind is made up already

ADD COMMENT VIEW COMMENTS (43)
Advertisement
Top Headlines
Sebastian Fundora: This Is Another Chance To Show I'm Not Just A Freak That's Tall Thurman: My Gut Says Spence Wins; He Better Not Let Garcia Land One Of Those Bricks Arthur: If Yarde Is Stupid Enough To Think I Haven't Got Power, He'll Soon Find Out Daily Bread Mailbag: Spence-Garcia, Crawford, Dubois-Joyce, More Angel Garcia: Danny Has Bigger Name Than Spence; Not Coming In As An Opponent Spence: Brook Definitely Is Damaged Goods; Crawford Did What He Was Supposed To Do Billy Joe Saunders Dominates Martin Murray Over Twelve Anthony Yarde: People Don’t Care About Excuses, There's a Job To Be Done Vito Mielnicki Jr. Confident His Abilities Are Growing Under Goossen Lyndon Arthur Hopes To Use Yarde as Springboard To World Title Fight Crawford: Spence Fight Not Important, I Don't Need Him For My Legacy - He Needs Me! Cardozo, Romero Make Weight For Interim-WBA 122-Pound Clash Has Canelo Alvarez Made a Mistake? Spence: I Picked Danny Garcia So I Could Rise To The Occasion WBC Prez Views Canelo vs. Spence as Mega-Fight in Future Errol Spence vs. Danny Garcia: Judges, Referee For Fight Saturday Night Fundora vs. Ahmed, Lopez vs. Santana - Weights Errol Spence, Danny Garcia - Ready For Showdown in Texas Billy Joe Saunders Dominates, Batters Martin Murray For Wide Decision Billy Joe Saunders vs. Martin Murray - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard James Tennyson Destroys Josh O'Reilly in One Round Lerrone Richards Wins Matchroom Debut, Shannon Courtenay Bounces Back Claressa Shields Shreds Savannah Marshall: She Lives Off That Amateur Win Clay Collard, Robeisy Ramirez To Stay Busy on Stevenson-Clary Card Errol Spence-Danny Garcia Weigh-In Results From Dallas Zach Parker-Cesar Nunez Pulled From Saunders-Murray Bill Due To Late Positive COVID Test Arum: Wilder Has No Rights To Third Fury Fight, Claim Will Be Denied Anthony Yarde, Lyndon Arthur - Ready For War Yunieski Gonzalez To Face Alex Theran in Miami, Florida Martin Murray: Saunders Fight A Few Years Late But We're Both Looking Forward To It Spence: Weird People On Twitter Told Me, 'I Wish You Would've Died' In Car Accident Mike Tyson: YouTube Stars Make Boxing Alive - UFC Was Kicking Our Butt! Saunders: Four, Five Weeks Not Enough Time For Smith To Prepare To Beat Canelo Martin Murray: I Don't Think Saunders Has Fought Anyone Like Me Nazarena Romero Battles Julieta Cardozo for Interim-WBA Title in Argentina Hearn Wants To See Tyson Fury at Ringside at Joshua-Pulev We Can't Know 'The Truth' About Errol Spence Until We See Him Fight Danny Garcia Ashley Theophane Reflects on Career as Sam Eggington Clash Nears Morgan Believes a Knockout is Needed To Defeat Tim Tszyu Foreman: If Mike Tyson Has 3 More Exhibitions Like That - I'd Back Him Over Any Contender
Advertisement
Advertisement
Latest Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement