Canelo-Jacobs: Adalaide Byrd Included In NSAC's Judging Pool

By Keith Idec

If you think the ludicrous scorecard Adalaide Byrd submitted for the first Canelo Alvarez-Gennady Golovkin fight would have eliminated her from consideration for judging another Alvarez fight, guess again. has learned that Byrd was included in the pool of potential judges Nevada State Athletic Commission executive director Bob Bennett sent recently to representatives for Daniel Jacobs and Alvarez. Brooklyn’s Jacobs (35-2, 29 KOs) has been very open since signing to box Alvarez (51-1-2, 35 KOs) about the urgent need for the most competent group of judges possible to score their middleweight title unification match May 4 at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas.

Fighters and their teams have the right to contest the use of objectionable judges, but ultimately it is up to the NSAC to assign judges to fights in Nevada. Typically, the NSAC has acquiesced once objections are made in order to avoid conflicts once fights are scored.

canelo-jacobs (4)_1

Byrd’s inclusion in the Alvarez-Jacobs pool is particularly perplexing because she scored Alvarez a 118-110 winner over Golovkin in a 12-round middleweight title fight in which Golovkin was at the very least extremely competitive with Alvarez in September 2017 at T-Mobile Arena in Las Vegas.

Nevada’s Byrd strangely scored 10 of those 12 rounds for Alvarez, who lost 115-113 on the scorecard of Nevada’s Dave Moretti. Connecticut’s Don Trella scored the first Alvarez-Golovkin fight a draw (114-114), which rendered it a split draw.

Moretti and Trella also are among the judges Bennett included in the pool for Alvarez-Jacobs. has been informed that Jacobs’ team has objected to Trella working his fight against Alvarez as well.

When asked by about the potential judges for his fight versus Alvarez, Jacobs didn’t name names. He did, however, indicate that the inclusion of one judge in particular, presumably Byrd, is not up for debate.

“I’ve had my opportunity to think about it,” Jacobs said. “I was presented with the pool of judges that they gave to us. And I think it was laughable at first. There was definitely one that was automatically out, once we got the list. But, you know, I expressed to my team what I felt about not only the judges, but the options of the referees we have.

“I’m just looking forward to getting an honest chance. That’s really all I want – just a true, honest chance. I don’t want any advantage. I don’t want any favoritism towards me. I just want a fair chance to go in there and fight the fighter they consider to be the best in the middleweight division and prove myself. But I don’t want any influence outside the ring to manipulate the decision or what happens inside there.”

Even Oscar De La Hoya, Alvarez’s promoter, admitted in the immediate aftermath of the first Alvarez-Golovkin fight that Byrd’s scorecard wasn’t close to accurate.

All the negative publicity that accompanied that controversial conclusion didn’t prevent the NSAC from assigning Byrd to score another fight just five weeks after the widely disputed split draw between Alvarez and Golovkin. In all, Byrd has judged 42 fights since Alvarez-Golovkin I, almost all of which took place in Las Vegas or Reno, Nevada.

Bennett will suggest three judges to the NSAC at its monthly meeting Wednesday morning in Las Vegas. The three judges and the referee for Alvarez-Jacobs will be approved and assigned at that meeting.

Bennett is not expected to submit the names of Byrd or Trella to the NSAC for assignment because Jacobs’ team has expressed concerns about them judging his fight against Alvarez.

Nevertheless, especially close attention will be paid to those assignments because Alvarez has been involved in at least four fights in Las Vegas in recent years in which at least one of the judges’ scorecards has drawn considerable criticism.

The first instance occurred in September 2013, when Nevada’s C.J. Ross scored Alvarez’s majority-decision defeat to Floyd Mayweather Jr. a draw (114-114) at MGM Grand Garden Arena. The two other judges – Canada’s Craig Metcalfe (117-111) and Moretti (116-112) – scored nine rounds and eight rounds for Mayweather, respectively.

Ross has not judged another professional boxing match since Mayweather-Alvarez.

Ten months later, Alvarez won a closely contested fight with Erislandy Lara by split decision.

Two judges – Moretti (115-113) and New Mexico’s Levi Martinez (117-111) – scored that 12-round, 154-pound bout for Alvarez at MGM Grand Garden Arena. Moretti credited Alvarez with winning seven rounds against Lara, whereas Martinez scored nine of the 12 rounds for Alvarez.

Almost exactly a year after the dubious draw between Alvarez and Golovkin, Moretti (115-113) and New Jersey’s Steve Weisfeld (115-113) scored Alvarez a narrow winner over Golovkin in their middleweight championship rematch. The third judge, Connecticut’s Glenn Feldman, scored the Alvarez-Golovkin rematch a draw (114-114), which accounted for it resulting in a majority-decision win at T-Mobile Arena.

Byrd, meanwhile, was the only judge to have Amir Khan ahead of Alvarez, 48-47, after five rounds in their middleweight championship match in May 2016 at T-Mobile Arena. Alvarez, who was ahead of Khan on the cards of Feldman (48-47) and Nevada’s Glenn Trowbridge (49-46), knocked out Khan in the sixth round.

Jacobs, who arrived in Las Vegas on Tuesday, is well aware of the judging history of Alvarez’s fights in that city.

“It’s definitely something that plays in the back of my mind,” Jacobs said. “But I don’t let it manifest. It’s just one of those things where I know that if I do what I have to do, which I totally see being 100-percent possible, then there’s gonna be no doubt. And then, if I knock Canelo Alvarez out, to some people it’ll be a miracle. But I’m not foreign to those things anyway.”

Keith Idec is a senior writer/columnist for He can be reached on Twitter @Idecboxing.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Eff Pandas on 04-23-2019

How many judges are on this list? Its f#cking embarrassing Byrd is considered among the best judges in NV somehow. Anyone who's looked at her scoring history on Boxrec can see she's been the dissenting judge in a lot of…

Comment by REYESdelBOXEO on 04-23-2019

[QUOTE=Robi13;19683560]Lmao I see you bro! Heck yeah man I'm hyped for that one too!!! Let the best man win!!![/QUOTE] Lmao! That's the best fight of the year so far damn it's gonna be crazy , many people think it's gonna…

Comment by Robi13 on 04-23-2019

[QUOTE=REYESdelBOXEO;19683500]Thanks man , with boxing debates sometimes I like to get in some rounds and carry opponents for a few rounds to torture them , but sometimes I go for the quick 1st round KO. Lol CANELO vs. Jacobs is…

Comment by Bad_Guy on 04-23-2019

Jacobs needs a KO or five KDs to win this fight. He will lose in any other scenario.

Comment by REYESdelBOXEO on 04-23-2019

[QUOTE=Robi13;19671169]Damn, this was fire bro.[/QUOTE] Thanks man , with boxing debates sometimes I like to get in some rounds and carry opponents for a few rounds to torture them , but sometimes I go for the quick 1st round KO.…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (97)
Top Headlines Malignaggi Spits In Lobov's Face at Contentious Press Conference Photos: Serhii Bohachuk Blasts Out Hernandez in Five Ortiz: Wilder Is Only One Who Can Say For Sure If Rematch is Next Pacquiao Embraces Underdog Role in Keith Thurman Fight Macklin Compares The Danger of Wilder To a Young Mike Tyson Malignaggi: I Look Forward To Sinking My Fists Into Lobov's Face Fury: I Came To ESPN To Make Wilder Rematch As Big As Possible Turarov, Oubaali, Joyce Back on July 6, in Kazakhstan, on ESPN+ Emmanuel Rodriguez Has No Excuses Over Tough Loss To Inoue Chris Norrad Confident That He Will Topple Hughie Fury Andrew Moloney on Linking Up With Top Rank, Facing Montoya Anthony Joshua: Andy Ruiz is Championship Level For Sure Joyce: Ustinov Win Proves I'm A Credible Opponent For Joshua Donaire: Figuring Out How To Beat Naoya Inoue Gets Me Excited! Deontay Wilder: Why Not Have Two, Three Fights With Luis Ortiz? Prograis vs. Taylor Will Have More at Stake Than WBSS Throne Dubois Plans To Do Damage on Gorman, Make a Statement Harvey Horn Added To Dubois-Gorman After Moving To 6-0 Wilder: Breazeale's Body Language Changed After First Right Whyte: Fury Makes No Sense, He's Always Contradicting Himself! Ronald Johnson Returns To The Ring on 6/15 in The Phillipines Raquel Miller, Jonathan Esquivel Get KO Wins at Gardens Casino Wilder Forces Us To Confront Our Fears & Joys In Boxing Fandom Roach Expects Pacquiao's Speed To Be Too Much For Thurman Wilder Manager Sees Joshua or Fury as More Likely For 2020 Kiko Martinez Plans To Return To 122-Pounds, Eyes World Title Ugas Hopes a Win Over Omar Figueroa Leads To World Title Shot Jeyvier Cintron Feels No Pressure Ahead of Koki Eto Eliminator Wilder: This Won't Be Like Lewis-Bowe, Joshua FIght Will Happen Jhonny Gonzalez Blasts Out Rafael Hernandez For Regional Belt Tyson Fury Praises Wilder For Big KO, Takes Dig at Joshua Photos: Gary Russell Jr. Retains, TKO of Kiko Martinez in Five Lipinets-Molina Targeted For July 20 Pacquiao-Thurman PPV Alantez Fox Drops, Stops Nick Brinson in Sixth Round Felix Alvarado Gets Dominant Win Over Reiya Konishi Juan Manuel Lopez, Emiliano Garcia Ends in a Majority Draw Jesus Rojas Drops Luis Castillo Three Times For TKO in Three Naoya Inoue: I Look Forward To Fighting Nonito Donaire Argenis Mendez: I Thought I Won, He Didn't Do Anything To Me Saunders: I Want Callum Smith - Canelo, GGG Don't Want My Style

Latest Active Forum Threads