Boxingscene's 2010 Y/E Awards: Prospect Of The Year

By Jake Donovan

If boxing is left with a 2010 season that was best known for what didn’t take place at the top level, then at the very least it could have left us with hope and promise for the future.

It did.

While it remains a struggle to piece together all of the big fights for which the public clamors, it hasn’t slowed the flow of traffic at the prospect level.

Thanks to stateside prospect-based series on various networks, more fighters than ever before are provided with the opportunity to make a name for themselves on the way up rather than being forced to toil in obscurity while awaiting their chance at prime time exposure.

Two stood out more so than any other, to where both are on the verge of title contention.

That they have both advanced to the contender stage before year’s end perhaps challenge the criteria that goes into recognizing the best prospects in the sport.

Still, that both are still on the rise qualifies them as fighters that continue to learn while they earn.

One started out a little further back than the other yet managed to catch up before the end of the year in terms of career progress.

With that comes the…


The irony of 2010 serving as a huge breakout campaign for Miguel Angel Garcia (24-0, 20KO) was that it began with the cancellation of what was supposed to be the toughest test of his young career.

Big things were promised when the year began for the youngest member of a fighting family that includes older brother and former 130 lb. titlist Robert Garcia, who currently mans his corner. Having recently graduated from California’s Ventura County Police Academy at the time, Garcia was slated for a huge step up fight on the inaugural episode of Fox Sports’ ‘Top Rank Live’ boxing series.

So important was the fight that he invited his fellow graduates to attend the show at the Hard Rock Hotel and Casino in Las Vegas, Nevada. All that came of everyone’s night was disappointment. Visa issues forced his scheduled opponent, Joksan Hernandez off of the show, leaving Garcia without a dance partner for the night.

The fight was never rescheduled, and Garcia was forced to settle for a tune-up bout a couple of weeks later, with his Fox Sports debut coming a couple of months later.

So began the run of the year’s brightest prospect.

A tough fight was promised against battle-tested veteran Tomas Vila in their April headlining bout. It was supposed to be the fight where we’d find out the stuff of which Garcia’s chin and fighting heart were made.

Those questions would have to be answered on another night. Garcia never gave Villa a chance to test either area, dropping him twice inside of a minute in scoring the quickest knockout of his career.

It was that moment when Top Rank truly realized what they hand on their hands, fast-tracking the Oxnard native towards title contention. An August showdown with featherweight spoiler Cornelius Lock – which also aired on Top Rank Live – saw Garcia score the biggest win of his career to date. A pair of knockdowns paved the way for an 11th round stoppage and the guarantee of a mandatory featherweight title shot sometime in 2011.

Garcia put a final exclamation point on his breakout campaign with a violent 5th round knockout of former junior featherweight title challenger Olivier Lontchi in a December preliminary pay-per-view appearance. The statement came at the perfect time, as Top Rank revealed earlier in the day that plans for a featherweight unification between Juan Manuel Lopez and Yuriorkis Gamboa were on hold.

While it meant bad news for the boxing world, it leaves open two opportunities for Garcia to pursue as he eyes a title shot at some point in 2011. A win over either would set the bar mighty high for the rest of the sport when it comes time to discussing the best fighters of the year 12 months from now.

If that day should come, he can take comfort in knowing that his pursuit of excellence came with the honor of being recognized as’s 2010 Prospect of the Year.


Some will glance at this part and question how he didn’t run away with top honors for this category.

Others will note his contender status as well as the fact that he was named one of the top prospects of 2010, and wonder just how long the prospect label can apply to a fighter’s career.

Somewhere in the middle, the wildly popular 20-year old makes his way to runner up status on the pages.

A year after the whispers begun of a red-headed, freckle-faced Mexican one day serving as a future pound-for-pound king, Alvarez enjoyed a breakout campaign in 2010, going 5-0 and garnering more publicity and attention with each passing bout.

Providing the greatest push for his career was a pair of high-profile chief support bouts on Golden Boy-promoted pay-per-view events.

An appearance on the May 1 card headlined by Floyd Mayweather’s 12-round dominance of Shane Mosley saw Alvarez survive a few rocky moments early on to come back and stop Jose Miguel Cotto in the ninth round of their welterweight bout.

Four months later, Alvarez became the talk of the town with an emphatic sixth round knockout of former welterweight king Carlos Baldomir. More so than the highlight-reel show-stealing moment itself was the reception he received from the boisterous crowd at the Staples Center in Los Angeles, providing the revelation to Golden Boy Promotions that on its hands was a superstar in the waiting.

His celebrity status in Mexico prompted his handlers to push for HBO Latino to get in on the act, agreeing to air his December bout with Lovemore N’Dou, which also aired live on Mexican television network giant Televisa. The fight was HBO Latino’s first regularly scheduled bout (excluding pay-per-view replays) since the end of Golden Boy’s Boxeo de Oro series five years ago.

The win over N’Dou wasn’t exactly Alvarez’ brightest moment, but the foundation has already been laid. Next up is a headlining slot in a March telecast of HBO’s Boxing After Dark, which may see the Mexican in his first alphabet title shot. If not on that night, then most certainly by his next fight.

Either way, it will officially serve as the end of his days as a prospect, thus ending the debate of where he rates on these pages. However, it doesn’t remove the shine from his rising star status.

Honorable Mention: Hard hitting super middleweight Edwin Rodriguez scored four knockouts in 2010, three of them televised including a one-sided beatdown of James McGirt Jr on Shobox… Mercito Gesta added power to his game in 2010, scoring knockouts in three of his four bouts in the past year, as he continues to serve as a favorite on the Spanish televised boxing circuit… Christopher Martin announced his presence this past summer with a big win over fellow unbeaten prospect Chris Avalos, one of five victories he posted in 2010. The bout aired on Showtime, though the San Diego native has become a fixture on Telefutura Solo Boxeo… 2008 Olympic Gold medalist James “Chunky” DeGale continues to dominate headlines in the United Kingdom, racking up four knockouts in as many fights in 2010. Chief among them was an eye-catching ninth-round stoppage of super middleweight contender Paul Smith in just DeGale’s ninth pro contest…  Others receiving votes among the staff include a pair of 2008 U.S. Olympic boxers in Sadam Ali and Demetrius Andrade; a pair of18-year old junior welterweight newcomers in Jose Benavidez and Frankie Gomez; and undefeated British super middleweight prospect George Groves.

For more Year End Awards 2010:

Round, Robbery, & Event

Knockout: TBA

Jake Donovan is the Managing Editor of Follow Jake on Twitter at or submit questions/comments to [email protected] 
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Soundtraveler on 01-03-2011

I think you need to add Undefeated Middleweight [B]Fernando Guerrero[/B] to the list, he is young, shows TONS of heart - draws over 5,000 people in Maryland consistently, he fights smart, has good power in both hands and breaks down…

Comment by SCtrojansbaby on 01-02-2011

Somebody needs to define prospect but I'll say anybody 25 or under who has never had a major title is a prospect. 1.Saul Alvarez 2.Nathan Cleverly 3.Mikey Garcia 4.Antonio Demarco 5.James Degale 6.Juan Carlos Salgado 7.Kell Brook 8.Tyson Fury 9.Danny…

Comment by RubenSonny on 01-02-2011

Thats a fair explanation :fing02: cant wait to see where these guys go.

Comment by JakeNDaBox on 01-02-2011

[QUOTE=NANI LOC;9885718]I meant Ring Magazine and everybody who overrates him is calling him prospect of the year.[/QUOTE] I don't think Ring Magazine has yet announced its Year End awards (not to mention that Prospect Of the Year isn't one of…

Comment by JakeNDaBox on 01-02-2011

[QUOTE=RubenSonny;9885420]one of the most underrated is Jesse Vargas that kid is the future.[/QUOTE] I like Vargas, but see him as still being a prospect in 2011. My rule of thumb for this category is that I don't like to vote…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (25)
Top Headlines Jessie Vargas Training With Freddie Roach, Still Eyes Kell Brook Photos: Chris Eubank Jr. Grinding Hard For James DeGale Clash Ramez Mahmood Looks Ahead To Return, Targets Titles in 2019 Kell Brook in Line For a Couple Big Fights in America, Says Hearn De La Hoya: Jacobs Jumped on Canelo Fight, GGG Not So Much Frank Warren Breaks Down Dubois, Adams Card on March 8 Keith Thurman - Twenty-Two Months Later Jacobs: I'll Beat Canelo - I'm Faster, Taller, More Range Than GGG Don King Fears For Joe Joyce: Heaven Help Him With Stiverne WBC Prez: Pacquiao Was Not 100%, Floyd Rematch Will Be Huge Badou Jack Clarifies Trainer's "Mike Tyson" Corner Instructions Photos: Jaime Munguia, Takeshi Inoue - Face To Face at Workouts Photos: Tug Nyambayar, Claudio Marrero, Colbert - Workouts Photos: Adam Kownacki, Gerald Washington - Putting in Work Photos: Keith Thurman, Josesito Lopez - Open Workouts Pedro Moreno vs. Ramon Mascarena Tops New Blood Card Stiverne: Joe Joyce? I'll Knock Him Out, Then I'll KO Joshua! Pacquiao-Broner Show Tracking Toward 400,000 PPV Buys Thurman Admits Past Hand Injury Will Require More Monitoring Anthony Joshua's Opponent Could Be Determined This Week Warrington-Galahad Purse Bid Postponed To February 5 Photos: Liam Smith, Sam Eggington - Go Face To Face in Liverpool Oleksandr Usyk To Return in Mid-May In U.S. As A Heavyweight Michael Conlan vs. Ruben Garcia Hernandez on March 17, ESPN+ Joe Joyce Promises Pain: Bermane Stiverne Disrespected Me! Josesito Lopez: I Know People Are Overlooking Me vs. Thurman Badou Jack Eager For Browne Rematch Once Cleared For Return Arum: Wilder-Fury Needed a Promoter and a Megaphone Amir Khan: Terence Crawford Is A Better Legacy Fight Than Brook Frank Warren on Wilder-Fury II, Frampton's Future, Warrington Lyon Woodstock Takes a Swipe at British Champ Sam Bowen Carlos Takam Feels Time is Right For Dereck Chisora Rematch Roach: Pacquiao, With Two Hands, Does Much Better With Floyd Reymart Gaballo, Romero Duno Get Opponents For February 9 Canelo: Beating Jacobs I'll Be One Step Away From Undisputed Brian Ceballo Staying Level-Headed, Taking Things Step By Step Ellerbe: Pacquiao Has Many Options at 147 - But Not Mayweather David Lemieux vs. John Ryder Possible For Canelo-Jacobs Card Crawford-Khan: Madison Square Garden Chosen as Site Francisco Vargas Vows Revenge: I'm Not Impressed By Berchelt

Latest Active Forum Threads