Benavidez Edges Herrera For Title, Outcome Disputed

By Jake Donovan

The concern heading into the HBO-televised opener was that Mauricio Herrera was too much for Jose Benavidez Jr. at this stage of the young boxer's career. For the second time this year, however, the veteran boxer proved no match for the ringside judges.

An interim title reign comes to a bitter end for Herrera, who landed on the business end of yet another widely controversial decision as Benavidez escapes with the win and a 140 lb. title Saturday evening at The Cosmopolitan in Las Vegas, Nevada.

Scores were 116-112 (twice) and an eye-opening 117-111 card from Dave 'Not Carl' Moretti. 

Herrera jumped out to an early lead, walking down the rail thin Benavidez Jr., who took several rounds to get going. The 22-year old boxer from Phoenix settled down in round four, putting in good work to the body and making use of his significant height and reach advantages.

The tide turned back in favor of the defending interim titlist midway through the fight, as Herrera drove Benavidez to the ropes with digging body shots. Both fighters let it all hang out in the 12th and final round, fighting as if the decision was very much on the table.

As it turned out, Herrera needed several knockdowns in order to leave with his belt still intact. The wide scores give Benavidez Jr. his first title. The former amateur standout advances to 22-0 (15KOs).

Herrera was forced to revisit the disappointment he endured earlier this year in Puerto Rico, where he was believed to have outfought World 140 lb. king Danny Garcia only to not get shown any love from the judges. History repeats itself, as he suffers his second loss in three fights in falling to 21-5 (7KOs). 

Jake Donovan is the Managing Editor of, as well as a member of Transnational Boxing Ratings Board and the Boxing Writers Association of America. Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Mammoth on 10-12-2018

Poor Herrera........

Comment by BattleAxePurist on 12-14-2014

[QUOTE=doubletake;15191694]If you count getting smacked around on the ropes most of the time, then Benavidez won lol[/QUOTE] So smacks to the guard are the same as single clean hard shots. ok

Comment by doubletake on 12-14-2014

[QUOTE=RyunosukeRonin;15191679]If you count pitty-pat arm punches that are just there to occupy time then Herrera won lol[/QUOTE] If you count getting smacked around on the ropes most of the time, then Benavidez won lol

Comment by BattleAxePurist on 12-14-2014

If you count pitty-pat arm punches that are just there to occupy time then Herrera won lol

Comment by lazaron72 on 12-14-2014

Benavides lost . Bigg robbery in Las Vegas by top rank and bob arum . This guy won't get far , got nothing at 140 . Big robbery .

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (61)
Top Headlines Bradley Skeete Reacts To Talk of Gary Corcoran Clash Canelo's Deal With DAZN is 10 Fights, $365 Million Guarantee Iain Butcher vs. Ukashir Farooq For British Title on Nov. 30 Arum: Nobody Sees Al Haymon or Talks To Him - It's Not Normal! Dereck Chisora Inks Management Deal With David Haye Exciting Card Scheduled for the WBO Convention in Panama Farmer: I'm Still Learning on The Job Every Day, It's Just Scary Canelo: Mayweather Should Return The Right Way - Fight Me! Jason Moloney Confident of Shocking Emmanuel Rodriguez Canelo: I'm Taking a Big Risk Entering Fielding's Comfort Zone Juan Heraldez-Maynard Allison Set For Mayweather Card, 10/27 Photos: Canelo, Rocky Fielding - Size Each Other Up in NYC Marcus Browne Arrested, 3rd Domestic Incident Since December Miguel Berchelt vs. Miguel Roman - Undercard Revealed Wilder Manager To Hearn: After Fury Fight, We Can Talk Joshua DAZN To Stream Canelo-Fielding Card, Future Canelo Fights Dmitry Bivol: I Want To Unify All Four Belts Like Usyk Did Tevin Farmer To Gervonta Davis: Enough Talk, I Want You Next! Dmitry Bivol vs. Jean Pascal is Confirmed For November 24, HBO Crawford vs. Spence - CompuBox Head To Head Analysis Khabib's Dad Wants Mike Tyson, Loma Sr. For Mayweather Bout Crawford-Benavidez ESPN Show Averaged 2.245 Million Viewers Mark Heffron To Vie For Vacant British Belt, Welborn Vacates Jarrell Miller Moving Forward With Plan To Win WBA 'Regular' Belt Crawford Frustrated at Times; "I Don't Get the Credit I Deserve" Arum: Mayweather Wouldn’t Have Gone For KO Like Crawford Kautondokwa's Promoter Expects Saunders To Bounce Back Zolani Tete Hopes Mayweather Sr. Will Provide Boost in WBSS Johnny Garton Expects a Real Fire Fight With Gary Corcoran Kell Brook Aims For December Fight, No Issue With 147 For Khan Ali Akhmedov Rolls Forward With Another Knockout Victory WBC Prez: Canelo Shut Mouths, Showed He's Better Than GGG! Nathan Gorman is Hounding Hatton For Daniel Dubois Fight Dmitry Bivol vs. Jean Pascal in Play For November 24 Regis Prograis Sees Future at 147, Eyes Errol Spence Cormier: Khabib is Crazy, Mayweather Will Beat Him Up Bad! Canelo: The WBC Has Been My Family Since The Beginning Dorticos' Coach Confident Second Time is The Charm in WBSS Miguel Roman Training Hard, Confident of Shocking Berchelt Photos: Canelo Honored By The WBC, Belted By Sulaiman

Latest Active Forum Threads