Benavidez Edges Herrera For Title, Outcome Disputed

By Jake Donovan

The concern heading into the HBO-televised opener was that Mauricio Herrera was too much for Jose Benavidez Jr. at this stage of the young boxer's career. For the second time this year, however, the veteran boxer proved no match for the ringside judges.

An interim title reign comes to a bitter end for Herrera, who landed on the business end of yet another widely controversial decision as Benavidez escapes with the win and a 140 lb. title Saturday evening at The Cosmopolitan in Las Vegas, Nevada.

Scores were 116-112 (twice) and an eye-opening 117-111 card from Dave 'Not Carl' Moretti. 

Herrera jumped out to an early lead, walking down the rail thin Benavidez Jr., who took several rounds to get going. The 22-year old boxer from Phoenix settled down in round four, putting in good work to the body and making use of his significant height and reach advantages.

The tide turned back in favor of the defending interim titlist midway through the fight, as Herrera drove Benavidez to the ropes with digging body shots. Both fighters let it all hang out in the 12th and final round, fighting as if the decision was very much on the table.

As it turned out, Herrera needed several knockdowns in order to leave with his belt still intact. The wide scores give Benavidez Jr. his first title. The former amateur standout advances to 22-0 (15KOs).

Herrera was forced to revisit the disappointment he endured earlier this year in Puerto Rico, where he was believed to have outfought World 140 lb. king Danny Garcia only to not get shown any love from the judges. History repeats itself, as he suffers his second loss in three fights in falling to 21-5 (7KOs). 

Jake Donovan is the Managing Editor of, as well as a member of Transnational Boxing Ratings Board and the Boxing Writers Association of America. Twitter: @JakeNDaBox

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by BattleAxePurist on 12-14-2014

[QUOTE=doubletake;15191694]If you count getting smacked around on the ropes most of the time, then Benavidez won lol[/QUOTE] So smacks to the guard are the same as single clean hard shots. ok

Comment by doubletake on 12-14-2014

[QUOTE=RyunosukeRonin;15191679]If you count pitty-pat arm punches that are just there to occupy time then Herrera won lol[/QUOTE] If you count getting smacked around on the ropes most of the time, then Benavidez won lol

Comment by BattleAxePurist on 12-14-2014

If you count pitty-pat arm punches that are just there to occupy time then Herrera won lol

Comment by lazaron72 on 12-14-2014

Benavides lost . Bigg robbery in Las Vegas by top rank and bob arum . This guy won't get far , got nothing at 140 . Big robbery .

Comment by doubletake on 12-14-2014

[QUOTE=jas;15190208]Kellerman was outraged by the decision [url][/url][/QUOTE] Good vid, embed:

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (60)
Top Headlines Yunier Dorticos Still Wants Revenge on Gassiev, Plots Return Canelo: I'll Look to KO Golovkin From Very First Round of Rematch Oleksandr Teslenko, Nicholson, Ivan Golub in Action in AC Devin Haney vs. Juan Carlos Burgos on September 28, ShoBox Photos: Bryant Jennings, Hart, Dimitrenko, Stevenson - Workouts Photos: Juan Francisco Estrada Grinds Hard For Superfly 3 Photos: Jayson Velez, Orlando Cruz - Go Face To Face De La Hoya Not Concerned Clenbuterol Will Taint Canelo's Legacy Photos: Frampton, Fury, Jackson, Pianeta - Open Workouts Devin Haney Obtains Promoter's License in California Carl Frampton Insists That He Has Learned From Past Mistakes Carlos Negron Inks Managerial With King Kong Boxing Bellew: I'm Chasing Greatness, Usyk Fight is Looking Likely Now Fury: I'm Still The Same Old G, I Want To Smash Wilder's Face In! Photos: Tyson Fury Looking Very Slim at Open Workout Antonio Tarver Arrested For Domestic Battery in Florida Abel Sanchez: No Beef? I Hope Canelo Stopped Eating Duck Too! Frank Warren: Fury-Wilder Winner Is World's Best Heavyweight Granados: Garcia Wouldn't KO Me, Either; Would Need Judges' Gift Tyson Fury: Let's Face It, Wilder Hasn't Really Fought Anybody Quigg: If Frampton Faces Warrington - Winner Has To Fight Me!'s Television Picks of The Week - August 15 James Branch To Return, October 6 In Leicester Fury: If Pianeta Chins Me - I'll Crawl Over and Kiss His Feet! Euro News: Rossing, Schwarz, Edis Tatli, Formella, Gamhour Ray Beltran: Lomachenko Must Beat Me To Get To Mikey Garcia Hugo Ruiz Makes Quiet Return, Aims To Reclaim World Title Katie Taylor - Documentary To Lift Lid on Split With Her Dad Top Rank's DuBoef on Decision To Go With ESPN, NVBHOF Nod Hearn Reacts To Critics: Miller vs. Adamek is NO Mismatch! Joseph Diaz, Manager To Meet: Decide on Weight Class Future Canelo 30-Day Weight For Golovkin Rematch - 167.4-Pounds Loeffler: Golovkin is 1 Win Away From Breaking Hopkins Record Fury: Wilder Coming Over Because He Knows Where Daddy Lives Arum is Firm: Murata To Face Quigley, Won't Bow To WBA Order Jermain Taylor - Domestic Violence Charges Are Dropped Tony Yoka's Appeal is Rejected, Doping Ban is Upheld By Judge Jacobs-Derevyanchenko Likely Headed to MSG Theater October 27 Derrick Webster Continues Streak, Stops Les Sherrington Mariana Juarez, Jackie Nava in Line To Collide Later This Year

Latest Active Forum Threads