It’s not a big fight but Paul Williams-Carlos Quintana, this Saturday’s HBO Boxing After Dark Welterweight main event (9:45 PM EST/PST), is a bout with ramifications. Williams, off of his win last July over Welterweight stalwart Antonio Margarito, has earned a spot near the top of his class. Quintana is his first fight since and begins the next phase of Williams’ career.
This is Williams’ waiting period.
At 6’2 and with a Heavyweights reach, the 26-year old Williams (33-0, 24 KO, WBO titlist) of Augusta, Georgia is both a physical marvel and a cliché: the high risk, low economic reward fighter. His only recourse in overcoming the cliché, in becoming an economic reward, is to continue to win. It’s a harder task than it appears, more mental than physical.
There’s no firm time and place Williams’ can look to right now that says “shot at World Welterweight champion Floyd Mayweather here” or at least “showdown with Miguel Cotto there.” If frustration sets in, and any degree of lethargy follows, Williams could find himself with the one-loss ignominy that happens upon the dangerous and under known.
The 31-year old Puerto Rican Quintana (24-1, 19 KO) is the sort of fighter who can expose a fighter who isn’t fully focused but it’s unlikely that Williams’ has reached that point just yet. How real then are Quintana’s chances this Saturday? What tests are in store for both men?
Let’s go to the report card.
Speed:
Power:
Defense:
Intangibles:
Overall Report Card: Williams B+; Quintana B
Williams isn’t the fastest man in the Welterweight division but does have quality hand speed and, combined with his sheer size, it makes the speed he possesses that much more frightening for opponents. If the speed that matters in boxing is the ability to land on your opponent before they land on you, then Williams has the best speed one can ask for. His ability to land his long jab first, and then reel off combinations, was valuable in the Margarito fight. It kept Margarito off balance for much of the first two/thirds of the fight even if many of Williams’s best shots missed or were blocked. That didn’t matter because it kept Margarito from getting off. Quintana has decent speed of his own but, to make things work versus Williams, his game will be timing. Against Joel Julio in 2006, Quintana was able to time the pressuring Julio’s rushes with the jab and counter the young man silly. The same strategy saw him bum rushed out of the ring against the more rounded offensive machinery of Miguel Cotto. Williams has the advantage in this category by a decent measure.
Pre-Fight Grades: Williams A-; Quintana B
Williams range reminds many of Tommy Hearns, but his punch should not. Instead, he may be more akin to the 6’2 Welterweight golden oldie Maurice Blocker in this category. While he does have stoppages in five of his last six, few were of the blistering, one punch variety. Williams gets people out of there by overwhelming them. Quintana may be, for a single shot, the slightly better puncher but it’s hard to tell. He hurt Julio on more than one occasion, but then Julio was hurt badly by veteran Cosme Rivera in a later fight which may speak more to his chin than Quintana’s punch. Williams took hard shots form Margarito and stood up so it’s doubtful Quintana gets to him. Neither man has ever stopped a fighter whose chin was considered above average and if you take away the Margarito win for Williams and the Julio win for Quintana, each has a resume that is fairly shallow. Summed up, this is not a puncher’s duel but it won’t be a pillow fight either.
Pre-Fight Grades: Williams B; Quintana B
Like power, this is a category where neither man is exceptional, settling instead for suitably professional. Quintana will attempt to fend off Williams offense with subtle head movement and inside blocking ability. Against Cotto, he attempted that but Cotto was able to swarm around Quintana’s tight elbows. Williams comes at Quintana from entirely different angles than Cotto did (or could), but if he can get into rhythm there could be similar results with him punching around and eventually through Quintana’s guard. Williams’s defensive game is reach-based, specifically using reach to keep his head and body out of range from the full force of Quintana’s shots or to use his long arms to smother incoming fire. Margarito, and even Walter Mathysse, showed that Williams is hittable largely because he gets so aggressive that he leaves himself open. Against Margarito, it was also shown that, as a tough fight wears on, his arms may drop enough to create openings.
Pre-Fight Grades
:
Williams B; Quintana B
If rumors of Williams struggling with his weight are true, then this fight could ask questions about his ability to muster his inner reserves in fueling a body that may be weakened by the scale. Williams has fought a great deal of his fights at the Jr. Middleweight and Middleweight limits; Quintana has always hovered around the Welterweight limit. Williams showed that he could control fatigue and even come roaring back in the Margarito fight, but does a near-eight month layoff make it harder on a body to drop back into what appears to be an unnatural weight? Would Williams even be a Welterweight without the day-before weigh-in rules? Beyond these questions, both have shown solid heart and beard during their limited exposure on bigger stages, with a slight edge to Williams based on his undefeated record and the pride that instills.
Pre-Fight Grades: Williams B+; Quintana B
If Williams is to stumble, it probably won’t be Saturday night. It is his misfortune that an injury to IBF Welterweight titlist Kermit Cintron cancelled what was supposed to be a unification showdown in place of this bout. Is there a curse on Williams WBO belt? Cintron has moved on to his own rematch with the man Williams beat for it, Margarito, and that winner likely moves on to a fight with Cotto. Williams is the pick to score a late stoppage this weekend and then…
Then he finds himself marking time the same way Margarito did for years while under the albatross of a belt that no one significant wanted because of who they would have to go through to get it. High risk. Low reward. For now and the foreseeable future, all Williams can do is win and hope that good things come to those who wait.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com