
By Ronnie Nathanielsz
The scheduled ten-round bout between WBO No. 11 ranked junior middleweight Charles “Killer” Whittaker and the Philippines Jury Noda on October 31 is a mismatch based on both the records of the two fighters and videos of Whittaker’s fights that we have seen.
Whittaker who is from the Cayman Islands has a record of 31-12-1 with 19 knockouts and has won his last seven fights since dropping a ten-round majority decision to Troy Roland in Grand Rapids , Michigan on April 17, 2004. At that time Rowland had a record of 17-1 with 5 knockouts.
Noda, on the other hand has a record of 5-9-1 with 4 knockouts according to boxrec.com and has lost his last six fights. In fact 5 of his 9 losses were by either KO or TKO.
In his last fight on September 13, 2008, Noda was knocked out in the 6th round by Arniel Tinampay in a Philippiune welterweight title fight. His losing streak began when Noda took a fight against the advice of an Australian who was handling him at that time and fought American Charles Bellamy in Tokyo , Japan on January 13, 2007 and was mauled and knocked out in the second round.
Whittaker, in his last fight on June 20, 2008 clashed with Troy Lowry who retired in the 4th round. In one of his tougher battles Whittaker won a twelve round unanimous decision over Jose Miguel Rodriguez Berrio on August 31, 2007. Berrio had a record of 20-1 with 12 KO’s.
A tape of Whittaker’s September 30, 2006 fight against Billy Lyell showed the world-rated Whittaker nailing his opponent with a right uppercut and a crushing right hand to win a 4th round TKO.
Last March 8, 2008 Whittaker clahed with Luther Smith and won by a 1st round TKO when he caught Smith with a hard right and his opponent tried to get up but fell over three times before falling back on the ropes, forcing the referee to call a halt.
The Games and Amusements Board boxing division headed by Dr. Nasser Cruz needs to take a close look at this fight and similar fights which are clearly terrible mismatches which will not only hurt the sport but far more importantly hurt one of our fighters.
It is impossible to understand the concern of the GAB and chairman Eric Buhain over the height and reach advantages of Oscar De La Hoya against Manny Pacquiao while failing to see the obvious mismatches such as the one between world-rated Charles Whittaker who has won his last seven fights and Jury Noda who has lost his last six.
Philboxing.com reported that the Whittaker-Noda encounter is on a fight card being put up by American Boxing Academy owner/manager Ken Smith and promoter Fred Salazar to showcase some of the promising fighters at the ABA Gym according to matchmaker Glenn Salazar. The Whittaker-Noda fight surely doesn’t belong in that category.