By Cliff Rold
Photo © Tom Casino/Showtime
It was all so organic.
That’s the adjective that rolls through my mind as I sit here, one day later, trying to figure out how to critique the third chapter of the rivalry between World Jr. Featherweight champion Israel Vasquez (43-4, 31 KO), Lineal/Ring Magazine/WBC) and former champion #4 Rafael Marquez (37-5, 33 KO). It all just seemed to flow logically from one fight to the next, with increasing ferocity in the ring and admiration from onlookers.
There was no need for multi-part commercials telling fans they needed to see these two go at it and no hollow set-up fights to try and make them think they wanted to see it again.
Instead, Vasquez-Marquez I was made one year ago and the fans that knew what they were looking at said “Hmm, that could be one hell of a good fight.” They were right. From there the rematch, and the rubber match, developed from the merits found in the debut’s seven rounds. They developed because fans wanted to see these two honor themselves and the sport again, and then once more.
In the days leading up to the third fight, there was no reason to issue press releases that trumpeted World champions that weren’t or Hall of Fame credentials that aren’t. When it was concluded last Saturday night, no television announcer had to circle the wagons after a twelve round exercise in tedium and brag about the size of Vasquez or Marquez’s corporate contract. That kind of house hyperbole just wasn’t necessary.
There was no amount of dollars or accolades that could be paid to adequately address what Vasquez and Marquez have put each other through; there’s no amount that could be spent by fans to adequately say thank you.
There’s chatter out there amongst the fans and pundits now, questions about where the efforts of these two rank amongst the great fights, great rivalries, of all-time. There won’t be a right answer except to say that these two earned, in blood, a place in those discussions. From the comfort of my couch, what stands out to me is this: I don’t know of another trilogy of bouts at the World-class level where each fight was better than the last. Zale-Graziano featured a wipeout for Zale in the final chapter; Ali-Frazier meant more to the sport and the world but had a quality dip in the second bout. Vasquez-Marquez went from very good, to great, to an awe-inspiring “saved the best for last” finish.
Other post-fight questions settle on what this rivalry has done for the credentials of each fighter individually. The answer to that is simple. The blows landed and received in their 25 rounds can be viewed, symbolically and vividly, as one-way tickets to Canastota.
The trilogy means more to Vasquez in that sense. Coming into the rivalry with Marquez, Vasquez had built a solid resume but not one that truly stood out. He had some solid wins, some tough losses. Two out of three in this run has changed the perspective on all of that and proven once again that history can not be judged too early.
Now he’s a fighter who found a way to triumph in both of his defining trilogies (let’s not forget the excellent Oscar Larios) and who persevered a decade at 122 lbs. to becomes its true champion twice. He faced everyone he could get in the ring with him, missing the big names of earlier in the decade only to carve his own name without them. He’s come back from off nights (Marcos Licona) to go on solid winning streaks; he’s come back from a knockout loss in a great fight (Larios II) to become a champion; he’s come off the floor to win more than twice; and he’s regained his title after some dared to call him a quitter (in the days between Marquez I & II). Altogether, he’s made it impossible to debate the greats at 122 lbs., including Wilfredo Gomez, without him.
Marquez had the glossier dossier prior to this rivalry but all of this has made his mandate for entry undeniable as well. After three early career stoppage losses that might have doomed him to be just “Juan Manuel’s brother,” Marquez found his way into the ring in 2001 and 02 with American Flyweight great Mark Johnson. Johnson marked his first great rival and Marquez ended Johnson’s prime while emerging victorious in both those bouts. In 2003, he ended the run of another solid American, this one undefeated bantamweight Tim Austin, annexing the IBF belt at 118 lbs. in the process. Seven title defenses later, he stood out as one of the best Bantamweights to come around since the 1980s heyday of Jeff Chandler. His world title victory in the first Vasquez fight and the two subsequent losses put the icing on the cake.
All these words and I still don’t know how to approach a critique of that third fight. I wouldn’t do it justice if I tried.
Overall Vasquez-Marquez Report Card: A+
I wish there was a higher grade than that.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com