By Cliff Rold
Manny Pacquiao-Miguel Cotto is signed and, wrongheaded catch weight agreement or not, it should be a heck of a fight.
It should also leave some fingers well gnawed. Pacquiao-Cotto is big, but there is another event waiting to be bigger. Will we get there?
If so, 2010 could be a watershed year in the contest for affection between missed martial arts (MMA) and boxing. For now, we enter a fascinating bridge period.
On July 11, former NCAA wrestling and professional (WWE) wrestling champion Brock Lesnar (4-1, 2 KO, 1 Sub) avenged his only professional MMA loss versus Frank Mir, solidifying his place as the UFC Heavyweight king. The Mir win followed on the heels of Lesnar’s defeat of MMA legend Randy Couture. Given Lesnar’s look, previous following from the world of performance art, and fighting skills, UFC may be on to its biggest star yet.
As boxing fans know, stardom and stature can always grow. Much depends on opponents. Early in his career, Oscar De la Hoya did decent pay-per-view numbers against the likes of Rafael Ruelas and Genaro Hernandez. The numbers grew as the toughness of opponents did, allowing De La Hoya to set and break records against Pernell Whitaker, Felix Trinidad, and Floyd Mayweather.
People will always pay to see stars. More will pay on the chance to see a star beaten. Lesnar, who drew boos after the Mir rematch with antics which kept him in the headlines for an extra day or two following the bout, is in the enviable position of being a star with a foe many think can defeat him.
More importantly, he has a foe many will pay to see defeat him.
Lesnar has Fedor Emelianenko (30-1, 7 KO, 16 Sub). It could be the MMA equivalent of Ali-Frazier (or at least Holyfield-Tyson) if they can get the two men into a cage.
Boxing has a hell of a counter.
Just as Lesnar has developed into a love-to-hate-him draw, boxing prepares for the return of its version of the same. Former three-division World champion and five-division titlist Floyd Mayweather (39-0, 25 KO) is set to make his way back to the ring for the first time since December 2007. In September, the man who retired as Welterweight champion takes on reigning Lightweight champion Juan Manuel Marquez (50-4-1, 37 KO) in what could be an intriguing affair.
It could ultimately be an h’ourderve.
The fight everyone in boxing wants to see right now is Mayweather versus World Jr. Welterweight champion Manny Pacquiao (49-3-2, 37 KO). More importantly, the question the most people would likely pay to see answered is ‘can Pacquiao beat Mayweather?’ They are rightly regarded as the pound-for-pound standard of recent years and it’s rare for two such fighters to be close enough on the scale to force a showdown.
Of course, there are a great number of variables at play before either Lesnar-Emelianenko or Mayweather-Pacquiao can happen.
Emelianenko had a fight scheduled with former UFC Heavyweight champion Josh Barnett on August 1st under the Affliction banner. Barnett’s latest failed test for performance enhancers will mean a replacement opponent. No matter who Fedor fights, he’ll have to win there, and then actually choose to sign with UFC, to really get the buzz going for a Lesnar fight. Lesnar, conversely, can’t lose on the road to riches.
Pacquiao-Mayweather faces obstacles as well. Pacquiao is now locked in for a November clash with WBO Welterweight titlist Miguel Cotto (34-1, 27 KO) in what could be the most physically exacting fight of his life. The former Flyweight champion has faced bigger men but none as skilled and close to their prime as Cotto. It won’t be an easy victory. Mayweather could have his difficulties with Marquez as well.
Just as challenging, both of their coming fights will be closely watched in terms of pay-per-view sales. Much of the chatter about Mayweather-Pacquiao so far has centered not on who wins but ‘how much?’ Mayweather says the monetary split must favor him. Sales numbers in the fall will be used to strengthen the case for one side or the other.
Lesnar-Emelianenko could be easier to make if both are under contract to the UFC, a benefit of sport centralization, but the money will be too massive to think there isn’t a path to getting Mayweather-Pacquiao done.
If the chips fall into place, prepare for the best round of boxing/MMA debates yet.
In 2007, each sport put forth major shows weeks apart. Boxing provided De La Hoya-Mayweather and UFC offered Chuck Liddell-Rampage Jackson II. Boxing ultimately won the pay-per-view sales race but both sports got explosive media coverage, including the covers of both Sports Illustrated and ESPN the Magazine.
A 2010 which featured Lesnar-Emelianenko and Mayweather-Pacquiao could make 2007 pale in comparison.
De La Hoya-Mayweather was hyped more as ‘give boxing another chance’ than a potentially great fight. UFC was being introduced to many who still hadn’t given it a fair chance. This time can narrow the focus more to the fights in terms of sheer quality.
The world outside both sports will inevitably use the bouts to compare the two fight genres, and some of the fans will argue. However, in the end, a simple truth may win out.
That truth?
A good fight is a good fight.
Look around at the online congregating points for fans of boxing or MMA and one can easily find places to debate either sport on its merits. Website Sherdog is about MMA first but has active and vibrant boxing-only discussion on its message boards. Most major boxing boards have the opposite. The majority of the fans stick to their favorites, but they’re still peeking around the corners at each other.
And nobody ever wants to miss an event.
Both boxing and MMA have a potential event on tap next year. Rather than a competition, the hype on merit and as an indirect showdown of their fields will be a boon to both. Rather than a showdown, it’s a chance for both sports to use each other to full effect and come out stronger.
The promoters on both sides will be happy to be perceived as competing while they laugh all the way to the bank…if the competitors can get them there.
The Weekly Ledger
But wait, there’s more…
Vazquez and the Cubans: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=21084
Khan-Kotelnik Wrap: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=21099
Caballero-Lopez a No Go?: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=21155
Picks of the Week: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=20990
New Pound for Pound: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=21134
Cliff’s Notes…
New divisional ratings should be out sometime this week if they’re not up now...So our own Mark Vester is reporting Arthur Abraham versus the winner of Lucian Bute-Librado Andrade could be used as a go between on the Super Middleweight tournament if there is a delay after Andre Dirrell-Carl Froch. Might getting the IBF belt into the mix also be a factor? This whole area of the scale is insane…So David Haye-Nicolay Valuev? Funny how when the brother with a good chin was on tap, Haye went elsewhere…While not liking that there is a catch weight at all, 145 lbs. should keep Pacquiao-Cotto competitive. Looking forward to this…Will Shane Mosley fight again in 2009?...Blackest Night is the looking like the best comic book event of the decade so far.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com