By Cliff Rold
It would be easy to whip out clichés about crossroads and the relative ages of lions. They might even be fitting in some sense. However, the old standards in describing a fight between two men with a wide age gap also short shrift what we might get on Saturday.
This is just a good match.
Put aside that IBF Light Heavyweight Antonio Tarver (27-4, 19 KO) is 39 or that erstwhile challenger (because he gave up a WBC belt for this bout) Chad Dawson (26-0, 17 KO) is 26. The recent form from both suggests two evenly matched men.
It’s hard to believe really.
In 2006, losing to Bernard Hopkins, Tarver put forth the worst performance of his career and looked shot. His win over Clinton Woods in April of this year was antithetical to the notion.
Dawson in the meantime has shown guts and built credentials with excellent wins against Eric Harding, Tomasz Adamek and, sort of, Glen Johnson. Johnson-Dawson of course happened on the undercard of Tarver-Woods and stole the show. Dawson weather some brutal punishment to escape with the win and keep this fight, the one being built all along, within his sights.
Now it’s here.
Let’s go to the report card(s).
Speed: If age is to be a factor physically, it will be in terms of speed. Both men will be quick at the beginning and Tarver showed exceptional speed early against Woods. As the fight wears on, Dawson is more likely to maintain his speed. One noticeable problem for Tarver, even as he won just about every round of his last three fights, in the Hopkins loss and even a winning third Roy Jones fights before it was a slowdown as rounds passed by. Dawson’s speed kept him alive against Johnson late; as the pressure and punches mounted, he dug deep for fight saving rallies in rapid combination. He can move his hands in close or at range, another advantage when considering how quick his hands get there. Pre-Fight Grades: Dawson A-; Tarver B
Power: Dawson has a good knockout percentage but he’s not really a devastating one-punch guy to date. His best stoppage so far was probably Ian Gardner and that came in round eleven. Against fighters of lesser class, he can be devastating but Tarver is no Epifanio Mendoza or Jesus Ruiz…and Tarver can fire back. It’s been some four years since he decapitated Jones in their second fight and Tarver has had no such highlight since, but don’t let the results distract from a base fact: Tarver is a legitimate one-shot threat. He’s a boxer first so he doesn’t always press his power game, but his best single punches are devastating. Don’t just ask Jones; pull the tapes of the Harding rematch. Dawson, dropped by Harding and Adamek and hurt severely by Johnson, can’t underestimate what Tarver can do with a fully leveraged southpaw left. Pre-Fight Grades: Tarver B+; Dawson B
Defense: The bottom line is, for an athletic fighter, Dawson gets hit too much and for different reasons. Against Johnson, he got hit because Johnson makes guys get hit. His pressure is as effective as anyone’s in Boxing. Against Harding and Adamek, knockdowns came as a result of leaving his hands too low. Tarver also gets hit, but manages distance and fights tall enough to see the incoming, making him a difficult target. Neither man is a defensive genius regardless. Defense in this bout will be predicated on the jab. The man who establishes his stick will be able to set the pace and control what’s coming back at him by keeping his man at the distance he wants. Will Dawson’s youth and speed mean his jab wins or will the experience of Tarver allow him to time Dawson? We find out soon enough. Pre-Fight Grades: Dawson & Tarver B
Intangibles: Tarver, as always, has talked a big game and, to his credit, Dawson has kept up with the chatter in the build-up. Hardcore fans are looking forward t this as much as anything left on the calendar because the hype feels real. The wills in the ring are going to weigh heavy; Dawson will have to build and then maintain a pace which threatens Tarver’s legs while staying wary of the power coming back. So far, he’s fought like a young man with the ability to shoulder the burden. Tarver will have to convince himself he has a hard twelve rounds of back and forth (versus the one-sided nature of all his bouts since Hopkins) still left in him. He’ll also have to maintain faith in his power from start to finish. He did in the third Jones fight and almost stopped Roy late; he did not against Hopkins and basically did anything but go for the KO even when he needed it. He sounds like a fighter with the desire to sacrifice for victory again and his career says, outside Hopkins, he can live up to the billing. Pre-Fight Grades: Dawson B; Tarver B
The Pick: I can see this fight going lots of ways without feeling good about any of them. It's the sort of fight where one guy could win more rounds and but get off the deck a couple times or the sort of fight where attitudes could flare for some point deductions. Dawson is younger, stronger and faster; Tarver remains wily and mean. I can't figure who wins, and I think it goes the full route, so I pick a draw.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com