By Rick Reeno
Background - Last Saturday's event in Manchester has set up a fall bout between Ricky Hatton, the biggest name at 140-pounds, and IBF junior welterweight champion Paulie Malignaggi. The fight has been talked about since last year. Malignaggi was Hatton's backup plan if the Mayweather Jr. fight fell through.
Hatton returned to the ring against Juan Lazcano to win a lopsided twelve-round unanimous decision. In the co-feature, Malignaggi retained his title with a close split-decision over former champion Lovemore N'dou.
Perception From The Outside - Both Hatton and Malignaggi did very little to increase the minor demand for their potential bout. They did very little to impress the viewing audience. Hatton was given a hand-picked opponent and still managed to find himself in rocky waters on at least two occasions. The ref stopping the action in the tenth-round, while Hatton was buzzed, to allow the Hatton corner to tie Ricky's shoe, did not make the performance look any better.
Between the two of them, Malignaggi had the tougher opponent, and it's always hard to motivate yourself for a fighter you previously dominated for twelve-rounds. Because he lacks power, Malignaggi will always have to prepare himself to go twelve-rounds.
In his last two outings, his performances have been below the standard of an elite fighter. Despite the hype, N'dou is tough, but he is not an elite fighter and neither is Herman Ngoudjo.
It could be worse when comparing Malignaggi's outings to the last two of Hatton. Malignaggi has the better chin and the tougher body. I don't think Hatton could have withstood the kind of beating that Miguel Cotto placed on Malignaggi in 2006.
Hatton vs. Malignaggi is bad clash of styles, and that's being nice. It has all the makings of an ugly fight. If Malignaggi is unable to keep Hatton at bay with the jab, the fight will become a close-pitched wrestling match.
Cold Hard Facts - Despite the obvious potential for a boring fight, Malignaggi is by far the biggest name Hatton can land at the weight. Analyzing the other champions, Timothy Bradley, Ricardo Torres and Andreas Kotelnik - they are less known and more dangerous with their ability to punch. Hatton's chin has been shook in his last two fights and Malignaggi's "5" career knockouts, and his name, make him a very handsome proposition.
In the end, there is more money to make with Malignaggi, it's the safe bet (compared to any of the other champions) and it's the road back (in Hatton's mind) to a Mayweather rematch. Malignaggi is not a big puncher, but he punches hard enough for his opponents to respect him. If his punches had no sting, he wouldn't be able to keep fighters like Cotto and N'dou from walking right through him. Given Hatton's stamina issues in the late rounds and his predictable style, Malignaggi has enough ability to outbox him. Lets not forget, Malignaggi has a bad right hand. The hand has been injured several times in the past, and he damaged that very hand last Saturday against N'dou. The right hand could play a big factor in the fight.
Based on what was presented last Saturday, the outcome is tougher to predict than it was last year.