By Cliff Rold (photo by Paul Gallegos)
To paraphrase Hall of Fame great Billy Conn, Paul Williams’s first loss marks the point where he truly begins to learn his craft. Carlos Quintana provided a tough lesson. In the first major upset of the year, Quintana (25-1, 19 KO) lifted the WBO Welterweight title and Williams’s (33-1, 24 KO) tag as the next big thing in the division all in one well swoop.
Quintana wasn’t given a strong chance at victory by many, including myself, and deserves the utmost credit for his performance. His December 2006 loss to fellow Puerto Rican countryman Miguel Cotto appeared to signal that the 31-year old Quintana would at best ride out his career as no more than the game opponent for better foes.
Quintana proved that judging fighters on the weight of a single loss is always folly. That is to be kept in mind as the still only 26-year old Williams moves forward. What must also be kept in mind is that in the first test of how Williams would handle the pressure of the expectations created by his July 2007 win over perennial contender Antonio Margarito, his marks fell short Magna Cum Laude. Where did they fall?
Let’s go to the report card.
Speed: As noted in the pre-fight report, Williams speed would be best utilized when he could use his tremendous reach to create room for his combinations and Quintana would need timing to overcome a deficit in this category. It was mission accomplished for Quintana; not so much for Williams. In a battle of two southpaws, Quintana’s edge in experience, amateur and professional, allowed him to land hard left hands over Williams’s low right hand repeatedly. Also notable was that Williams appeared slower than he has in previous fights. He didn’t appear to beak a hard sweat until nearly a third of the way into the fight and lacked snap in his shots, indicating that the struggle of squeezing his 6’2 frame down to 147 lbs. took a toll.
Pre-Fight Grades: Williams A-; Quintana B
Post-Fight Grades: Williams B; Quintana B
Power: Williams again lived up to the billing that while he might have Tommy Hearns-like range, his power is much more Maurice Blocker. I noted in the pre-fight report that Quintana was likely to have better single shot power and that appeared to be the case all night on Saturday. Williams best shots slapped; Quintana’s snapped. He never had Williams seriously hurt, but it was clear that “The Punisher” was being punished by crafty Carlos. Weight struggles might be an issue here for Williams as well but it’s far more likely that he just isn’t much of a puncher. His game is volume punching, something he did not successfully have enough of to overcome the accuracy of Quintana’s left hand.
Pre-Fight Grades: Williams B; Quintana B
Post-Fight Grades: Quintana B+; Williams B-
Defense: Both got hit, but Williams got hit cleaner on the night. Quintana was able all night to smother Williams best stuff inside and blocked well the incoming fire at range. Williams just seemed to get hit a lot. Like so many long armed, athletic fighters who feel free to hold their hands at waist level, Williams found that against schooled foes, those hands belong quite a bit higher. Williams best defense would have been to use his legs and long arms to keep Quintana at bay. Instead, he let him inside and got punched repeatedly for his error.
Pre-Fight Grades: Williams B; Quintana B
Post-Fight Grades: Quintana B+; Williams B-
Intangibles: Williams’ weight may be seen by some as a rhetorical out in describing the action, but it’s the elephant in the room. In his 34 fights, he has only weighed 147 lbs. or less seven times. Put another way, he’s a highly artificial Welterweight and should probably be at least at 154 lbs. Quintana surged in the late rounds, a stronger sturdier professional much more at home in his body. Would a few pounds have kept Williams from eating left hands? Probably not; it appears that Quintana was just the better man, stylistically, on Saturday. With his back against the wall, a fighter short on big opportunities in his decade in the sport made the most of what would likely have been his last big one. His performance spoke to intangibles the like character and professionalism needed to go along with skills at the highest level. Williams almost kept pace in that regard, never quitting and never ceding the fight. He made Quintana work every step of the way in a very good prizefight.
Pre-Fight Grades: Williams B+; Quintana B
Post-Fight Grades: Quintana A-; Williams B+
Overall Report Card: Quintana B+; Williams B
So where do they go from here? Quintana’s team is already speaking the name Shane Mosley and it would be a just reward for the gameness Quintana showed in the ring on Saturday and in persevering through ten years to get to this stage. Williams will be back and is likely to be a factor for years to come, but his return should be a division higher. The money might be at Welterweight right now, but history says that money will chase up the scale eventually and Williams would do well to try and be the roadblock. He’d also do well to either avoid fellow southpaws or, at the very least, pick his right hand up in the future
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com