By Cliff Rold
Right off the top, let me say how happy it should make every fight fan that former IBF junior lightweight titlist Stevie Forbes (33-9, 5 KO) is getting a crack at boxing’s ‘golden’ ticket. Forbes came of age in the sport at a moment when 130 lbs. was as deep and talented a pool as any in recent memory. Mayweather, Corrales, Freitas, Casamayor… Forbes on his best day would have made a fight with any of them.
As is too often the case though, there’s only so much room at the top. Much as was the experience for Stevie Johnston five pounds up the scale, Forbes was the wrong combination of style and small reward to get a chance to show exactly where he fit. When you’ve read this week from knowledgeable insiders this week that Forbes has a shot, it is because they know what he was and might have been.
Win on Saturday night against former super lightweight, welterweight and junior middleweight champion Oscar De La Hoya (38-5, 30 KO), and all the yesterdays denied Forbes will be trumped by a right now that is all his.
And a Forbes win could be even more than that.
For all the fans who see through the infomercial feel of it all; who see the attempt at a seductive enticement to believe Mayweather Beats De La Hoya II will be anything more than that label; for those real, true fans who’ve kept boxing afloat over the years and scream out for Mayweather-Cotto instead of a bout that smacks of corporate subsidy, a Forbes win would be of near Biblical proportions.
The only problem with the hope for a little old-time religion come Saturday is that, with multi-millions on the table, Forbes got the call. That has to dampen the spirits.
Let’s go to the report card:
Speed: If there is a category in the fight where Forbes appears to have a real edge, it would be speed. At 130 lb, it was his speed that kept him in fights when his power had no chance to. He had the excellent ability to not only get off first when he needed to, but also to get off in counter. Will that speed follow him to this fight at just above welterweight (both men weighed in at 150 lb)? Even if it does, the edge may still fall to Oscar. The concussions caused by Oscar’s left hook over the years have been a result of a shot that gets to the target with blinding speed. Forbes is quick handed, but Oscar’s speed snaps. Add in his familiarity with higher weight divisions, and the advantage that should be Stevie’s probably isn’t.
Pre-Fight Grades: De La Hoya A-; Forbes B+
Power: How much need be explored here? Look at the records; they don’t lie. For Forbes to win Saturday, he has to fight a perfect fight for thirty-six minutes. He can hit hard enough to keep a fight honest, but if he couldn’t raise any scare in the larger Grady Brewer, who decisioned Forbes in the second season finale of the Contender, Oscar’s proven chin isn’t in much jeopardy. Oscar has been a great left handed puncher over the years; he knows it and so does Forbes. The intrigue in this category will be how Forbes approaches the situation. For a light hitter, he’s one hell of an in-fighter. He is good in the pocket, rolling his shoulders, staying inside the storm to land in combination. Oscar’s hook is best from distance, off the jab. If Forbes can close the gap, he muffles the shot.
Pre-Fight Grades: De La Hoya A-; Forbes C-
Defense: This fight features two quality defensive fighters, both of whom integrate their offense off subtle defensive postures. Forbes is the more natural, able to roll with punches and seamlessly come back with jabs, hooks and uppercuts. That doesn’t mean he’s unhittable; far from it. In losses to Daniel Santos, Yodsanan Nanthachai, and Brewer, he got hit plenty on the way to the cards and none of those men had the speed, experience or power of De La Hoya. Oscar’s defense largely comes with his legs and off the jab, but he isn’t without head movement. He also has picked up the shoulder roll from his years of work with Floyd Mayweather Sr., but unlike Forbes, he looks like he’s thinking about doing it which can sometimes cause a stutter when he begins to return fire. The bottom line is that neither man is Willie Pep, but they don’t lead with their chins either.
Pre-Fight Grades: De La Hoya B; Forbes B
Intangibles: All objections to future plans aside, Oscar is a proven character commodity in the ring. He’s shown heart and the ability to battle through adversity over the years in battles against Ike Quartey, Shane Mosley and Fernando Vargas. While some point to late fight fades against Bernard Hopkins, Felix Trinidad and Floyd Mayweather, it is often forgotten that sometimes great fighters fade against other great fighters. No sin there. Forbes has shown his character as well, always engaging and never giving up on a career that often lacked opportunity. In recent years, he’s stepped in with naturally larger men in the opponent role, only to seize his chances and embarrass Jr. Welterweights Demetrius Hopkins (who he beat no matter the official scoring) and Panchito Bojado. In the Bojado fight, he showed serious beard as well. For as long as the bout lasts, and as seen in the cut form on the scales Friday afternoon, we’ll see two real professionals in the ring.
Pre-Fight Grades: De La Hoya A; Forbes A
Overall Report Card: De La Hoya A-; Forbes B
The Pick: As this columnist has noted in the past, Oscar made a sound decision here if he’s going to get serious about beating Mayweather. Forbes is as close, in size and style, as he can get to Floyd while also protecting the seemingly inevitable financial windfall to come. Were Forbes just a tad bit more natural to the weight he’s fighting at, I’d seriously consider picking him. Then again, he might not have seriously been considered for this bout if that was the case. Look for Forbes to log some quality early rounds only to succumb to the larger and more well rounded Oscar sometime around the seventh.
And don’t feel bad if you’re rooting for the underdog, loyal reader. You won’t be alone.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com