By Cliff Rold
In sports there are winners and there are losers.
Most of the time.
It’s been said a tie is like kissing one’s sister but after all the shots they took in the mush on Wednesday in Osaka, Japan, it’s unlikely WBA ‘regular’ Jr. Bantamweight titlist Nobuo Nashiro (13-1-1, 8 KO) or challenger and former World Jr. Flyweight champion Hugo Cazares (30-6-2, 22 KO) were doing much kissing after their grueling draw.
Draws are never a preferred outcome but sometimes they are the fairest route. It appeared the case here. In the interest of full disclosure, seeking the fight out on YouTube, only rounds 1-8 and the final frame could be found with highlights for rounds 9-11. Therefore, the fight isn’t scored here. However, from those highlights, and the excellent reporting of Hall of Famer Joe Koizumi at FightNews, the outcome doesn’t merit any controversy.
What was fully available to view does merit a rematch. While it did not match the epic scope of February’s Juan Manuel Marquez-Juan Diaz Lightweight championship epic, Nashiro-Cazares was nasty stuff and among the best bouts of the year.
Let’s go to the report card.
Pre-Fight Grades
Pre-Fight: Speed – Nashiro B+; Cazares B/Post: Nashiro B+; Cazares B+
Pre-Fight: Power – Nashiro B; Cazares B+/Post: Nashiro B+; Cazares B+
Pre-Fight: Defense – Nashiro B; Cazares C+/Post: Nashiro B; Cazares B
Pre-Fight: Intangibles – Nashiro B; Cazares B+/Post: A for both
Cazares, who looked drained in his last two fights at 108 lbs. versus Ivan Calderon is fully acclimated now to 115 and it showed in his sharper speed and form. The southpaw fought a disciplined bout, as both exchanged for long stretches at mid-ring. Standing tall in the pocket and alternating between counterpuncher and aggressor in the first half of the fight, Cazares found Nashiro a tough target in the first two rounds and ate some big right hands and a couple notable left hooks inside. By the third, he was timing Nashiro’s rushes and even stunned the titlist for a moment before staving off a rushing comeback. Nashiro edged the fourth but Cazares was rough going in the fifth and sixth to pull the bout even.
His momentum was carrying through round seven and then came the eighth. It was one of the best three minute adrenaline rushes of the year. Cazares busted in with his lead left and all hell broke loose as each man took turns battering the other. A slip to the canvas by Cazares in the final thirty seconds broke the flow of the round which was a shame as it was round of the year stuff to then.
It might have been anyways. What could be seen of 9-11 had Nashiro, as was the case in the bulk of the rest of the fight, landing the flusher, cleaner blows but Cazares was always there to fire back. In the final round, Nashiro landed two huge rights near the corner and wobbled Cazares. The Mexican wisely held, moved, and then re-engaged but the Japanese juggernaut fought with relentless determination.
The crowd certainly got its yen’s worth.
In terms of power, both men were rocked but withstood with guts, tough chins, and the luck that neither man is really a one-punch KO artist. They hit hard for their size, but just hard enough to keep the leather flowing. Defensively, Nashiro was a little better, able to use his arms and shoulders to deflect many of the lefts while Cazares showed more control but still ate a lot of shots when Nashiro got close.
To their credit, both men earn the highest marks for those things which can’t be taught. They fought with spirit, pride, and will in a contest which got better as the rounds wore on. It was an escalation of tensions and neither folded as the heat turned up.
Looking Ahead
It is astounding to consider Nashiro has only just finished his fifteenth pro outing considering the quality of foes he has faced since stepping up to defeat veteran Hidenobu Honda in his fifth fight. Beginning there, his last eleven foes have had a combined record of 260-56-5, including outstanding titlist Martin Castillo and Alexander Munoz. Now there is Cazares.
There needs to be Cazares again.
Both men exited with reasons to feel themselves the victor but the truth was no one left with their hand raised. If there is to be a rematch, let’s hope it can be exposed to a wider audience. Both men entered the ring under the head scratching logic of a WBA which currently recognizes three titlists. Vic Darchinyan (32-2-1, 26 KO), the real World champion of the division, is the ‘Super’ titlist while Nonito Donaire (22-1, 14 KO) is the ‘interim’ man. It’s probably farfetched, but a card which featured Darchinyan-Donaire II with Nashiro-Cazares II would be one hell of a night of boxing.
That the winners could logically, possibly, move on to each other is no small shakes either.
Let’s hope for the best at a weight class which, still, is one of the premieres in the sport.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com