By Ryan Songalia
Photo © Natasha Chornesky/FightWireImages.com
The names you see here may not be household names. Gone are the days of Benny Leonard, Ray Robinson, and Gene Tunney dominating the headlines in the Empire State, capturing our imaginations with their proficiency in the ring, and their flair out of it. Pugilistic breeding grounds like the Gramercy Gym, Stillman's Gym, and the Times Square Gym have long since been razed, casualties of the ever changing landscape of the Big Apple.
A new generation of fighters have picked up the slack where the greats have released their burden, continuing the tradition of fighting spirit that has become a staple of the Gotham pride. Slugging away and earning our respect in venues like the the famed Madison Square Garden and the Hammerstein Ballroom, New York boxing is alive and well due in no small portion to the unrelenting heart of the New York warrior. Here is one writer's assessment of the top fighters in the state of New York.
1. Joan Guzman, Brooklyn, NY; 27-0 (17 KO); Super Featherweight
For this flashy Dominican native, now is the summer of his youth. After years of a misguided career that seemed to be moving in circles, "El Pequeno Tyson" has emerged as one of the pound for pound elite in the world after gaining the WBO 130 pound title from Jorge Barrios.
Guzman brings to his division speed, speed only comparable to Manny Pacquiao at that weight limit. He also possesses technical craft unparalleled to his peers, able to put combinations together that have separated him from his opponents thusfar and afforded him an edge against all of his foes, remaining unbeaten. Guzman does seem to have lost the clout in his punches that devastated opponents at 122, demanding that he focus on his technical game more than he had previously.
Guzman successfully defended his title against Antonio Davis in his last outing. Hopefully Guzman can follow that up with a meaningful bout that can answer the question on many boxing pundits' minds: Just how great is Joan Guzman?
2. Luis Collazo, Queens, NY; 27-2 (13 KO); Welterweight
Sometimes, it's not what you can't do, but what you can do that works to your detriment. That statement applies accurately to Luis Collazo, the Nuyorican southpaw from Queens. Collazo won the WBA Welterweight title in a dramatic battle with Jose Antonio Rivera last Spring, only to cede it to the bigger name of Ricky Hatton. The fight was close and it could have gone either way, but a first round knockdown proved to be the deciding margin by which the fight was judged.
The slippery NewYorican is a small welterweight, but his diminutive stature has been somewhat of an advantage ala Pernell Whitaker. "He's so dangerous because he appears to have great legs and he can box and brawl equally well", endorsed world class trainer John Scully. "He knows when to do one or the other. Being all that and a southpaw to boot makes him difficult for anyone in his weight class."
Collazo is scheduled to face Walter Matthysse next, a fight with title bout implications in the balance. Somebody is going to make a lot of money at 147, and Luis Collazo wants his share of it.
3. Vivian Harris; Brooklyn, NY; 27-2-1 (18 KO); Junior Welterweight
On paper, Vivian Harris seems to have it all. He's a long-armed, versatile fighter with power in both hands who can adjust to every style. He is the owner of a solid chin and an extensive amateur background, however he has yet to stake his claim as a major star in the ring.
Last June, Harris was in position to set himself up for a showdown with Floyd Mayweather Jr. Holding the WBA Junior Welterweight title and being showcased on the undercard of Mayweather's destruction of Arturo Gatti, Harris imploded on the biggest stage of his career, being knocked out in seven by the unheralded Carlos Maussa.
Now rebuilding his reputation, Harris has dispersed of Emmanuel Steward and is now being guided by Lennox Blackmoore, his original trainer. Harris' next fight will be a WBC eliminator against the dangerous banger Juan Lazcano.
4. Shannon Briggs; Brooklyn, NY; 48-4-1 (42 KO); Heavyweight
If we were to use the traditional definition of pound for pound, then Briggs would fall a few rungs from the top because, well, he's pound for pound the size of two lightweights. In spite of his terribly indiscreet weight of 268 for his last bout, Shannon surprised us all with a last second stoppage of the heavily favored Sergei Lyakhovich to annex the WBO Heavyweight title. For the first time in his career, the hype was eclipsed by his actions in the ring and justified a legacy that previously stood for unfulfilled potential.
Now at the age of 34, "Shannon the Cannon" has finally gained the mental and emotional maturity that have enabled him to put his fine talents together. "To be honest, I think he's the most talented guy in the heavyweight division", claimed former trainer Jeff Mayweather. In an interesting twist, Mayweather will now be in the opposing corner of Russian mandatory challenger Sultan Ibragimov for their impending February showdown. Prior to his title winning affair against Lyakhovich, Mayweather was outed in favor of Chuck McGregor.
Briggs has impressive hand speed for a big man, and coupled with his excellent balance and heavy-handed power, he stands a decent chance to remain a title holder long enough to get the showdown with IBF champ Wladimir Klitschko he craves. That is all contingent on him staying hungry, however.
5. Curtis Stevens; Brooklyn, NY; 16-1 (12 KO); Super Middleweight/Light-Heavyweight
One half of the Chin Checkers, Curtis Stevens' intimidating presence in the ring elicits flashbacks of another Bedford Stuyvesant product, Mike Tyson. Punishing combinations to the body and head also help his cause, which has seen 11 of his opponents fall within two rounds.
Stevens' only setback as a professional came against spoiler Marcos Primera. Leading on all the judges cards and cruising to a victory in the eighth of a ten-rounder, Stevens imploded due to fatigue and was stopped, although the case can be made that the fight was halted early. He's been very active, winning 3 fights in a row over a thirty day span, including a decision victory to avenge his lone defeat. During that streak, he also managed to pick up the NY Light-Heavyweight title.
Stevens has crushing power, particularly in his trademark left hook, but his primary weakness comes when matched against movers. He needs to cut the ring off better and his stamina is iffy, but the future is looking bright for Stevens, who at only 21 has a bright and prosperous future ahead of him.
6. Paulie Malignaggi; Brooklyn, NY; 21-1 (5 KO); Junior Welterweight
After his convincing defeat at the hands of Miguel Cotto this past summer, it appeared that "The Magic Man" was ready to disappear from the upper level of the boxing stratosphere, his own boasts free promotion to his crushing demise. When you thoroughly analyze his performance however, it wasn't too bad for a guy who had never previously stepped up in opposition as a professional. Malignaggi was in way over his head and found himself overwhelmed by a bigger, stronger, and more experienced man.
Malignaggi has all the tools to be a world class fighter, except for non-existent pop to his shots and his potato-chip brittle hands. Great movement and combination punching can take you only so far, but when the time comes and you can't fight your way out of trouble, you're going to find the deeper ponds of pugilism difficult to navigate in crunch time. He has a ton of heart and speed to burn, but he needs to be harder to find in the ring if he looks to enjoy a sustainable career. It will be interesting to see how he adjusts to his new trainer, Buddy McGirt.
Malignaggi's next fight is scheduled for this February, when he returns against fringe contender Edner Cherry on HBO's Boxing After Dark. Many questions remain to be answered, and it's time for Malignaggi to take the stand.
7. John Duddy; New York City; 18-0 (15 KO); Middleweight
Originally from Ireland, John Duddy has proven to be one of New York's most exciting imports in recent years. Last time out, boxing fans got the treat of a lifetime when the former 2000 Olympian squared off in a brutal tug of war with former champion Yori Boy Campas. For 12 hard fought rounds, both men teetered on the brink of disaster in one of the most electric bouts in Madison Square Garden's recent history. Duddy came out with the win, but emerged with a new measuring stick of his own abilities.
Duddy has impressive power, having felled the vast majority of his opponents inside of 4 rounds. He is a bit slow of hand, and his technique is at times robotic and repetitive. His best punch is his right cross, but it'd be foolish to say that his opponent's look forward to catching his left hook, either.
If one is seeking to uncover some kind of flaw in Duddy's game, one need not look any farther than Duddy's defense. For all intents and purposes, Duddy is incapable of avoiding an incoming shot. If you throw a bottle into the ring from 20 rows back, it'd be some feat for you to not strike him with the bottle. For his part, he has heart and a stable chin, but long term you have to wonder how many life and death struggles Duddy will be able to survive.
8. Dmitriy Salita; Brooklyn, NY 26-0-1 (15 KO); Junior Welterweight
Dmitriy Salita goes by the nickname "Star of David", but as of yet has fallen short of becoming the star of Dibella Entertainment's deep stable of talent. The Brooklyn-based junior welterweight turned pro in 2001 to heavy fanfare, with his popularity among the Jewish community and a successful 2001 New York Golden Gloves bid adding a boost of momentum to the stylish technician.
As Salita's star began to rise, he encountered uncharted adversity in March of 2006, when he ran into tough journeyman Ramon Montano. Down twice in the first round and on the verge of having his career aspirations dashed to threads in front of a packed house in Atlantic City, Salita survived the ten round distance and was awarded with what some consider to be a fortuitous draw.
Salita's in-the-ring inconsistencies may be a product of the unstable revolving door of trainers that he has encountered throughout his career. Lost in the premature media dismissals of Salita was that he is still a well-balanced technician with exceptional combination punching and a diverse arsenal. Of course, we're in a show and tell business, and you have to show it to be it. Behind the momentum of several solid victories in recent months, Salita looks to maneuver into position for a title shot in the near future. When he steps up against top competition, then we will find out if his record is the mark of great talent, or judicious matchmaking and officiating.
9. Yuri Foreman; Brooklyn, NY; 22-0 (8 KO); Junior Middleweight
For the proponent's of pure technical skill, Yuri Foreman is the real deal. Textbook boxing talent combined with effective foot movement have made Yuri Foreman a top prospect, if not an in demand attraction at the box office.
If Foreman's hands can remain healthy, he has the amateur schooling and professional temperment to guide him into position for a title shot. This bouncy, frenetic boxer lacks power in his punches, but when you can move like he does, it's not the biggest deficiency in the world.
10. Francisco Figueroa; Bronx, NY; 14-2 (10 KO); Junior Welterweight
It's hard to find a fighter more enjoyable to watch then "El Gato". Figueroa has a showman's flair that has made him sort of a cult figure in New York boxing, with a growing loyal following. Figueroa's flashy southpaw style draws similarities to Hector Camacho, with both employing awkward defensive maneuvers to supplement their offensive arsenal. A sizzling body assault supplemented by a mean overhand left make him a dangerous fighter for anyone in his weight range.
Since dropping a close decision to Francisco Rincon at the Mid Hudson Civic Center 2 years ago, Figueroa has stayed undefeated, picking up the New York State 140 pound title along the way. In his last outing, "El Gato" put on another entertaining exhibition of style and flair as he earned a close victory over cross-borough rival Joey Rios. Plans for a fight with Dmitriy Salita fell through after HBO rejected it for a television date, but Gato remains in the talented mix at 140 pounds.
Any questions or feedback? Send them to me at mc_rson@yahoo.com . My Myspace address is http://www.myspace.com/asian_sensation201 . My website url is https://www.boxingscene.com/ryansongalia .