By Cliff Rold
One fighter acted his age and the other did not, each to their advantage. Both exited with shiny new belts and the position of man to watch in their respective divisions. In their own way, 37-year old heavyweight Vitali Klitschko and 26-year old Light Heavyweight Chad Dawson made Saturday night their own, scoring career affirming victories of very different kinds.
In what was a highly anticipated double-continent doubleheader, Klitschko and Dawson produced performances beyond hyperbole. This page will supply it anyways.
Let’s go to the report cards, beginning with the big boys.
Vitali Klitschko-Samuel Peter
Speed – Pre-Fight Grades: Peter B-; Klitschko B/Post-Fight: B-; B+
Power - Pre-Fight Grades: Peter & Klitschko B+/Post-Fight: B/B+
Defense - Pre-Fight Grades: Klitschko B; Peter B-/Post-Fight: B+/B-
Intangibles - Pre-Fight Grades: Peter B; Klitschko B/Post-Fight: C+/A+
Yes, the pre-fight report card picked Peter to win, by KO no less. Clearly that was not the result.
It’s hard not to hyperbolize this win for new WBC titlist Klitschko (36-2, 35 KO). The moribund Heavyweight division was dynamited alive by his win. It created a buzz on message boards and fight fan phone lines. While he never quite proved it, there was a feeling Vitali was the man after Lennox Lewis retired in 2004 and the buzz speaks to the idea that “The Man” has returned.
What the eye revealed may have hid it, but the 28-year old Peter (30-2, 23 KO) did show up. Klitschko just made it seem like he didn’t and in doing so would have easily confused an unlearned observer about who the older man was. Klitschko showed off better speed and timing than anyone could have expected after close to three inactive years and, with the first big right hand of the fight, imposed his power as well. Perhaps most impressive, regardless of how slow Peter appeared, Vitali made himself an almost impossible target. He fought tall and with tremendous focus, getting off first and last all night.
There will be those who use this bout to validate negatives observed previously in Peter but, while he’s no Liston or Foreman, he’s been far from a bum. Klitschko turning him out with ease spoke volumes about his professionalism and mental toughness. He deserves full credit for one of the most impressive ring performances, much less returns, in recent memory.
From here, things get interesting. As noted on the main BoxingScene page, Klitschko vs. WBA interim titlist Nicolay Valuev talk is already heating up. He has a mandatory with resurgent former IBF Cruiserweight titlist Juan Carlos Gomez. And if he can beat both of those men, in whichever order, he’ll theoretically have to deal with the WBA’s regular titlist Ruslan Chagaev as well when Chagaev is back from his Achilles injury. Those are all good, competitive fights. Little brother Wladimir will be in action in December against undefeated IBF mandatory Alexander Povetkin to defend the IBF and WBO belts with WBO mandatory and also undefeated Alexander Dimitrenko looming. It won’t get us closer to an undisputed champion, but a bunch of interesting fights in the meantime isn’t all bad either.
Moving down the scale…
Chad Dawson-Antonio Tarver
Speed - Pre-Fight Grades: Dawson A-; Tarver B/Post-Fight: A/B
Power - Pre-Fight Grades: Tarver B+; Dawson B/Post-Fight: B/B
Defense - Pre-Fight Grades: Dawson & Tarver B/Post-Fight: B+/B
Intangibles - Pre-Fight Grades: Dawson & Tarver B/Post-Fight: A/B+
Unlike Klitschko, Dawson acted his age by showing off what should usually be true in a Boxing match. All things being equal, a man with a thirteen-year age advantage whose going to be worth following wins with that advantage. The new IBF Light Heavyweight titlist Dawson (27-0, 17 KO) did just that Saturday, winning at least nine rounds against 39-year old Antonio Tarver (27-5, 19 KO).
Tarver showed some good stuff even in losing. He blocked well with his gloves and arms, was effective with the jab, and even stunned Dawson with some well-timed uppercuts. His problem was two-fold: as the fight wore on, his punches lost snap and he didn’t have the youth to keep up with Dawson’s output. There are a lot of good fighters at 175 lbs. Tarver can still defeat; none of them are named Chad Dawson.
In his previous outing, Dawson barely survived another old man of the game in Glen Johnson and he must have learned a ton in that narrow win. He showed the same exceptional hand speed this time out but, unlike in the Johnson fight, didn’t allow himself to be punished when his foe opened up. He kept his head, played defense, and then fired. The geography of the fight was also his as he circled and determined when to fight on the ropes and when he would be at ring center. It was an example of a very good fighter coming into his own, the birth of prime.
Before exploring Dawson further, let a moment be reserved for Tarver. While never every fans favorite, he has been the sort of fighter fans claim to want to see more of. From 1999, in his first bout with Eric Harding, through the loss to Dawson, Tarver has fought real top ten competition consistently for almost a decade. Only 2007 saw a serious dip in quality, a reset on the road to his 2008 double of Clinton Woods and Dawson. He didn’t win them all, but he fought the sort of schedule fans should demand from a world class fighter in the 2-3 fights a year era we reside in. And even in defeat this weekend, he never gave up and stayed in the fight all the way. No one has to like him, but everyone should respect what he’s gotten done by now.
Tarver fades closer to yesterday while Dawson is all of today and his sky is the limit. He is not yet proven the clear best Light Heavyweight in the world but one can sense the day growing near when he does. A rematch with Johnson is still warranted and would be a gift to fans that enjoyed their first savage war. Dawson of course will also have an eye on the November 8th showdown between Ring titlist Joe Calzaghe and former divisional kingpin Roy Jones. The winner of that bout certainly couldn’t feel like a champion without facing Dawson. Dawson’s search for top foes need not end with those two bouts though; conversation with members of the camp of Super Middleweight titlist Mikkel Kessler offered up that a Dawson-Kessler fight is one they might be interested in and one fight fans could anticipate. From 160-175 lbs., Boxing is littered with talent right now. Dawson won’t have to look hard to further prove his place among the best of the game.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com