By Rick Reeno
Aside from all of the controversy between the WBC and the local commission, Saturday's main event at the Beau Rivage Theatre in Biloxi, Mississipi has people talking. IBF/WBO/WBA lightweight champion Nate Campbell (32-5-1, 25 KOs) will make his first defense of the titles against undefeated two-division champion Joan Guzman (28-0, 17 KOs). Back in March, Campbell, a decent underdog, upset then-undefeated Juan Diaz with a dominating performance in Cancun, Mexico to lift the titles. In his first title defense, Campbell is once again listed as the underdog in several betting circles.
In the co-feature, WBC junior welterweight champion Timothy “Desert Storm” Bradley (22-0, 11 KOs) will make his initial defense against Edner “Cherry Bomb” Cherry (24-5-2, 12 KOs).
The staff of BoxingScene.com comes together to voice their opinions, strategies and predictions for the big fight.
Robert Morales - Nate Campbell via decision over Joan Guzman: Guzman has gone the distance in his past seven fights - five of which were at junior lightweight. In other words, he has shown little power since moving up from super bantamweight. Since this will be Guzman's first fight at lightweight, he is at a distinct disadvantage against Campbell, who has been a lightweight for the past three years
Cliff Rold - Campbell was one of the better stories of the first half of the year; I expect Guzman to emerge as one of the key stories in the second half. It won’t be easy. Guzman will have to be focused for all twelve rounds to have a shot and he needs to come ready to build an early lead because Campbell will get better as the fight wears on. If Campbell’s long jab is established before the second half of the fight, he could exact a brutal price against Guzman down the stretch in Guzman’s first real step to 135. I suspect the speed gap will allow Guzman to get his lead and hold it, pulling out a decision at around 8-4 in rounds in a very good fight.
Jake Donovan - A banner year for Nate, who got married and realized his longtime goal of becoming a champion. Nothing but well wishes in married life, but the boxing honeymoon ends this weekend. Guzman too complete of a fighter, and his sturdy beard and superior defense will help neutralize the one true advantage Nate boasts in this fight (punching power). Guzman by unanimous decision.
TK Stewart - I like Nate Campbell in this fight for several reasons. Number one is that he is a little bigger guy who turned pro above 135 pounds and he also has a five-inch reach advantage. I also think that Nate will be able to take everything that the light punching Guzman will be able to throw at him. Number two, I've seen Guzman fight in person and although he is an extremely busy puncher and a gifted mover he doesn't get a lot on his shots. Guzman hasn't scored a knockout since February 2004. Number three, there is a big difference at 135 pounds for a smaller guy that is moving up. Lightweight is a whole new ball game and this is Guzman's first 'official' fight at 135 and his first against a real 135-pounder who is strong and agressive and who can take a shot and give a shot. Lastly, Guzman has been off for 10 months and this is only his third fight in three years, so aside from being light in the bank account, he's got to be rusty. A guy with his style needs the timing and the quickness that only activity brings - and I just don't think he'll have it. For all of those reasons, I like Nate by a late rounds stoppage or a decision
CompuBox/Bob Canobbio - Joan Guzman should win with a close unanimous decision.
James Blears - Nate Campbell looked awesome against Baby Bull in Cancun and although Joan Guzman is slick and fast, Nate is too big and strong. If Nate can motivate himself to the same extent, then Joan will loose a unanimous decision after electing to box, milling on the retreat.
Brent Matteo Alderson - Not to brag about my pics because they havn't been very good this past year, but I did pick Campbell to upset Juan Diaz ( https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=12619 ) and that's because Campbell is a naturally hard puncher and Diaz gets hit a lot. I think Campbell is limited and I really like Guzman in the fight, even though I think Joan is too small for 135 pounds. He should be fighting 130 or less. Still, I think Guzman is one of the 12 best fighters in the world and feel he should win this fight handily.
Dave Sholler - Guzman by Decision. Call this one a gut feeling, but I like Guzman in convincing fashion. While he hasn't stopped an opponent since 2004, the 32-year-old Dominican has all the tools necessary to grind out a decision victory over Campbell.
Lyle Fitzsimmons - Nate's too strong at 135. Guzman may look good early, but once he gets hit by a slugger like Campbell, he'll stay hit. Campbell will knock Guzman out in ten.
Ernest Gabion - Nate Campbell should pull out win, knocking out Guzman by the tenth-round.
Shawn Krest - It seems like Guzman's power stayed behind when he moved up to super featherweight. Now he's moving up again to lightweight. Meanwhile, Campbell seems to have found second life after a stretch where he won three of eight fights. Look for midnight to strike on his Cinderella run. Guzman by tight unanimous decision, score it 115-113
Michael Campbell - Joan Guzman should win by unanimous decision, 116 to 112.
Paul Gallegos - Nate Campbell has been back on track as of late since sticking out his chin against Robbie Peden way back when. I think that the Campbell train is going to get derailed. I haven't seen Joan Guzman fight in a while, but as I remember, he was one of the stronger fighters in his division. I think that Guzman's peedpower will overcome Campbell's power and experience. Guzman by unanimous decision.
Michael Doss - The fight will be close, Guzman will pull out a twelve-round split-decision.
Troy Ondrizek - Campbell's chin is unquestionable as is his punch output. Guzman has the speed to slow down Nate and frustrate him early. With a few early rounds in the bank Guzman will come to realize that those early rounds would be the best time of his night. Nate's intelligence and ability to adjust to his opponents will work through after the 4th round and Guzman will fall short not because of ability, but because he won't have the guts to do more than Campbell. Campbell by unanimous decision.
Alexey Potapov - I consider Joan Guzman as the favorite in this fight, and he should benefit from his work with trainer Floyd Mayweather Sr. Mayweather has always given a lot of attention to defense, which in this fight I consider ideal for Guzman. Certainly, Nate Campbell has more experience, but in this case I think Guzman will get the win with a unanimous decision from judges.
Alphonso Costello - If an unfocused dimwitted Nate Campbell shows up on Saturday night, Joan Guzman will keep his unblemished record intact. This fight will be determined by mental toughness. Campbell’s newly found focus along with his execution and natural boxing abilities should be enough to fend off Guzman’s exceptional boxing style. In the end, I pick Guzman to defeat Campbell by unanimous decision in a battle of wits.
John Hively - I am a Nate Campbell fan. He's a flawed warrior and that makes for great fights. But I think Guzman will box him, in which case he stands a chacen to win, but I don't think so. This is a toss up fight, but I like Nate to pull it off.
Rick Reeno - It's very hard for me to go against Joan Guzman in this particular fight. The guy is as slippery as they come. He's jumped through several divisions in a very short time. He managed to keep his speed and chin along the way, but he lost some of his power when he jumped to super featherweight. I know Nate has a very good plan to counter his speed and movement. I don't know if the plan can be executed. Other fighters have tried counter Guzman's speed and failed. This is going to be a very close fight. Guzman is fighting at lightweight for the very first time. If he manages to lose a step or two because of the added weight, it could be a very long and painful night. I'm picking Guzman to win a close unanimous decision.