By Cliff Rold
One man’s loss could be a division’s gain.
Wednesday’s big Jr. Bantamweight showdown in Osaka, Japan would be a solid match on paper without the loss. With it, a fight which won’t air live in the U.S. takes on more immediate meaning then the many that don’t.
In July, World Jr. Bantamweight champion Vic Darchinyan (32-2-1, 26 KO) made a game effort at his third title in a third weight class. Joseph Agbeko, the IBF Bantamweight titlist, had other ideas and Darchinyan returned to 115 lbs.
A month later his first conqueror, Flyweight Nonito Donaire (22-1, 14 KO), moved up from 112 to join him. 115 has been a hot class for most of this decade. Darchinyan-Agbeko threatened to throw water on the flame.
That it did not is a net gain for the fans leading to Nashiro-Cazares. As a unified titlist, Darchinyan is recognized by the WBA as ‘Super’ champ while Donaire as won the ‘interim’ tag. Nashiro-Cazares takes care of the ‘regular’ tag, all from the same body.
Is the WBA having three titlists in the same weight class about the stupidest thing on Earth? Um, yeah.
But anything which puts this combination of fighters in shooting range of each other is an example to three wrongs making right.
Let’s go to the report card.
The Ledgers
Nobuo Nashiro
Age: 27
Titles: WBA Jr. Bantamweight (2008-Present, 1 Defense)
Previous Titles: WBA Jr. Bantamweight (2006-07, 1 Defense)
Height: 5’4 ½
Weight: 115
Average Weight – Last Five Fights: 116.15 lbs.
Hails from: Osaka, Japan
Record: 13-1, 8 KO
Current/Former World Champions/Titlists Defeated: 1 (Martin Castillo)
Current/Former World Champions/Titlists Faced in Defeat: 1 (Alexander Munoz)
Vs.
Hugo Cazares
Age: 31
Title: None
Previous Titles: WBO Jr. Flyweight (2005-06, 3 Defenses); Lineal/Ring/WBO (2006-07, 1 Defense)
Height: 5’4
Weight: 114
Average Weight – Last Five Fights: 114.95 lbs.
Hails from: Los Mochis, Sinaloa, Mexico
Record: 30-6-1, 22 KO
Current/Former World Champions/Titlists Defeated: 4 (Nelson Dieppa, Alex Sanchez, Kermin Guardia, Roberto Vasquez)
Current/Former World Champions/Titlists Faced in Defeat: 1 (Ivan Calderon)
Pre-Fight Grades
Speed – Nashiro B+; Cazares B
Power – Nashiro B; Cazares B+
Defense – Nashiro B; Cazares C+
Intangibles – Nashiro B; Cazares B+
While both Cazares and Nashiro enter Wednesday’s bout riding win streaks, they also enter with question marks. Nashiro struggled to win his second belt in a split decision against Kohei Kono last year. He came off the floor in a struggle with Konosuke Tomiyama in his only fight since. A prodigious talent who knocked off the vastly more experienced Martin Castillo, in only his eighth fight, to win his first belt has found more struggle since.
Cazares too has faced difficulty. After a 16-fight win streak which saw him win the WBO belt at 108 lbs. and, later, Ring Magazine recognition as champion, Cazares ran into the brilliant boxing of Ivan Calderon. He nearly overcame an early points deficit the first time around; a nasty cut stopped the rematch from getting to the later rounds Cazares needed. With rumors swirling of severe difficulty in making the low weight line, Cazares moved up and defeated the tough Roberto Vasquez to get this shot.
It is an evenly matched affair.
Though some might assume Cazares as the smaller man, it is not the case. The two battlers have less than half an inch between them in height and while that favors Nashiro he’ll give up that height. He often starts from outside with his gloves high but after shooting a jab he’s looking to stoop and fore big left hooks and overhand rights. Nashiro isn’t afraid to barrel in with his head to maintain pressure.
It could play to Cazares’s advantage. The Mexican often stands straight up, firing the jab from an almost open stance to set up winging lefts and rights. With a slight advantage in speed, Nashiro should be able to counter with the left regularly as Cazares comes wide, but when he drops his head things get interesting. The sharpest punch in the Cazares arsenal is a quicker than expected uppercut underneath. If Cazares times Nashiro coming in, the more natural puncher should do damage.
Both men have to date shown solid beards. The light punching Calderon stunned Cazares a couple times but weight loss and the speed of Calderon’s counters played a role and he never went down. Nashiro may have been down with Tomiyama but he got up and had his legs back quickly only to pummel his foe into submission two rounds later.
Beyond tough chins, both men have often leaky defense. Nashiro’s is a little better but he’s aggressive and willing to get hit to land his own shots. Cazares often dispenses with defense altogether. If Nashiro has a clear advantage, it will be getting hit less. While he was well behind in the scores by night’s end, he had no trouble finishing against Alexander Munoz in his lone loss and Munoz is a big puncher.
Where viewers will win (live and later if this ends up on something like YouTube) is in both men’s willingness to engage with big things on the horizon. Cazares has enough name in the U.S. to hope for a propelling into big dollars with men like Donaire and Darchinyan. Nashiro might hope to lure either man overseas or travel for a chance to be the latest Asian name to matter to the broader boxing world.
The Pick
This is a tough pick. Nashiro’s home field advantage and lengthy battles with Castillo and Munoz speak to his ability to stay with the best of his class. Cazares is still largely untested at 115. Vasquez is a big win, but was a better fighter at 108 and 112. However, he was in with real quality at 108 and seen speed Nashiro doesn’t present. It’s a great style clash and could result in the sort of war which leaves hardcore fans lobbying for something other than Juan Manuel Marquez-Juan Diaz as Fight of the Year.
Ultimately, Nashiro should land more shots, more often, by the end of a fight where both men struggle through brutal moments. Nashiro win by late stoppage or narrow majority decision with bigger things possible down the road.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com