By Cliff Rold
There will be some “Viva Mexico” shouts to be certain when elite 115 lb. tacticians Fernando Montiel (35-2-1, 26 KO, WBO titlist) of Los Mochis, Sinaloa, Mexico and former alphabelt titlist Martin Castillo (33-2, 17 KO) of Mexico City face off to round out the Pavlik-Taylor II undercard on Saturday. It’s an intriguing battle with two central questions:
Is Castillo, 31, still close enough to his prime to give himself the best chance to win?
Has Montiel learned to handle the pressure of big moments?
If the answer to the second question is no, then the first may not matter. Montiel represents for Castillo his first real challenge since a July 2006 stoppage loss on cuts to Japan’s Nobuo Nashiro. Castillo showed signs of a bleed in his speed and reflexes in that bout as significant as the blood coming from above his eye. Those signs of slowing had been there in the bout prior to Nashiro as well, a rugged rematch war against Alexander Munoz that saw Castillo hit repeatedly by a looping right hand he had avoided so deftly in a 2004 bout with Munoz.
Castillo now battles to show he is still a true powerhouse at the top of a division that he should have more concretely ruled over the last six years. It was a turn of judged points, and another cut, that stunted his ascension. A 2002 title shot against then-IBF titlist Felix Macahdo was sent to the cards after six rounds in a bout that Castillo appeared to have well in hand. The judges felt otherwise, all awarding the bout to Macahdo by scores of 58-56. The regard with which Castillo was, and largely still is, held as a professional made his wait for another title opportunity much longer than it should have been. When opportunity knocked, he kicked the door in with the first, and dominant, win over Munoz for the WBA belt.
Montiel, 28, has a different proof standard. Montiel still has to prove that he can beat an elite fighter on a big stage.
A talented, athletic boxer-puncher, Montiel had serious hardcore buzz on his way up and through a WBO title reign that began in 2000 with a stoppage of the tough Isidro Garcia. An eventually tragic win over Pedro Alcazar in June 2002 (Alcazar passed away two days after the fight due to unrealized brain injuries) led to two easy stoppage wins over outmatched foes as Team Montiel gauged how the Alcazar bout would affect him. He looked good enough to secure an HBO Boxing After Dark main event in 2003 against former titlist Mark Johnson and, for lack of a better word, Montiel seemed at times to freeze on the way to a decision loss.
With the ghost of Alcazar looming, it was easy to ask if perhaps it was too big a challenge too soon. Time appeared to bear that out as Montiel went on a six fight win streak, defeating Johnson conqueror Ivan Hernandez to regain his belt and picking up a decision over the threatening Pramuansak Posuwan. Boxing After Dark called again, this time for a bantamweight bout against Jhonny Gonzalez. In a dreadfully dull fight, Montiel appeared to freeze again en route to a decision loss.
As was the case after his first loss, Montiel has regrouped with three straight wins, the last of them a fight of the year contender on Versus in 2007 against Luis Melendez that saw both men get off the deck in pursuit of victory. Still, Jr. Bantamweights don’t get many chances to graduate into the honors class of money in the sport and another falter could mark the end of such hopes for Montiel.
Let’s go to the report card.
Speed: This is a category where the differences are not only in ticks on the stopwatch but in delivery style. Montiel snaps his shots out faster and seems to jerk his upper body along with his shots. Castillo is the more fluid and relaxed fighter. It stands to reason that Montiel will land his jab first early on, but Castillo will be likely to land in combination off of the jab. Foot speed matters as well in this fight. Montiel has quick feet but often pulls straight back in reaction. Castillo, an orthodox and schooled veteran, is careful to step out at angles throughout his fights. Ultimately, natural speed favors Montiel but only slightly. Pre-Fight Grades: Montiel A-; Castillo B+
Power: Both men hit well enough to keep an opponent wary but it is Montiel that has been the more likely of the two to score knockouts. That is a product of his speed, which enables him to land his best stuff from angles that opponents don’t see coming. Castillo has stopped few top level opponents and his best knockout probably came against Hideyasu Ishihara in 2005, an eleven round accumulation of punishment. Natural power then favors Montiel, but it must be noted that while neither man has ever been stopped Montiel has been hurt and on the deck more times than Castillo. In fact, I’m not sure if Castillo has ever been dropped so the actual power advantage may not be what it seems. Pre-Fight Grades: Montiel B; Castillo B
Defense: Montiel has suffered his share of swollen eyes and Castillo his share of cuts. Translation: neither man is unhittable. That doesn’t mean a Rocky-esque battle will ensue here. Castillo and Montiel are fighters who accept that being hit is often the price of entry to do some hitting of their own but they have the schooling to minimize how high the price gets. Castillo has had plastic surgery to aid in avoiding cuts and he’ll need it, particularly against a Montiel right hand that often is thrown over the top before slashing down against opponents faces. Pre-Fight Grades: Montiel B; Castillo B
Intangibles: The questions being asked in this bout are all one needs to know in defining the intangibles. There are different types of pressure in bouts and Montiel has survived the pressure of title shots and having to get off the floor to win. So far, it is only the maximum of attention that has limited him. Castillo has shown that he can handle adversity in and out of the ring, fighting through a cut and some bombs in the Munoz rematch and remaining the height of professionalism as he warded off certain frustration between title shots earlier in his career. With their careers viewed front to back, Castillo appears the better gamer. Pre-Fight Grades: Montiel B; Castillo A-
Overall Pre-Fight Report Card: Montiel B+; Castillo B+
On paper this is an evenly matched contest between seasoned professionals. On canvas, fight fans should expect the same. Three years ago, Castillo would have been the pick without blinking but 31 is getting old for a Jr. Bantamweight and the chance is that the slight erosion of speed that began in 2006 could be more pronounced in 2008. So why is the pick still Castillo? Even with an erosion of speed, Castillo is still the more fluid fighter and his game is more well rounded. It’s a tough one, but Castillo by close decision seems the safe call in a bout that could, in spirit if not style, resemble the 1999 bantamweight classic between Johnny Tapia and Paulie Ayala.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com