By Cliff Rold
It was hard in the build to the fight to find anyone rationally picking World Lightweight champion Juan Manuel Marquez to defeat Floyd Mayweather. The 32-year old Mayweather (40-0, 25 KO) of Grand Rapids, Michigan showed the world why Saturday night at the MGM Grand in Las Vegas, Nevada.
For almost every second of twelve rounds, the five-division former titlist who retired in 2008 as the World Welterweight champion and a leader in the pound for pound debate dominated the smaller, slower, reigning 36-year old Lightweight champion Marquez (50-4-1, 37 KO) of Mexico, capturing a unanimous decision made to look easy.
It was Mayweather’s first fight since stopping then-undefeated reigning Jr. Welterweight champion Ricky Hatton in December 2007.
Both men came in below the Welterweight limit, Mayweather at 146 and Marquez a career high 142 in his sixth fight since leaving the 126 lb. Featherweight division. There had been some controversy about the weight as an agreed upon catchweight of 144 lbs. was missed by Mayweather and, reportedly, ended up costing him in the neighborhood of $600 thousand in penalties for the two pounds over.
Smiling as he waited for the opening bell, Mayweather began his return to the ring with a landing left jab but missed seconds later with a lead left hook. Poised, Marquez pushed his jab towards the face and chest of Mayweather, missing high but landing low. The Mexican defended against the lead hook and landed the best punch of the round just inside the final minute with a long left hook. Mayweather replied with a left hook and blocked a combination attempt by Marquez in the final thirty seconds.
Mayweather again peppered with the jab to start round two, slipping away from a rush from Marquez. With little action unfolding, Marquez landed a big right hand to draw first a smile from Mayweather and then a leaping left hook which put Marquez on his back. Rising on unsteady legs, Marquez took the mandatory eight and resumed the battle, still punching if missing, while Floyd added a razor sharp right before the round ended.
Gamely, Marquez landed two rights to the ear to initiate the third followed shortly by a quick left inside and then another right. Timing the shots from there, Mayweather leaned away from the right while tagging Marquez with hard jabs in a closer frame. Continuing to box calmly, Mayweather watched Marquez’s best shots hit air or air off his shoulders in round four until a hard right caught his cheek near the ropes at the minute mark. Moving back to mid-ring, Mayweather’s jab stung the face of Marquez repeatedly as a trickle of blood began to flow near the Lightweight champion’s left eye.
In the fifth and sixth round, Mayweather’s mastery of Marquez began to bleed any sense of drama from the action. All of the Mayweather tricks, from pull counters to grinning while shoulder rolling, were on full display, leaving Marquez to resort to spot flurries with the rarest of landing leather. Showing the heart fans have come to expect, Marquez got better in the seventh, landing a few hard body shots but still struggling to handle the speed of Mayweather.
In round eight, Marquez landed a hard right counter in the first minute and another right near the minute mark, adding another in the closing seconds to build on his better seventh round. Whether it was enough to win the frame was made difficult to say as Mayweather continued to slam his own lefts and rights home in between those bursts from Marquez.
Things took a turn for the worse in round nine for Marquez. He was firing back with pride but getting torn up as nearly two of every three shots thrown by Mayweather found their mark. With the final three rounds ahead, the only interesting question left was whether or not Mayweather would go for a decisive finish. Through the eleventh, Marquez was still standing and throwing, no quit to be seen.
It was Marquez’s misfortune not to have found a round to win as the whistle sounded for the final round. Rising from his stool, Marquez came forward and did his best. It was enough for him to finish on his feet eating whatever Mayweather wanted to hit him with. Unanimous scores came in for Mayweather at 118-109, 120-107, and 119-108. The scores which gave Marquez winning rounds appeared charitable.
“I been off two years…I can get better.” Mayweather said of a night where it would be hard to find how that was the case. Giving credit to Marquez’s courage, Mayweather stated, “He’s tough, tough as nails. He’s one hell of a fighter.” The pre-fight interviews were interrupted by WBA Welterweight titlist Shane Mosley (46-5, 39 KO) who entered the ring to challenge Mayweather only for opposing camps to grow increasingly acrimonious.
Mosley-Mayweather might be the biggest challenge either man could find in the ring but the bigger challenge for Mosley might be overcoming the dollars which could be had elsewhere. Mayweather may wait until after the November 14 WBO Welterweight title bout between titlist Miguel Cotto (34-1, 27 KO) and reigning Jr. Welterweight champion Manny Pacquiao (49-3-2, 37 KO). Pacquiao and Mayweather dominated the pound for pound conversation even before Mayweather’s brief retirement and should continue to do so in the weeks ahead.
Marquez chalked up the weight and speed of Mayweather as too much for him but stated a fight between Mayweather and Pacquiao would be a different fight stylistically than what he could put forth.
The referee for Mayweather-Marquez was Tony Weeks.
In the chief support bout of the evening, 30-year old WBA Featherweight titlist Chris John (43-0-2, 22 KO), 126, of Indonesia and 29-year old 2000 U.S. Olympic Silver Medalist Rocky Juarez (28-5-1, 20 KO), 126, of Houston, Texas, proved the axiom that lightning rarely strikes twice. A rousing draw between the two men in February of this year set the stage for Saturday’s rematch. Outside of a last second explosion of drama, John was dominant in solidifying his place as the world leader in his weight class.
Sporting a Mohawk, Juarez immediately pressed the action in search of his vaunted left hook. John, relaxed and jabbing, poked away at a distance and tied up when the fight came to close quarters. John landed a long right uppercut for the best punch of round one. As the second round developed, Juarez’s penchant for stuttering offense was taking hold as John landed sharp counter rights opened up off a controlling jab.
Juarez was more effective in round three, still taking more than he was giving but managing a big right hand near the end of the round. Moving more than he had in the first quarter of the fight, John circled the ring to start the fourth and peppering Juarez with quick rights and lefts through most of the frame.
Evident as the fifth, sixth, and seventh rounds unfolded was that the feverish pace of the first match was not yet rekindled. John was less willing to trade in close and increasingly more successful because of it. In round eight, he had only to absorb the occasional body shot as his jab was able to keep Juarez pinned outside. Even as John’s left eye began to swell over the next few rounds, the contact rate for the champion kept the fight out of reach for Juarez.
It took until round eleven for Juarez to find room for the left hook he’d been missing all night. Unfortunately for Juarez, John took it without problems and responded with a damaging right of his own. In the final round, John kept his right hand close to his cheek to avoid a fight saving bomb. Juarez almost landed it anyways. With thirty seconds left in what had been a disappointing contest, Juarez landed a left hook which shook John badly. It became a race for the clock with John doing everything he could to stay on his feet. Near the ten second mark, a Juarez uppercut nearly dropped the Indonesian but he wisely grabbed and stayed just far enough away to hear the final bell standing.
After the brief flash of drama, obvious scores of 114-113, 119-109 and 117-111 were turned in for John. It was his John’s 12th successful defense of the WBA belt. Juarez fails to capture gold in his sixth try after previous failures versus Humberto Soto, twice against Marco Antonio Barrera, and Juan Manuel Marquez. The referee was Joe Cortez.
29-year old Australian Lightweight Michael Katsidis (26-2, 21 KO), 135, continued his rebound from consecutive losses to Joel Casamayor and Juan Diaz with battering split decision win over 27-year old 2004 U.S. Olympian Vicente Escobedo (21-2, 13 KO), 134, in twelve rounds. It was Escobedo’s first loss in fourteen fights going back to April 2006.
The rugged Australian, who fights out of Thailand, began in a defensive posture, circling Escobedo before stepping in with a big right hand. The pose did not last long as Escobedo applied his jab and Katsidis pursued with power shots. Escobedo responded with a sharp right and left hook but was forced to take a hard step back when Katsidis landed a pair of left hooks. A cut was opened over the left eye of Katsidis before the round closed but his aggression carried the frame.
Escobedo continued to jab in an attempt to control distance but Katsidis pressured him to the ropes soon into round two. He stayed mostly on Escobedo’s chest throughout the round with each man landing sharp shots inside. The fight continued with similar geography through the sixth, Escobedo increasingly bold in opening up while Katsidis landed the heavier blows.
By round seven, fatigue could be seen setting on Escobedo who was more frequently shoved around by the nudging shoulders of Katsidis and open for an increasingly volume of lefts and rights to the face. Into the eighth, one could wonder when Escobedo might be overwhelmed but the moment was not coming and the former Olympian continued to fire between Katsidis’ rushes.
In the ninth, Escobedo’s courage was rewarded in spots as the relentless Katsidis ate some of the hardest lefts and rights of the fight along with a wicked left uppercut. Occasionally bouncing on his toes, Escobedo stayed a step ahead in round ten, narrowing the scorecards and working towards closing the left eye of Katsidis. He appeared still well behind, but rounds eleven and twelve loomed large.
Escobedo’s stand was stymied in round eleven, Katsidis again throwing, landing, too much. They battled on even terms to close what had been a memorable battle, flurrying at the bell to the applause of the crowd. The scoring would ultimately favor Katsidis twice at 115-113 and 118-110 with the remaining card going surprisingly to Escobedo at 116-112.
The referee was Russell Mora.
Katsidis-Escobedo was contested for the interim WBO Lightweight title. The formal WBO belt is still held by lineal World Lightweight champion Juan Manuel Marquez, also the owner of the WBA and Ring Magzine titles, and Katsidis would presumably be positioned for a shot at Marquez when the Mexican returns.
In the televised opener, 30-year old Featherweight Cornelius Locke (19-5-1, 12 KO), 125, of Detroit, Michigan, rebounded from a loss in his last outing to score a commanding knockout of previously undefeated 28-year old Orlando Cruz (16-1-1, 7 KO), 126, of Puerto Rico. The action was brick throughout but Locke showed dominance from the start, scoring a knockdown in the first and a sharp right hook in round five to drop Cruz a second time. Cruz rose, as he had in round one, but referee Robert Byrd halted the action at 2:04 of the fifth.
The card was televised in the U.S. on HBO Pay-Per-View, promoted by Golden Boy Promotions.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com