By Cliff Rold
For those who ask for only the best men in a given weight class in battle with each other, SHOWTIME’s Saturday doubleheader (9PM ET/PT) is manna from heaven. It’s a card full of intrigue and, as important, story.
There are the stories of two men once hailed as the best in class doing attempting to get there one more time; the story of a plucky veteran in pursuit of a defining win; and the heir apparent building his chops.
Let’s go to the report card(s).
Chad Dawson (25-0, 17 KO, WBC titlist) vs. Glen Johnson (47-11-2, 32 KO)
Speed: Dawson A-; Johnson B
Power: Dawson B; Johnson B
Defense: Johnson B+; Dawson B
Intangibles: Johnson A; Dawson B
Of all the big name fights this weekend, Dawson-Johnson may be the toughest to pick and the most fun to watch. Dawson is the faster man by quite a bit, but does he have the physical strength to keep Johnson on the outside? His long left jab, four inch height advantage, and lateral movement could make that the case.
Johnson comes forward behind somewhat of a modified shell defense. Moving in behind a stiff jab and high hands, he is able to throw nasty hooks and uppercuts once he works his way inside. The weakness there is that, if he gets caught outside, his defense can limit his offense forcing him to choose one or the other.
Both Dawson and Johnson lack real one punch power (Johnson’s knockout of Roy Jones notwithstanding). If their given foe doesn’t hear the final bell, an accumulation of shots pushed them to the brink. Johnson has been stopped only once, in an eleven round beating from Bernard Hopkins in 1997; Dawson has been dropped hard in each of his step-up fights against Eric Harding and Tomasz Adamek but has risen and fought effectively both times.
All of this adds up to a likely war of attrition. Dawson has the athleticism to run away with it if he settles into a rhythm, but at age 25, the temptation to make a statement won’t let him. Johnson will make him work hard and Dawson will be sore in the morning, but he should be sore with the relief of a unanimous decision.
Clinton Woods (41-3-1, 24 KO, IBF titlist) vs. Antonio Tarver (26-4, 19 KO)
Speed: Tarver B+; Woods B
Power: Tarver B+; Woods C+
Defense: Tarver B-; Woods B-
Intangibles: Tarver B; Woods B-
By no means is this a bad fight; it could turn out to be a damn good one in terms of entertainment value. Still, there’s got to be the feeling that this one is almost ‘loser leaves town.’
Tarver is 39 and almost two years removed from a drubbing against former World Middleweight king Bernard Hopkins for Ring Magazine’s version of the Light Heavyweight crown. His recent opposition has been about rebuilding and testing what the old man has left. Woods is another gauge of it.
A fighter who has always given his all, Woods has never been confused with any of the sports true elite fighters. He has a lot of wins on his record but a second look shows that the talent pool he’s beaten is fairly shallow. Take him off his home court and he could easily be 0-3 rather than 1-1-1 against Glen Johnson.
Tarver appears to be the faster man when he lets his hands go, but he’s never consistently done it even at his peak. Woods is deceptively fast on the inside; Tarver’s sometimes lax defense and lack of physical strength could allow him to do some serious work on the inside. Woods’ problem is that he is no defensive gem either. That spells trouble against a Tarver who still has a laser of a left hand. The power in the left could equal a Tarver stoppage win around the tenth.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com