By Cliff Rold
It’s rare that one could have a serious debate about whether or not 36 minutes of in-ring action was more or less exciting than the eleven minutes of rest time in the bout. That debate is upon us the one remarkable thing that can be said for Saturday night’s otherwise dreadful bout between now WBO and still IBF titlist Wladimir Klitschko (50-3, 44 KO) and Sultan Ibragimov (22-1-1, 17 KO).
This was not a good night for boxing in terms of reminding people why the Heavyweight championship of the world is supposed to matter. In fact, showcased alongside an HBO documentary about the life of Joe Louis, it was a reminder of what the title isn’t in February 2008. Klitschko has been more entertaining before, and will be more entertaining on some other date, but he made no progress in his effort to create a buzz around himself as the ‘baddest man on the planet.’
Let’s go to the report card.
Oh, wait, let’s not.
What analysis of the tactics in this bout would even make sense? Speed, power, defense? No, the only interesting analysis would be to examine this fight’s qualities as a sedative.
The nature of the bout was determined early on. Ibragimov’s best chance was certainly not to stand outside the pocket with his feet almost in different time zones in the hope that Klitschko would provide a giant opening for a miracle left hand. It was to try to get inside and land the best short hook he could muster. That didn’t happen and the result was viewed (at least temporarily; no telling how many gave up and went to bed) from there.
Klitschko will get his share of grief for never really engaging Ibragimov and should. The one right hand he landed flush late in the fight all but knocked his foe out of the ring. There’s no faulting the logic of taking the easy win when one can get it, and Klitschko figured out early that he could win with his jab alone. He couldn’t have picked a worse time for that sort of strategic decision.
This fight got more mainstream press ink than any Heavyweight fight in the last couple of years. Klitschko got a seat on Conan O’Brien and Fox News and the house was packed at Madison Square Garden. This was a golden, and lost, opportunity to stamp himself in the public consciousness. Ibragimov appeared no more dangerous than Klitschko knockout victims Calvin Brock in November 2006 or Ray Austin last year; if he had fought as if he believed that, Klitschko would have done himself and the sport a service.
Look, this fight earned a solid D grade leaning lower. Styles make fights, and sometimes they unmake them. This was the latter. Let’s look to the future.
During the fight, Ibragimov was verbally compared to WBA titlist Ruslan Chagaev in a way that would lead viewers to believe that Chagaev would create a similarly dull fight with Klitschko. After the bout, when commentator Max Kellerman summarized the steps Klitschko can take to solidifying his hold on the vacant World heavyweight championship, he skipped over Chagaev (24-0, 17 KO) to Samuel Peter, a fighter Klitschko beat about 9 rounds to 3 in 2005. Yes, Peter officially had Klitschko down in the three rounds he won, but nothing he’s done since (including one clean win over James Toney in two fights and getting off the floor multiple times to defeat Jameel McCline) suggests he can do much better than that. With officiating that is more vigilant against rabbit punching he could do worse.
That’s not even mentioning that Peter is going to be locked up in the race to be Vitali Klitschko’s next potentially postponed fight if and when he defeats Oleg Maskaev in two weeks for the WBC belt (something Vitali’s little brother Wladimir himself touched on in his post-fight interview). Vitali still maintains his ‘emeritus’ status in the WBC ratings, a status that allows him to demand a title shot whenever he wants to pay a sanctioning fee. That status is a primary reason for why it took over a year to get to Maskaev-Peter.
Conversely, Chagaev might be the only Heavyweight in the world right now with a serious chance to defeat Klitschko. He’s defeated former titlist John Ruiz and two current top ten Heavyweights in Vladimir Virchis and the seven-foot Nicolay Valuev. In the Valuev fight, Chagaev showed that he could handle a much larger man and outland him as well. Would he be able to do that against a Klitschko who is faster and more athletic than Valuev? That’s why they fight the fights.
If HBO, as his all but official promoter, wants the right opponent to make their financial investment into Klitschko add up to the words “true world champion,” Klitschko-Chagaev is the currently possible fight that definitively gets them there. Samuel Peter may be rated #2 by Ring Magazine, but Chagaev’s record and resume says that spot belongs to him.
Kellerman was correct though in arguing that, at this point, the line between consensus #1 Heavyweight and actual Heavyweight champion of the world is blurry at best. No matter the quality of Saturday night’s fight, Klitschko is still on a nine-fight win streak that includes wins over Peter, then-consensus #1 Chris Byrd in 2006, an avenging of his loss to Lamon Brewster and, with the Ibragimov win, the tying up of any direct lineage loose ends created by his WBO belt loss to Brewster in their first bout.
Klitschko may not have earned much applause Saturday night, but he’s earned the right to be called the best Heavyweight in the world until proven otherwise. That Klitschko did nothing Saturday to make being the world’s best Heavyweight boxer an event again is a different matter.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com