By Cliff Rold
A generation ago, Boxing’s reach into the sports mainstream would have made 24-year old Lightweight titlist Juan Diaz (33-0, 17 KO, WBA/WBO/IBF) a lock for real stardom. His combination of buzzsaw style and wholesome story would have been a gimme’.
A native of the All-American city of Houston, Texas; a college student while he holds his titles; works with the League of Women Voters to get out the vote; an aww-shucks old-school personality; and world-class non-stop combination punching from someone who just happens to be considered by many to be the best Lightweight in the World today.
25 years ago, he’s on a Wheaties box. Without a DeLaurean, it’ll be tough to get back to 25 years ago. No, it’s 2008 and Boxing struggles regularly to attract mainstream sports attention. Sure, Diaz has a solid following amongst boxing fans but, so far, that’s it.
That’s too bad.
It may be that there just isn’t room for Diaz’s kind anymore; maybe there isn’t room for the matinee idol. That’s what Diaz would have been then. He would have fit in nicely with a fighter like Ray Mancini, someone the man of the house could respect in the ring and Mom could want to bake a pie for. Mom might even be biting her nails as he headed into the ring with the power punching Nate Campbell (31-5-1, 25 KO) if this Saturday was a different Saturday, in a different time.
Instead, Diaz will be seen by an audience largely tuning in to see a Heavyweight curiosity in the main event and the ingredients that should make him a star will fail to get their just due again. Entering his eighth year as a professional, will Diaz ever get the chance he needs or is his fate to be enjoyed by the fight audience alone?
It can’t be all about the numbers on the calendar.
World Middleweight champion Kelly Pavlik put together a critical knockout streak on HBO last year and has been written up multiple times by mainstream outlets like Sports Illustrated. He was last seen throwing hooks on behalf of the campaign for Hilary Clinton in the critical primary state of Ohio. That resulted in his face being all over media outlets; a number of them, including MSNBC and Fox News, addressed him by both his name and title.
Leading Welterweight contender Miguel Cotto isn’t quite a mainstream star just yet, but he’s proving to be a consistent Pay-per-View draw and his presence at New York’s annual Puerto Rican day has done nothing but build his profile. As he continues to win, his position as a threat to the increasingly mainstream Floyd Mayweather Jr. should cross him over, if only for that superfight.
Pavlik and Cotto turned pro at roughly the same time as Diaz and are equivalently regarded in their weight classes. What then makes the difference? It could be a matter of smart promotion. Let’s face it, in his biggest battles Diaz has done his job in the ring but hasn’t been made to look like a star outside it. The crowd drawn to see him face Acelino Freitas was miles from home in Connecticut. His bout last October with Julio Diaz drew a crowd impersonating as many, if not more, empty seats than full ones. Contrast that with the rabid New York crowds Cotto draws or the vocal travelers that follow Pavlik.
Consider that Juan Diaz turned pro at the same time as and to nearly as much fanfare as Cotto; that he’s been on free national television; that he’s been written up feature-style by the New York Times prior to winning his first belt.
Something’s not adding up.
It could be his weight class. While he is seen as the best at 135 lbs., that doesn’t mean too much at the moment. It’s not a particularly deep or star-studded class when compared to the field five lbs. below (featuring Manny Pacquiao and Juan Manuel Marquez) or 12 pounds up at Welterweight (featuring Floyd Mayweather, Cotto, Shane Mosley and more).
It could be comfort with his promoter. That certainly has been an issue, and his relationship with Don King is all but over, with Diaz likely to move on to Golden Boy Promotions, the outfit he scorned to go with King in the first place. Golden Boy will be promoting the bout later this month between the debated World Lightweight champion Joel Casamayor (35-3-1, 21 KO) of Cuba and Michael Katsidis (23-0, 20 KO) of Australia. Can Golden Boy put Diaz on the track to catch up to his peers?
If they can get him to the winner of Casamayor-Katsidis, particularly if that winner is Katsidis as I expect it to be, then the answer might be yes. Diaz-Katsidis erases any doubts about the field at 135 lbs. through the joy of the violence those two can produce. Both in their prime, these two could generate the sort of bloodshed that forces full attention on the Houston native and maybe a desirable rematch on top of it; stardom by way of rivalry.
The key for greater stardom is there, somewhere, and Diaz will find it. The Wheaties box may be out of reach, but joining Pavlik and Cotto as the leaders of the new school is not. He’ll need a win this Saturday to keep that possible.
Ooops: In a brief piece on Tuesday of this week previewing the World Flyweight championship rematch between champion Daisuke Naito and challenger Pongsaklek Wonjongkam, I noted Naito as born in Tokyo. A reader in Japan, Kaneki Akiyuki, took the time to point out the following:
Dear Mr. Cliff Rold
This is a Japanese boxing fan in Tokyo, Japan. I read your article about the Wonjongkam-Naito bout. That was a quite interesting one full of love for boxing and deep insight to the sports. But there is one mistake about Naito. Although you mention Tokyo as the city of his birth, it is actually not. Naito was born in Hokkaido, the nothernmost prefecture of Japan. He came to Tokyo when he was 18. Other than this, the article is perfect. I often visit boxingscene.com to gather information about various fighters and bouts. Keep up the good work, sir!
I stand corrected, and anyone who points out one of my mistakes that politely can get a mention anytime.
Making Haye: With his eye already on Heavyweight prizes, the U.K.’s David Haye (20-1, 19 KO) may be one and done as the World Crusierweight champion should he successfully defend this weekend against Welshman Enzo Maccarinelli (28-1, 20 KO, WBO titlist). Parlaying a sentiment expressed when it looked like we might not even get one defense out of the thrilling power puncher (https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=11220), it will be a shame if this fight marks somewhat of an end to what has been an incredible action run at the 200 lb. class. That Haye is defending his crown gives hope that the end may not be upon us.
Maccarinelli, in what should be the fight of the week, has a serious shot at taking the legitimate championship of the world home with him this Saturday. If so, that eliminates the threat of a pause, if not a stop, to the cruiserweight run. The drum could begin beating immediately for Enzo to face the man most deserving of a title shot right now, American Steve Cunningham (21-1, 11 KO, IBF titlist), and that would be a fight just as intriguing as the one this Saturday.
Then again, Haye going to Heavyweight with a win wouldn’t be the worst thing. Heavyweight needs a fighter who knows that part of his job is to show up and be exciting. Haye, even with a questionable chin, never fails in that regard.
Heinz: Allow me to chime in with my regrets about the passing of the great W.C. Heinz last week. The writers of yesterday are a fading breed, and Heinz carried heavy company in men like Jimmy Cannon and Red Smith. In less than a year, the world of and outside Boxing has lost three friends who provided, among other things, words that illuminate the canvas of the minds eye, also including Norman Mailer and Hank Kaplan. These are great losses not because I or most of you reading knew these men personally. I didn’t.
They are great losses because their minds were a gift no longer available.
Peggy Noonan, a former speech writer for President Ronald Reagan, wrote a fitting tribute in the Wall Street Journal last week to honor the passing of conservative intellectual giant William Buckley. In it she offered that, “when Jackie Onassis died, a friend of mine who knew her called me and said, with such woe, "Oh, we are losing her kind." He meant the elegant, the cultivated, the refined. I thought of this with Bill's passing, that we are losing his kind--people who were deeply, broadly educated in great universities when they taught deeply and broadly, who held deep views of life and the world and art and all the things that make life more delicious and more meaningful. We have work to do as a culture in bringing up future generations that are so well rounded, so full and so inspiring…the individualist at work in the world, the defender of great creeds and great beliefs going forth with spirit, style and joy. May we not lose his kind.”
Noonan’s sentiment applies in spirit to the passing of Heinz as well. Heinz, on the printed page, was of a special kind
Cliff’s Notes…
Finally, I’ll admit that I’m still walking in the shadow of Vasquez-Marquez III last Saturday. It’s a fight that remains stuck in my head as I debate with myself where it places historically. I couldn’t resist weighing in on just that to start the week. I also had a thing or two to say about the critical events to come this weekend. Feel free to peek back at those.
Marquez-Vasquez III: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=12911
The T.V. Fights of the Week: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=12940
Naito-Wonjongkam IV: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=12952
The Fight of Fighter of February: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=12896
I hope you enjoy reading them as much as I enjoy writing them.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com