By Cliff Rold (photo by Joe Cordova/FightWireImages)
Paulie Malignaggi warned all week the deck was stacked against him. He went out and fought a hell of a fight anyways. Then the scores were read with the best of them saved for last. Gale Van Hoy’s 118-110 score in favor of Juan Diaz is a candidate for worst scorecard of the year if not the decade. After the fight, HBO’s Max Kellerman talked about elements of the marketplace, or the idea of a hometown draw getting the benefit of the doubt in close ones.
115-113 is marketplace.
A fair case could be made it was right.
Because, being fair, different eyes could see Diaz or Malignaggi deserving the nod. There were lots of close rounds and 115-113 either way was a reasonable outcome. 116-112 might have been pushing it but there have been worse cards.
118-110?
118-110, or ten rounds to two, was a Jo Jo Guerra special. 118-110 was so far removed from reality as to suggest Paulie was right all along. Partially muted, Malignaggi went deep into the well in his post-fight interview, referencing past egregious outcomes in Texas into the days of Julio Cesar Chavez (Remember the Alamodome!). Given the smiling face of Diaz’s promoter, Oscar De La Hoya, in the background, we can all assume the same demand for an investigation that followed the scores of De La Hoya’s rematch with Shane Mosley and controversially scored wins against Pernell Whitaker, Ike Quartey and Felix Sturm.
Okay, maybe not the latter three.
Let’s go to the report card.
Grades
Pre-Fight: Speed - Diaz B+; Malignaggi B+/Post: B+; A
Pre-Fight: Power - Diaz B-; Malignaggi C-/Post: Same
Pre-Fight: Defense - Diaz B; Malignaggi B/Post: B/B+
Pre-Fight: Intangibles - Diaz B+; Malignaggi B/Post: B; A-
Perhaps the most striking element of the fight, from the opening bell, was how different this Malignaggi (26-3, 5 KO) was from the fighter who was stormed by Ricky Hatton last year. The legs were back and as the fight progressed, so was the swagger. His speed was clearly underestimated in the pre-fight report card and he used his hands and feet to control geography for steady stretches of the bout. Diaz (35-2, 17 KO) looked downright plodding at times. Malignaggi needed to force Diaz to reset often to win on Saturday and did it enough to give himself a shot. To Diaz’s credit, his ability to whip off shots in multiple allowed for him to have his own moments throughout.
Neither man is much of a puncher, which was known before the opening bell and evident in the ring. It didn’t hurt the action as the pace was outstanding and the leather never really stopped flying. Power isn’t a prerequisite to a hell of a fight at the lower weights. Skills and styles can make for plenty worth watching and did here. Because each man was throwing, they were also catching but Malignaggi gets more credit for defense because he was more often able to deflect the rushes.
In terms of the intangibles, both men scored high. As Diaz pointed out after the bout, he never wavered at the sight of his own blood, a charge made after losses to Nate Campbell and Juan Manuel Marquez. The charge was always a little silly given that he was hit a hell of a lot, and hard, in those fights. The one bad sign tonight was that Diaz was troubled by Malignaggi’s movement far more than could be expected. He hasn’t faced a lot of Malignaggi’s type of style in his career and in the long run this weekend’s difficulties could be good for him.
Malignaggi gets credit because, just two fights ago, it appeared he might be shot. His performance against Diaz, easily still one of the best Lightweights in the world, says a lot about how good Hatton was that night and how much Malignaggi has left. Malignaggi doesn’t have a style everyone loves, but he fights with guts and heart and makes the most of what he’s got. He can walk away knowing it still takes a genuinely elite Jr. Welterweight to convincingly beat him.
Looking Ahead
Unfortunately for Malignaggi, there aren’t a lot of options for him right now but perhaps the sympathy he’ll get from this could make him viable for a guy like Devon Alexander, a still building potential star who needs to add some more depth to his dossier.
For Diaz, while he struggled Saturday, he remains one of the most consistently watchable fighters in the game. Malignaggi’s skill and speed made him look less than his best, but world class foes can do that. Diaz didn’t show any signs of slack since his loss to Marquez and was wise to call for a rematch. It would be shocking if Marquez got by Floyd Mayweather in September, meaning he should be back to defend his Lightweight crown. Diaz-Marquez I is still the fight of the year in 2009; could Diaz-Marquez II shine in 2010?
The undercard provided food for thought as well. Robert Guerrero (25-1-1, 17 KO) looked like he might let a huge early lead slip away only to dig deep in the final two rounds to seal an earned IBF 130 lb. title win over Malcolm Klassen (24-5-2, 15 KO). Klassen showed he could be in the fight but it took him four flat rounds to prove it and he never recovered. Guerrero gets credit for a strategy that didn’t look for his power and instead relied on some of the best boxing he’s ever done. He beat Klassen with his feet.
Can he beat the rest of the best at Jr. Lightweight? With fellow titlists like Jorge Linares and Humberto Soto around, let’s hope we find out.
In the opener, Daniel Jacobs (18-0, 15 KO) got what was expected: his toughest outing to date. Opponent Ishe Smith (21-4, 9 KO) did what he was there to do, losing while exposing some of the weaknesses in Jacobs developing game. This will be the most valuable training tape Jacobs has generated yet. The Brooklyn-ite remains a work in progress but, only 22, that’s not a bad thing.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com