By Cliff Rold
It wasn’t the buzz-generating main event most hoped for, and the undercard brawl took a little while to break out, but no fan could walk away disappointed. Saturday night on HBO, two quality fights broke out and two careers got back on track while leaving the defeated in a place where they too could hold their heads high.
The pencil and pad cats at ringside however should hang their heads in shame. The scoring that would have resulted had Rocky Juarez-Jorge Barrios gone to the cards was on the way to being an epic stain; the scoring that did result in Juan Diaz-Michael Katsidis, while ultimately selecting the correct winner, was equally awful. Juan Diaz may have won as many as eleven rounds on the night and at least eight; he walked away with a split decision. Jorge Barrios looked to have built a solid lead through the first two-third of his bout with Juarez but was down by two and four points before being stopped on a vicious, Joker-esque lip split in the eleventh. Sure, he was coughing that perceived lead up, but it doesn’t change what was coming.
For a more specific call of the action, loyal readers can check out Jake Donovan’s excellent post-fight recap: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=15777
Forget what could have been for now; what will be is hope for the future, particularly the Light weight future 24-year old Juan Diaz (34-1, 17 KO) after Diaz gave his hometown Houston fans a performance worth paying for (and scanning the size of the crowd, they did in spades).
Let’s go to the report card.
Speed: In the pre-fight report card, it was noted that “athletically, Katsidis might be faster but Diaz gets off in combination in ways few other fighters can. His approach can wear down opponents mentally because he throws those combinations both first and in counter.” There was no mental breaks for the 28-year old Katsidis (23-2, 20 KO) and in fact he appeared to have learned from the hurting loss to World Lightweight champion Joel Casamayor. His hands were held higher, his punches thrown straighter and the athletic speed advantage was there. What was also there was Diaz’s ability to block and parry shots, punching in between Katsidis’ best efforts and ripping in combination. Diaz’s first shot might not be the fastest, but his fourth in succession probably is. The jab of Diaz was quick and accurate all night as were the short left hook and snapping right uppercut he uses to great affect Pre-Fight Grades: Diaz B+; Katsidis B/Post-Fight: Both B+
Power: On paper, it appeared Katsidis’ best chance to win would be crashing home with something Diaz didn’t see and putting the young Texan on the floor. In the ring, it was the case and he couldn’t get the big shot home. Two factors could be blamed: Diaz’s chin when hit and his ability not to get hit much anyways. Diaz landed in the first two-thirds of the fight by near 3-1 advantages and Katsidis, who has been officially knocked down by both Casamayor and the light punching Graham Earl, never appeared in any serious jeopardy of heading to sleep. In other words, Diaz is just not a puncher; well, at least not a power puncher. He is a volume puncher and there is no doubt his opponents feel it in the morning. Katsidis’ swollen face and lacerations will stare back at him from the mirror for quite a few days. Pre-Fight Grades: Katsidis A-; Diaz B/Post-Fight: Same
Defense: Katsidis, after building a reputation for wars lacking in any pretense of defense, deserves credit for technical improvement against Diaz. He fought a mature, controlled fight and applied more defense than is his norm. Sure, he still got busted up, but he also blocked well, kept his hands high, moved his head and, significantly, kept his chin tucked for all twelve rounds. Diaz’s defense was as it always is: tight and consistent. For a guy who throws as often as Diaz does, who has the reputation for action he does, Diaz can be an unsung defensive gem. The turtle shell he gives himself makes him extremely difficult to hit clean. The only fighter whose gotten past it, Nate Campbell this past March, did it by standing his ground and forcing Diaz to try and get around Campbell’s educated shoulder work. Katsidis had some late success in close with Diaz as well but moved too much and opted out of long stays in the trenches. Pre-Fight Grades: Diaz B; Katsidis D+/Post-Fight: Diaz A-; Katsidis C+
Intangibles: The narrative of this bout sought to examine who would suffer most from their first defeat. Both Diaz and Katsidis showed they’d learned from previous bad days and, more importantly, moved on. Neither man showed any give, any ghosts, or any less a will to win than they ever have. There’s a feeling among many older followers that losses are dramatically overrated today. It used to be part of the learning curve. Diaz and Katsidis suggest wisdom in the older generation. Pre-Fight Grades: Diaz B+; Katsidis B-/Post-Fight: A’s all around
Diaz can now look ahead, and not too far. While it was disappointing to not hear him say on HBO how much he’d like to get revenge on Nate Campbell, the thought of Diaz facing the winner of next week’s Joel Casamayor-Juan Manuel Marquez fight certainly wouldn’t be a bad option for Diaz or the fans. It wouldn’t be a bad option for the sport either, putting a still-rising star in with the biggest possible name.
Katsidis has nothing to be ashamed of even with a loss and there is no reason to think he won’t be seen many more times on U.S. TV. In three appearances going back to the summer of 2007, he’s given the paying masses what they came for. Heck, Katsidis versus one Breidis Prescott, a shock winner over highly touted Amir Khan earlier Saturday in the UK, would be earth-scorching.
And who knows…if Katsidis can continue to show the fight to fight improvement he displayed Saturday, a rematch with Diaz somewhere down the road might provide the classic Boxing didn’t quite get this weekend.
Bonus Coverage
The HBO undercard also provided some thrills in a solid affair between 2000 U.S. Olympian Rocky Juarez (28-4, 20 KO) and former WBO Jr. Lightweight titlist Jorge Barrios (47-4-1, 34 KO). Juarez picked up his first serious top ten win since facing 1996 Olympian Zahir Raheem in 2004 as well as his second win over a former titleholder. The grades earned on Saturday went pretty much as predicted; in fact none of the pre-fight grades earned an increase or decrease:
Speed: Juarez B; Barrios B
Power: Juarez B+; Barrios B+
Defense: Juarez B; Barrios B-
Intangibles: Juarez B; Barrios B+
After Saturday, it’s safe to say Juarez can be considered the equivalent of David Tua in the 130 lb. class. He plods forward, waiting for the perfect punch, doling out measured punishment where he can. Against the very best in class, the strategy fails. Against everyone else, it works. Barrios leapt to an early lead with a jab and plenty of wild stuff; Juarez just stalked along until some hurting body work opened up opportunities for clean combinations. Problems with the scoring aside, Juarez didn’t look like he was letting Barrios hear the final bell even without the nasty split lip.
From here, Juarez finds a wide open 130 lb. class about to be conjoined with the likes of Robert Guerrero and Jorge Linares. After earlier career losses to Humberto Soto, Juan Manuel Marquez and Marco Antonio Barrera (twice), Juarez may only be hitting the beginning of his time with the world title level. We’ll have to wait and see.
One thing is certain. Houston, Texas will wait and pay to see. Golden Boy Promotions put on a show and put butts in the seats. By showing up for locals Diaz and Juarez, the fine people of the Lone Star State may have created a new destination for big time Boxing. Houston definitely gets an A.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com