By Cliff Rold
Photo © Ed Mulholland/FightWireImages.com
A little more than one week from now, world super middleweight champion Joe Calzaghe (42-0, 31 KOs) of Wales will make his second defense of the crown since gaining universal recognition as ‘the man’ last year against US Olympian Jeff Lacy. His pending bout, against Ring Magazine #10 contender Peter Manfredo (26-3, 12 KOs), will also mark the 20th defense of his WBO belt. Yet, for all his accomplishments and dominance at 168 lbs., Calzaghe can’t help but hear the whispers, the questions about whether he has made a lasting impression.
Having just turned 35 (happy birthday champ), words like ‘history’ and ‘legacy’ should be taking on new meanings. It’s this simple: everyone knows he’s good but is Joe Calzaghe great? More importantly, if Calzaghe should defeat the prohibitive underdog Manfredo as expected, will he make the decision a great fighter would make and face his #1 contender, Denmark’s Mikkel Kessler (39-0, 29 KOs)? Having been a smashing success in his HBO debut, Kessler has made that question one of the biggest in the sport.
It might be unfair, but asking that question almost assumes a Calzaghe victory against Manfredo. Manfredo, who cut his teeth as the first season runner-up on “The Contender,” is not a bad fighter. There has been little to indicate that he’s a special one either. After ten years on top of his division, it’s unlikely that Calzaghe will fall to anything less.
While the competitive merit of this bout is questionable (Manfredo fought the bulk of his career at 154 lbs. and has yet to beat a legitimate top contender at any weight), the business quality of this decision is not. Calzaghe has made no secret that he wants to make a mark in the United States and Manfredo is more recognizable than most fighters stateside. (Ironically, in a strange twist of fate, after years of yearning for big U.S. money, the biggest money available may now be against the European foe on U.S. TV.)
HBO gives this bout the Manfredo bout its biggest possible stage and grants Calzaghe a chance to stamp himself firmly in the minds of those who missed him over the years. What it does not do is finish the process of validating his place in the record books. This is his second chance to complete that journey.
After all, Kessler is the second titlist to unify belts under Calzaghe’s watch. For much of Calzaghe’s time as a titleholder, his spot at the top was shared with Germany’s Sven Ottke. It was assumed by many that Ottke and his handlers plain weren’t willing to take that fight. Regardless, Ottke would retire undefeated in 34 bouts with the IBF and WBA straps around his waist. Had Calzaghe been able to get Ottke into a ring, history might be more forgiving of a failure to face Kessler today. He did not and history beckons still.
There are those who will ponder alternatives to that view. Some might point to the win over Lacy as enough but most that had actually seen Lacy and Kessler knew the bigger challenge was Kessler as early as 2005.
If Lacy doesn’t cut it, facing the winner of the June bout between Bernard Hopkins and Winky Wright would suffice for Joe, right? It would be nice but, without Kessler, Calzaghe will never be able to claim the same stake of greatness that both Wright and Hopkins already do.
Former undisputed champions at 154 and 160 lbs. respectively, Wright and Hopkins made their mark by leaving no doubt. They cleaned out their primary divisions, facing down younger men or men expected to beat them. Wright won (and lost a few) against near everyone of note in his class from Julio Cesar Vasquez to Shane Mosley. Hopkins went so far as to enter Madison Square Garden to stare down Puerto Rican icon Felix Trinidad, the ultimate home field disadvantage, and made sure to face his heir apparent Jermain Taylor twice before leaving middleweight behind.
Beating a 42 year old Hopkins will never mean for Calzaghe what beating the younger B-Hop would have. It will mean even less if he proves a lesser champion in his own class than Hopkins was in his.
Kessler is not, after all, a run of the mill contender. He has faced five consecutive top ten contenders, owns wins over three of the current top five, has six total wins over current/former alphabet titlists, and picked up two of his own alphabet titles (WBC/WBA) along the way. The most recent moment of this notable run is Kessler’s shut-out of then #5 contender Librado Andrade (24-1, 18 KOs).
Based on this resume, Kessler dwarfs the challenges presented to Calzaghe in the past. Quick: name Calzaghe’s five best wins? Kind of tough isn’t it. Jeff Lacy rolls off the tongue; maybe Chris Eubank follows. Add on Byron Mitchell, Charles Brewer, Robin Reid, Richie Woodhall…and the pool gets pretty shallow from there. It’s not all Joe’s fault; after all, fighters with double digit title defenses always have some forgettable foes along the way. Joe just seems to have more than a reasonable share of them. Various cancellations, postponements, and a history of injuries over the years haven’t helped, building speculation of a hesitant warrior.
Calzaghe-Kessler would make every argument and criticism moot for good. A win and he’s cleaned out the division. Calzaghe will also have an emphatic case that he and he alone is not just king for today but king for all-time in the some 24-year history of his weight class. Should the result be a loss in a close, exciting bout then guess what? The winner of Hopkins-Wright is likely still to be there.
So watch with interest not just the fighting skills but the post-fight rhetoric on April 7, 2007. If, as expected, Calzaghe stands victorious over Manfredo and has little to say of a showdown with Kessler, the answer may be had. Great fighters chase greatness wherever it can be achieved. If Joe, in the twilight of his career, wishes to achieve lasting greatness, Kessler will be the first word out of his mouth.
Rold Rants and Rambles…
Kessler’s Passport: If Joe’s feet are to be held to the public fire to make this fight, so too must Kessler answer his end. Efforts will be made certainly to make this bout on neutral turf, but if it can only happen in the UK, Kessler needs to get on a plane. His promoters and managers may resist, but Kessler needs to be the boss and slam his foot down on this one. It’s one thing to say you want the man; it’s another to be willing to do whatever it takes to get him. Muhammad Ali, Sugar Ray Robinson…heck, Brian Mitchell…all went on the road when they had to. If the money’s legitimately not right, that’s one thing. If geography stops this bout, the blame should fall squarely on Kessler. After all, no matter how many belts he has, he’s the challenger in this must-have bout...
Sergio Mora – Wasted Snake: I can sort of understand the rationale of the Mora camp in turning down a bout with World Middleweight champion Jermain Taylor in Memphis. What I can’t understand from the “Contender” season one winner is why he isn’t fighting at all. Since winning the show in May 2005, he’s had three bouts, his last coming in August 2006. He’s been ten rounds once and has a paltry 19 fights since turning pro in 2000. If all Mora’s people want to do is cash him out, then fine. This pace ought to cover it. If Sergio’s interested in being a significant professional fighter, he should try a professional schedule. He’s not good enough to rest on his laurels yet…
Hill-Maske II: Has it really been eleven years since Virgil Hill-Henry Maske I? Considering how old the two of them are heading into their rematch, I would have thought it was more like twenty. I’m not sure what purpose this fight serves, but if two old veterans can find people to pay to watch them go through the motions this Saturday, more power to them.
I’ll be slightly interested in the outcome for my own reasons. Hill-Maske II gives a chance to reflect on the result of their first bout in 1996. If Hill goes to the Hall of Fame one day, it is the Maske win that most gets him there. It was the win that made him the undisputable World champion at 175 lbs. after 20 title defenses over two WBA title reigns and earned him Maske’s IBF strap. The only other titlist of note at the time, Fabrice Tiozzo (WBC), had lost to Hill prior during that second WBA run and thus didn’t count. The culmination of Hill’s career was also the start of a lasting mess.
Today, Bernard Hopkins is widely recognized as the light heavyweight king, having won it from Antonio Tarver who won it from Roy Jones. Who did Roy win it from? That’s the mess. Hill lost the real title to Dariusz Michalzewski in 1997. Michalzewski took the lineal, true World title to Germany and sat on it; first, against solid challengers and then, particularly after 2000, against a lot of stiffs before losing to Julio Gonzalez in 2003 (who lost in his first defense to Zsolt Erdei).
That means historically, for those of us who believe that lineage still matters, Zsolt Erdei is the real World Champion at 175 lbs. Erdei (26-0, 16 KOs), an Olympic medalist from Hungary, is a fine fighter and would make a great fight with Hopkins but the chance of the true light heavyweight champion and the best light heavyweight facing off seemingly remains farther away then eleven years…
The Ten Second Bell: Great fight this Friday on Telefutura as former flyweight titlist Irene Pacheco (33-1, 24 KOs) challenges WBO 118 lb. titlist Jhonny Gonzalez (33-5, 28 KOs). Pacheco has won three in a row since being stopped in a 2004 war by Vic Darchinyan and Gonzalez is making his first start since his brutal loss to Israel Vasquez. This has all the makings of a solid fight as each man battles to extend his time in the money pool…Oh yeah, Hill still beats Maske…IBF cruiserweight titlist Krzysztof Wlodarczyk and Steve Cunningham have agreed to terms for their immediate rematch. The first fight was not seen in the US, was probably won by Cunnigham, and, hey, who cares? There is only one World champion at cruiserweight: Jean Marc Mormeck. Those who willingly pay for shots at belts corrupted by strippings (this belt was taken from then undisputed champ O’Neill Bell because he was injured) lose the right to complain about corrupt decisions…If you get a chance, check out the new book from BoxingScene’s own Tom Donelson. “Boxing in the Shadows” is a welcome addition to any bookshelf…It’s got to be asked: Does Manfredo have a real chance at the upset next week? The answer might be yes if history is the guide; more on that next week.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com