By Cliff Rold
It wasn’t pretty. No one bore witness to a classic. But at the end of the day, the pride of Wales embraced the concept of winning today, looking good tomorrow, and maintained his career long undefeated run. This scribe ultimately came up with a score of 116-111 in favor of the victor but opinions vary with an educated minority leaning towards Bernard Hopkins.
We all knew they were past their prime coming in, but it didn’t mean the anticipation wasn’t there. In what was likely a one-time only showdown between the best Middleweight and Super Middleweight of their eras, and two men who will be in the conversation with the all-time greats at those weights for so long as there is a barber’s chair, would we have it any other way than food for debate?
At the end of the day the record reads…
Joe Calzaghe (45-0, 32 KO) W SD12 Bernard Hopkins (48-5-1, 32 KO)
Let’s go to the report card.
In Friday’s preview the following grades were assessed:
Speed: Calzaghe A; Hopkins B
Power: Hopkins B+; Calzaghe B
Defense: Hopkins A; Calzaghe B+
Intangibles: Hopkins A; Calzaghe A
After twelve rounds of action, and inaction, those grades clearly bear some new evaluation. Calzaghe’s perceived advantage in speed largely made the difference in the fight but it wasn’t that wide a gap. In the first third of the fight, the 36-year old Calzaghe even looked slow in spots, missing left hands wide. As observed by the HBO announce team, Calzaghe made adjustments in the form of shorter shots; slaps if you will, but accumulating slaps. By the end of the bout, Calzaghe had doubled Hopkins in both punch output and punch connects. Whether Compubox is all that accurate is another debate; it was clear he landed more and he did so because his reflexes allowed him to do so.
The power edge for Hopkins was there as expected. The first round knockdown of Calzaghe wasn’t a hurting blow; Calzaghe rose quickly with his legs beneath him. It was though a reminder that, when he wants to, Hopkins can do damage. The thing that made the shot so effective was that he walked Calzaghe into it as if it was choreographed. In his mind, one would suspect it was. To Calzaghe’s credit, few right hands would land that flush again. Calzaghe did a good job of blocking and slipping the shot the rest of the night, avoiding or at least muffling their weight. What he didn’t do was land anything that seemed to make Hopkins say “Whoa.” Then again, Hopkins still excellent chin never seems to allow that.
Defense was on display, too much display, from both men. Hopkins complained after the fight that he left with his face unmarked. Let’s ignore that the only mark Calzaghe had was a bridge of the nose scrape that probably came from a headbutt. Hopkins unmarked face was largely a product of a game plan that revolved around fighting as little as possible. He was so focused on defense that often his own shots were off the mark, uncommitted to in hope of not getting hit in return. That allowed Calzaghe to use Hopkins defensive posture against him. Calzaghe got hit with some stiff stuff, but only once at a time and rarely in the second half of the fight.
As expected, perhaps even feared, the fight came down to the intangibles category by way of a chess match. One could almost see Hopkins and Calzaghe thinking in the ring and, with the final scores as a gauge, it was Calzaghe whose mind won out. The 43-year old Hopkins has made clear over the last few years what it is that he brings to the ring. Calzaghe looked like he’d be sucked into it, and then wasn’t. Over the second half of the bout, as he did last November against the more engaging Mikkel Kessler, Calzaghe figured out what his best play would be, flurrying and moving forward to win almost every, if not every, round from seven on through to the end. A case could be made that Hopkins stole the tenth after he went Vlade Divac on a not-so-low blow, but that’s about it.
There just aren’t many points to go around for a dazzling exhibition of “look how effective I am at stopping a fight from breaking out”…and if fans want to see unmarked faces, there are plenty of Proactive commercials with Jessica Simpson that are better on the eyes. As was the case in Pernell Whitaker’s much worthier of debate loss to Oscar De la Hoya in 1997, Hopkins fell too much in love with his ‘style’ and forgot that he had to impress more people than himself.
Post Fight Grades
Speed: Calzaghe B+; Hopkins B
Power: Hopkins B+; Calzaghe B
Defense: Hopkins B; Calzaghe B
Intangibles: Calzaghe A; Hopkins B
Overall: Calzaghe B+; Hopkins B
In the end, we got a new Ring Magazine Light Heavyweight titlist and a strong possibility of a fall showdown between Calzaghe and Roy Jones Jr. The fight did nothing to hurt Hopkins place in history and will largely serve as a footnote to both men’s Hall of Fame careers. Hopkins will always be able to say it would have been different if he was younger; Calzaghe will always reply that it wouldn’t have changed the result. For they, and their fans, their will never be an answer good enough. Calzaghe’s backers at least have the measure of April 19, 2008 bragging rights.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com