By Cliff Rold
It’s an old cliché, the one about the light at the end of the tunnel either being the sun or an oncoming train. It’s also an apt description of today’s Heavyweight division heading into this Saturday’s HBO (9:30 PM EST/6:30 PM PST) showdown between titlists and top contenders Wladimir Klitschko (49-3, 44 KO, Ring Magazine #1, IBF belt) of the Ukraine and Sultan Ibragimov (22-0-1, 17 KO, #6, WBO belt) of Russia. Is this the beginning of the drive to clarity in the division or just a road bump on the avenue of chaos?
For the two warriors heading to the ring this weekend, it’s the former. With the WBC belt almost sure to be tied up in politics through most of 2008 and no guarantee that the winner of Klitschko-Ibragimov will face WBA titlist Ruslan Chagaev (24-0-1, 17 KO) before the end of the year, the possibility of more chaos ultimately winning out can’t be ignored. To defeat that depressing thought, we have one night of something better.
Ibragimov was once thought, singularly, to be something better as one of the division’s hottest prospects. An off the floor struggle with journeyman contender Ray Austin in July 2006, and dull WBO belt-winning and defending efforts against faded former World Heavyweight champions Shannon Briggs and Evander Holyfield last year threw some water on any sparks Ibragimov was generating. He proved to be good enough in those fights to earn his place among today’s top heavyweights. The problem is that being good enough amongst today’s top Heavyweights is no plaudit. The impression has been, since Lennox Lewis’s abdication of the true throne in 2004 and had been even in the years prior, that the Heavyweight division has sunk to a level of permanent average.
That is not to say Ibragimov, 32, has an entirely average resume. He made it to the final round of the 2000 Olympic Heavyweight bracket before losing a competitive decision to the great Cuban amateur Felix Savon. He followed that with a bronze medal at the 2001 World Championships. None of that will matter if he can’t figure out how to, from his southpaw stance, demand respect from Klitschko with a left hook or two.
The odds suggest that he’s not expected to do that; at least not to great effect. Klitschko, 31, a 1996 Olympic Super Heavyweight Gold Medalist, is a strong favorite in this bout and for good reason. He holds a 4 ½ inch height advantage (6’6 ½ to 6’2) and should outweigh Ibragimov by at least twenty pounds. His right hand is among the most devastating in the game. And his chin…
…ahh, the Wladimir chin. Or is it the Wladimir stamina? Who knows which the bigger x-factor is from fight to fight, but both have failed him in the past. Klitschko has been on the deck and/or forced into frightening bouts of fatigue courtesy of Steve Pannell, Ross Purrity, Corrie Sanders, Lamon Brewster, Davarryl Williamson, and Samuel Peter. Those x-factors are why a fighter who can look so dominant on offense is also so suspect in other regards.
Talk to the old-timers and hardly a one has much nice to say about Klitschko. Currently on an eight-fight winning streak and regarded as the best active Heavyweight by a wide margin, Klitschko has failed to convincingly put past failures behind him. That’s for good reason; history suggests that failures returning repeatedly to similar factors equal up to failures in the future. The otherwise spectacular Jr. Middleweight Terry Norris was built by God with every tool imaginable but a world-class chin; he didn’t grow one over time and Klitschko is unlikely to pull that off either. If he defeats Ibragimov, there will be many who chalk it up to his being the least mediocre, rather than the best, Heavyweight in the world.
Those attitudes and realities are why it’s hard to say whether or not Klitschko-Ibragimov marks a new beginning or more of the same train wreck that has ruled in the absence of Lewis. No matter who wins, or how, there will be many (probably me too) who will still be waiting for the other shoe to drop, for any momentum generated to be blunted in short order.
It’s called parity, and it’s never been good to the Heavyweight division. It’s also never been rare.
How many Heavyweights were perceived as much better than average between the reigns of Jim Jeffries and Jack Johnson? Between Gene Tunney and Joe Louis? Between Rocky Marciano and Sonny Liston?
How shallow was the field of serious contenders that confronted Larry Holmes? Mike Tyson? Lewis?
How many times has the Heavyweight division really been all that good? (The answer is probably five times by the way: the Corbett-Jeffries years; the days of the African-American round robin that featured Johnson and Sam Langford; the Marciano years; Ali’s 70s; and the bulk of the 1990s).
Let’s face it, the big boys might have garnered the most fame and the most episodes of Sports Century but the number of them who truly stand with the greatest fighters of all time, regardless of weight, isn’t that many. It is a division that has been far sturdier in times of dominant force than it has unpredictable competition. It is a division overwhelmed through time by fighters who have been just ‘pretty good.’
That’s the case today. The post-Lewis years have often been treated unfairly in relation to the number of exciting fights that have occurred because there just hasn’t been a single fighter to generate lasting excitement or a belief in fans that they are truly watching a champion.
It hasn’t helped that many fans feel like they’ve been force fed a hype job about both Klitschko’s (big brother Vitali included) that sounded, and sounds, like a louder trumpet than merited. Rather than leave them to be judged on their merits as what they have been and are (which is good but not nearly great prizefighters), ratcheted rhetoric has made their flaws more glaring.
That’s too bad because neither has been, and the active Wladimir is not, that bad. In fact, Wladimir is a pretty good Heavyweight. If he’d been around between the reigns of Jeffries and Johnson, or Marciano and Liston, Wladimir might even be seen as a great Heavyweight. Much smaller but still former World Heavyweight champions Tommy Burns and Floyd Patterson would have been hard pressed to stay in the ring with him; they’re both enshrined in the Hall of Fame. Timing sometimes can dictate perceptions.
More important than timing, time can change a lot. The Heavyweight division in darker times is thus always headed both towards the sun and an oncoming train if we see the sun as the future and the oncoming train as the next great Heavyweight. None of the current cast may fit the bill, but we all know, deep down, that somewhere on a planet of 8-billion plus, a potentially great Heavyweight is in a gym. He might still be an amateur. He might be a young pro that hasn’t reached his full potential just yet.
But he’s out there.
And if we have to live through a little more chaos to get to him, than that’s what we’ll do. We’ll live. And a fight like Klitschko-Ibragimov isn’t tough to live with at all.
Breakdown: Tune in to BoxingScene tomorrow for the pre-fight report card and pick on this Saturday’s fight.
B.A.D. Ass Idea: After last Saturday’s Pavlik-Taylor II undercard, I would hope that there are more converts to what should be a deep 115 lb. bandwagon. In the world of pundits, the idea of a must-see encounter between the division’s two best fighters, Cristian Mijares and Fernando Montiel, has come up everywhere from MaxBoxing to ESPN to the clickable pages here at BoxingScene. It’s a perfect fight for HBO’s Boxing After Dark but there’s no reason it need dance alone.
The devastation that Montiel (36-2-1, 27 KO, #1, WBO belt) left in his wake against the proven Martin Castillo, and the sheer mastery that Mijares (34-3-2, 14 KO, #3, WBC belt) displayed against Carlos Navarro, makes it easily one of the best fights that can be made in any division and the clear choice to fill the vacant World title in the division. These Jr. Bantamweights are not the only men who deserve some spotlight time in the sun though.
Since I’m playing armchair matchmaker, why not a doubleheader pairing Mijares-Montiel with the other best fight available below 122 lbs., World Jr. Flyweight champion Ivan Calderon (30-0, 6 KO) versus his number one contender Ulises Solis (26-1-2, 20 KO). If HBO doesn’t like the sound of that show, maybe Showtime could. It might not be a ratings bonanza but at the right arena it could draw a hell of a crowd and, more importantly, the two winners would emerge as undeniably strong members of the pound-for-pound debate.
Would any real boxing fan be anywhere but watching a show with those two fights on it?
The Worst: Since I mentioned Mijares, I would be remiss not to mention Doug Tucker’s 120-108 scorecard last weekend in favor of Mijares’s foe, Jose Navarro. Boxing writers often decry things as the worst this, the most awful that. Tucker’s scorecard is one of the reasons folks should think twice about such proclamations. That’s because Tucker’s scorecard, in a fight that Mijares clearly won, is by far the worst, most awful, scoring I have ever witnessed. Emanuel Steward mentioned on air that perhaps Tucker got the two fighters confused and that might be the only logical conclusion. Moving on to a mantra…
Go Stevie Go!: The road to September’s proposed Mayweather Beats De La Hoya II is now clearly defined. World Welterweight champion Floyd Mayweather (40-0, 25 KO) will land some more potatoes on a seven-foot tall performance artist at Wrestlemania and Oscar De La Hoya (38-5, 30 KO) will tune up with former Jr. Lightweight titlist and season two Contender finalist Stevie Forbes (33-5, 9 KO). Plans are to air it May 3rd, live, on free-to-subscribers HBO as Oscar’s ‘thank you’ to fans.
Awwww shucks.
Ain’t that swell.
You mean after asking fans to shell out for pay shows over the years like bouts with Yori Boy Campas, Felix Sturm and Javier Castillejo, Oscar’s ready to give back? You mean this has nothing to do with trying to create the impression, on the largest audience possible, that Oscar has a real chance win the rematch with Floyd, thus overcoming at least one objection to charging people twice in the hope that they’ll see a memorable fight once? Of course not; that’s just so cynical.
And boxing doesn’t do cynical. Well, um…
Here’s another question: does anyone really want to see Mayweather Beats De La Hoya II? Read the question twice. It’s not the same question as do the bankers, investors and stock holders involved with the business interests of that fight want to see it. It’s also not the same question as will anyone watch it. Given the marketing muscle and names involved, of course people will watch it. But it’s a lot like taking a man who likes his ladies tall and busty and stranding him on a deserted island with lady midgets.
He doesn’t want to but if that’s the best there is he will.
No, what real boxing fans, and even some casual viewers, really want is Mayweather versus his number one contender, Miguel Cotto (31-0, 25 KO). It might be the best fight in boxing and one that could build a rematch based solely on its merits. If the desire to see Mayweather-Cotto resembles you, loyal reader, than here’s your mantra for the next few months:
Go
Stevie
Go!
Those three words (stop chanting and finish reading please) represent the only opportunity the world has to avert Mayweather Beats De La Hoya II. Is Forbes live against De La Hoya? Probably not; he got the fight after all. He’s a smart professional choice, one who can emulate Mayweather just enough to give Oscar some solid rounds without having any chance of hurting the “Golden Boy.”
That doesn’t mean we can’t hope for something more; that we can’t hope for Forbes to get into a rhythm against a potentially rusty Oscar, start working the jab, landing in combination, and getting the hell out of the way before the incoming comes in. Given that the fight will be in southern California with multi-millions looming in the background, the deck is stacked before we even get to the fact that Forbes, who faltered against a larger but less talented Grady Brewer on the Contender, will be fighting a larger man with equal if not more talent than Forbes has displayed thus far.
Root anyways. Root, if not for Forbes to outright win than to at least make a mess of the scorecards, taking even more of the luster off of the “Really? Again?” being served this fall. It must be said, even if Forbes pulled the huge upset, there’s no guarantee that Floyd and Cotto would get it on. That would only be the best case scenario. At worst and at least it could be stellar fodder for shaming the two of them into actually opening a negotiation. So say it again…
Go
Stevie
Go!
You’re the best chance boxing has to get what it wants over what it will take.
Cliff’s Notes…
The Taylor-Pavlik show dominated most of my thoughts in the days before and just after the bout. If you want to take a look back, feel free:
Pavlik-Taylor Post: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=12670
The T.V. Fights of the Week: https://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=12693
I hope you enjoy reading them as much as I enjoy writing them.
Cliff Rold is a member of the Ring Magazine Ratings Advisory Panel and the Boxing Writers Association of America. He can be reached at roldboxing@hotmail.com